A DIY eye makeup remover & the 5 best store-bought options

A DIY Eye Makeup Remover & The 5 Best Store-Bought Options
See Gallery
A DIY eye makeup remover & the 5 best store-bought options

A beauty industry favorite, this gentle and effective product easily strips off stubborn eyeliner and mascara without any oily residue. 

Get It Here

No rubbing or pulling is needed with this soothing liquid that dissolves eye makeup quickly, leaving skin clean and smooth.

Get It Here  

This lightweight creme-gel formula gentlyeliminates every trace of face, lip and eye makeup and leaves skin extra soft.

Get It Here

Cleansing Gel and Makeup Remover. A variety of natural ingredients work together to not only remove eye makeup, but to create healthy, nourished skin.

Get It Here

This mineral-oil based cream is thick, but does an excellent job of removing eye makeup and other grit from the day. And your face will feel moisturized and velvety.

Get It Here


One of the most important things women can do for themselves is to maintain a daily skin regimen. After all, your skin is your largest organ and can't be replaced. While cleansing and moisturizing come naturally, many women skimp on an integral part of the routine: removing eye makeup. Leaving eye makeup on overnight can result in irritation and even infection.

In our search for the best eye makeup removers, we discovered an easy, DIY solution, thanks to Frugally Sustainable. You need just three ingredients: distilled water, castile soap, and olive oil.
If you'd prefer store-bought eye makeup remover, you have two options. The solution to cutting through heavy eye makeup is an oil-based remover (baby oil and Vaseline are inexpensive alternatives). However, this often leaves an oily residue. And for women with sensitive eyes and skin, this may cause irritation, not to mention a greasy feel. Enter oil-free makeup removers, which are just as effective.

Here are five acclaimed eye makeup removers that have been praised by aestheticians and women searching for the perfect product.

More from Elizabeth Street:
The Best Drugstore Products for Under $10
Coconut Oil is the Must-Have Beauty Product This Winter
The Best Tinted Moisturizer to Bring Some Color Back Into Your Look
The Best Natural Beauty Product for Hair, Skin and Nails
Read Full Story