'I told you so': Dave Ramsey made the correct call on US real estate last year — but is he still right about housing in 2023? Here's what the financial guru is predicting now

Remember the Great Recession? If you do, chances are you don't do so fondly — and if you were heavily involved in real estate, or underwater on a mortgage, then a decade-plus later you may still be licking your wounds.

The complex causes of the subprime mortgage crash of 2008 led to housing prices plummeting by a third, according to the Washington Post. So, if Americans today — what with soaring mortgage rates and high-profile bank failures — feel shaky about the housing market, who can blame them?

Don't miss

• Super-rich Americans are snatching up prime real estate abroad as US housing slumps — but here's a sharp way to invest without having to move overseas

• 36% of millionaires say it’ll ‘take a miracle’ to retire amid rising costs and a shaky market — here are the best shock-proof assets to grow your nest egg

• Warren Buffett gets gloomy: America's 'incredible period' is coming to an end. Here's what nervous investors can do right now

Well, Dave Ramsey for one.

Say what you want about the guy, but when he ventures a prediction connected to consumer finance, he’s often on target — sometimes with frightening precision. During a recent episode of The Ramsey Show, he had a few choice words for Americans who fear a repeat of 15 years ago.

“We predicted exactly what would happen,” Ramsey said. “We were using data, not emotions to actually figure out what was going on.”

Ramsey was referring to a livestream special he hosted on July 14, 2022, in which he spent an hour explaining the details of the the housing situation and why the market was not headed for a 2008-style crash.

The biggest difference between then and now? While interest rates continue to rise, he says today there’s a “dramatic” shortage in terms of housing inventory. Here’s what that means.

National shortage on affordable housing

The National Low Income Housing Coalition found in a recent study that there’s a national shortage of 7.3 million affordable and available rental homes for extremely low-income renters. That’s Americans at or below the federal poverty line, 30% lower than the median income.

It’s important to note that’s only for those in extreme poverty.

More broadly speaking, Realtor.com found slightly better results, with a 6.5 million shortage of single family homes overall. That’s even as prices dropped slightly during the latter half of 2022.

Meanwhile, the number of prime buyers in 2008 (Gen Xers) totalled 55 million versus 66 million prime buyers today (millennials), as Ramsey pointed out during the livestream.

The overall housing shortage continues to keep real estate demand up across the country. And so long as demand outpaces supply, higher home prices will result. (Clever homeowners can leverage this by selling their property in a hot market and moving to an area with more plentiful inventory and lower prices.)

As those two factors converged in the pandemic, Ramsey says panic set in.

“Everyone’s going, ‘Oh, it’s all going to go away! It’s all going to be another 2008!’ We kept saying, ‘No it’s not, it’s not going to bust,’” Ramsey recently recalled on his show.

“I think we can just stop and say I told you so.”

That being said, Ramsey does think the market has slowed down. Indeed, after median home prices peaked at $449,000 in June 2022, they dropped to $400,000 by January 2023, according to data from Realtor.com. That was a dip of about 10% — yet nowhere near the 33% tumble seen in the 2008 housing crash.

But go figure: As of July the median home price is $440,000, down slightly from $445,000 in June. That’s a decline of 2% from June 2022 — definitely not a crash, let alone a sign one is on the way.

Read more: This janitor in Vermont built an $8M fortune without anyone around him knowing. Here are the 2 simple techniques that made Ronald Read rich — and can do the same for you

Temper your expectations

So, homeowners looking to sell can take heart. On the one hand, the days of receiving dozens of offers in one weekend, sight unseen, are gone. Ramsey contends that sellers will have to stage, clean up and work on the curb appeal of their homes to sell for a good price.

Assessing the market heat up during the pandemic, Ramsey says “that was an anomaly.”

“That was a short period of time … when everyone sat around in their house and got fat and decided they wanted to move out of their house. There was a shortage of lumber, lumber when up 3x, it’s back down, and builders are not building specs right now. They’ve slowed down and they’re adding to this shortage.”

Ramsey and his team had predicted that after the recent drop there would be a 2% to 3% increase in the value of homes this year. But as they note on the show, this is in home value — not asking price.

“It’s not people buying like they’ve lost their dadgum minds. This is reasonable people buying properties at reasonable prices,” Ramsey said.

Prepare for higher mortgage rates

As for mortgages, Ramsey notes that we may never again see those 2% or 3% mortgage rates of the recent past. Instead, Americans will need to level-set their expectations to a norm of 6%.

“The only reason it was driven down below 6% was the government artificially [did it] to restimulate the real estate market after 2008,” Ramsey said.

All said and done, Ramsey and his team stated may check in on their predictions more often — if only to say “I told you so.”

“We completely nailed that,” he said. “[We] looked at the data and we hammered it. We nailed it.”

And when it comes to housing, a hammer and a nail beats getting hammered and nail biting every time.

What to read next

• How can I stop the pain and make money in this nightmarish market? Here's 1 simple way you can protect your nest egg

• Jeff Bezos and Oprah Winfrey invest in this asset to keep their wealth safe — you may want to do the same in 2023

• Here's how much money the average middle-class American household makes — how do you stack up?

This article provides information only and should not be construed as advice. It is provided without warranty of any kind.