Welcome to the Club, Tea Party: Previous Political IRS Scandals

Former IRS Commissioner Douglas Shulman, talks with others during a recess from his testimony before a Senate Finance Committee hearing on Capitol Hill in Washington, District of Columbia, U.S., on Tuesday, May 21, 2013. The committee was holding hearing about the criteria used by the IRS to identify 501(c)(4) applications for greater scrutiny. Photographer: Pete Marovich/Bloomberg
Pete Marovich/BloombergFormer IRS Commissioner Douglas Shulman (middle), talks with others during a recess from his testimony before a Senate Finance Committee hearing.
The IRS-Tea Party scandal continues to unspool, with former IRS Commissioner Douglas Shulman telling the Senate Finance Committee on Tuesday that he learned of the improper political targeting in the spring of 2012, but told neither senior Treasury officials nor members of Congress.

Republican senators didn't sound convinced, according to the Associated Press:

"It's just implausible to me," Sen. John Cornyn, R-Texas, said in an interview after the hearing. "Bureaucrats don't take risks by doing things that they know will get them fired, or get them disciplined by their superiors."

Sen. John Thune, R-S.D., said, "It's just hard to figure that there isn't more to this than they are letting on."

"How much did the political calendar influence when they disclosed this?" Thune said. "Obviously it was a presidential election year. Disclosure of something like this would have been explosive."

Explosive, perhaps, but not in fact surprising, given the history of the IRS. The nation's revenue collecting agency has been dogged by accusations of corruption, and cyclically consumed by efforts at reform, since the institution of an income tax to raise funds for the Civil War. And politically motivated uses of the agency's powers are far from unheard of.

Sponsored Links
So were politics at play in this most recent targeting? It appears we won't find anything out from IRS official Lois Lerner, a career civil servant who has headed the tax-exempt organizations division at the heart of the brouhaha since 2005. Various news organizations have reported that she is taking the Fifth and will refuse to testify before Congress because of the Justice Department's ongoing criminal investigation.

Meanwhile, the House Ways and Means Committee has just set up a website to solicit information from citizens connected to what it calls "The IRS Political Discrimination Investigation." ("Your story is critical to moving the investigation forward. Taking a few minutes to fill out the form below and share your story will allow the Committee to identify key facts and take action to deal with the failures of the IRS.") Dulling the partisan edge of the story somewhat is the fact that Shulman was appointed commissioner by President George W. Bush.

But special scrutiny of right-wing groups under a Democratic president during an election season is obviously suspicious, and there's precedent for skullduggery at the IRS. Here, with a hat tip to Slate and Time, are some lowlights of the agency's last hundred years.

Welcome to the Club, Tea Party: A Brief History of IRS Scandals
See Gallery
Welcome to the Club, Tea Party: Previous Political IRS Scandals

In 1924, Treasury Secretary Andrew Mellon, one of the country's wealthiest men, was feuding with Sen. James Couzens (R-Mich.), said to be the richest member of Congress. Couzens wound up being sued by the Bureau of Internal Revenue, precursor to the IRS, over a tax bill of between $10 million and $11 million on a sale of Ford Motor Co. (F) stock -- an amount approximately equivalent to $140 million today. The result was a power struggle between Congress and the administration of Calvin Coolidge, which led to the creation of the U.S. Joint Committee on Taxation. The Washington Post dubbed the affair "the greatest tax suit in the history of the world."

Photo: President Calvin Coolidge (Left) and Sen. James Couzens (right in glasses).

Under the Kennedy administration, the IRS targeted right-wing political groups for audits; the stated purpose was to determine whether such groups were abusing their tax-exempt status, but the bias of the effort was obvious, despite superficial attempts to disguise it. "By the end of 1964 the Ideological Organizations Project had led to recommendation of the revocation of exempt status for 15 groups (14 of them right-wing)," reports John A. Andrew in The Other Side of the Sixties. "The IRS eventually approved four of the recommendations for continued action (3 right-wing groups), rejecting the rest or sending them back for further study." The project remained secret from the public until the Church Committee hearings in the mid-1970s.
I hope you're sitting down, because it turns out that the power of the IRS was abused under President Richard Nixon. In a reverse of the Ideological Organizations Project, a White House aide named Tom Charles Huston -- who had been president of Young Americans for Freedom, one of the groups on the Kennedy administration's radar -- suggested investigating left-wing groups with tax-exempt status, and Dick could dig it. Huston also proposed using electronic surveillance and burglary against left-wing "radicals" and antiwar types, so he was Nixon's kind of guy. (Amazingly, J. Edgar Hoover objected to Huston's proposals.) Nixon pressed for the creation of something called the Special Services Staff, the purpose of which was to use the IRS against his "enemies." Unlawful applications of IRS power were part of the articles of impeachment drafted against our uncrookiest president by the House of Representatives.

Worse than Watergate, but significantly less well-known, is a 15-year FBI program directed against domestic political groups deemed "subversive." It was called COINTELPRO, and the IRS was one of its tools of attack. Members of the New Left, black activists, antiwar figures and other dissidents were targeted for audits, and the IRS handed over 200 tax returns for investigatory purposes in a manner deemed illegal in 1968.

Photo: Fred Hampton, national spokesman for the Black Panther Party, who was killed by members of the Chicago Police Department, as part of a COINTELPRO operation.

In a 2001 paper titled "The Political Economy of the IRS," researchers reported that data for 33 IRS districts from 1992 to 1997 showed significantly lower audit rates in electorally important districts, as well as those represented by members of important congressional committees. "These findings suggest that the IRS is not a rogue government agency, but rather is an effective bureaucratic agent of its political sponsors," the authors note drily. "'Reforming' the IRS by subjecting it to an independent oversight board appointed by the president would therefore seem to be redundant."
After a guest preacher denounced George W. Bush's Iraq policy in a 2004 sermon delivered at All Saints Church in Pasadena, Calif., the IRS began an inquiry into the congregation's tax-exempt status the following year. The church hired Marcus Owens, a former head of the IRS tax-exempt section, to represent it. Owens said the IRS's contention that the church had implicitly intervened in the election "seems ludicrous." The church was eventually able to keep its 501(c)3 status. "I'm very interested to know whether the IRS is taking a look only at churches that are critical of the war in Iraq, or also at the churches that are supportive of the war and the president," the rector told The Washington Post. IRS Commissioner Mark W. Everson (pictured above) said, "There is absolutely no place for any politics in our consideration of these things."
Read Full Story
  • DJI28195.42-410.89-1.44%
  • NIKKEI 22523671.13260.501.11%
    Hang Seng24542.26155.470.64%
  • USD (PER EUR)1.180.00470.40%
    USD (PER CHF)1.100.00600.55%
    JPY (PER USD)105.420.03100.03%
    GBP (PER USD)1.300.00410.32%

From Our Partners