The Only Frozen Pizza You Should Be Buying from the Grocery Store

Cheesy Pepperoni Pizza Pull

The People Have Spoken.

Frozen pizzas are a staple of many level-headed and passionate pizza aficionados alike. It could be a quiet and calm, self-care-fueled night in which you find yourself reading by aromatic candlelight only to realize that in the last few minutes, you've been possessed by an all-consuming urge to consume an entire frozen pizza.

Or, you could've had a late night on the town that left you clamoring to retain a grip on the face of the earth itself, and in dire need of some form of reasonable sustenance.

This is where frozen pizzas come into play. And you better believe that not all frozen pizzas are packing the same flavor profile and value. Thankfully, this Reddit thread seeks to crown a winner of the bunch.

Reddit screenshot of a Torino's Party Pizza box.

Maybe, The Golden Standard.

"Totino's party pizzas are a disgusting mess and I love them. I'm pretty sure the first ingredient is chemicals, but it reminds me of being a poor kid when my mom would lovingly slap some American cheese slices on top and serve it up hot."

– u/nothingbutM via Reddit

Reddit screenshot of a Tombstone frozen pizza.

Because It's Tough To Top A Tombstone Pie.

"I really like the Screaming Sicilian holy pepperoni. It is like a Tombstone pizza with better quality toppings and sauce. Their Stromboli are also really good."

– u/suraklin via Reddit

Reddit screenshot of Freschetta frozen pizza.

You're Not Alone Freschetta Fans.


– u/Flairion623 via Reddit

Reddit screenshot of Minnesota's famous frozen pizza, Heggies.

It Would Seem That Minnesota Is Calling.

"Heggies, sold in Minnesota."

– u/kay37815 via Reddit

For more delicious recommendations, sign up for our free newsletters.

Reddit screenshot of a Motor City Deep Dish frozen pizza.

These Best Never Flee The Shelves.

"Motor city deep dish. Not expensive but so good!"

– u/Okay_Willingness_784 via Reddit

(Motor City also happens to be one of the best frozen pizzas at Costco.)

Reddit screenshot of a Red Baron frozen pizza.

These Are Just Classic.

"Red Baron all the way."

– u/WakeMeForSourPatch via Reddit

(See how these Redditor favorites stack up against our in-house taste test to find the best frozen pizza.)

Reddit screenshot of a frozen pizza from Home Run Inn.

Chicago Doesn't Play Around With Their Pizza.

"Home Run Inn. Everything else tastes like a factory."

– u/blackcurrents78 via Reddit

And as a quick follow-up, u/hindermore further confirms there could be something here:

"I have been getting these lately and I am convinced these are the best frozen pizza. I have tried lots of brands over the years but Home Run Inn has been the most satisfying by far. Toppings stay in place, cheese is nice and thick, plenty of meat on the meat lovers, crust is tasty. When you get the plain cheese, it has extra cheese on it. It is also good reheated. It’s a bit pricier than some of the other options but worth it in my opinion. Tons of calories in those things."

YouTube screenshot of someone reviewing Wild Mike's frozen pizza.

Mike Is Wilding Out These Days, And Apparently That's A Good Thing.


– u/Yeahgeebs via Reddit

Yeah, so it apparently could barely fit in the oven. Best take preliminary measures in that case.

"Yea Wild Mikes! I got to try this when I was in Montana a couple of years ago. 5 bucks and it barely fit in the oven it was so big. Came with seasoning and tasted freakin great."

– u/jack_geller via Reddit

Reddit screenshot of Jack's frozen pizza.

Let's Hear It For Jack's.

"Some of the happiest days of my life genuinely include getting back to my apartment in undergrad, throwing one of them things in the oven for 11 minutes, and eating the entire thing in one sitting like an animal."

– u/LarrcasM via Reddit

Reddit screenshot of a Doctor Oetker's frozen pizza.

A Guilt-Free Pie, It's On The Doc's Orders.

" - it's cheese, bacon and kale. The cheese and bacon are for taste, the kale is to make me feel like I'm eating vegetables without actually really tasting like it."

– u/sqwidsqwad via Reddit

This article was originally published on Cheapism

Cheesy Pepperoni Pizza Pull

More From Cheapism