Don’t Waste Money: Avoid These 10 Costly Mistakes When Refinancing Your Mortgage

Prostock-Studio / Getty Images
Prostock-Studio / Getty Images

Refinancing your mortgage has the potential to save you thousands in interest payments, but it can also drain your wallet if you’re not careful. From buried prepayment penalties to unnecessary closing costs, the refinancing process is riddled with financial pitfalls you need to avoid. Make one wrong move and you could squander your potential savings while lining the pockets of lenders and brokers.

Be Aware: 5 Types of Homes That Will Plummet in Value in 2024
Try This: 7 Unusual Ways To Make Extra Money (That Actually Work)

In this article, we’ll outline the most common and costly mistakes homeowners make when refinancing their mortgage — hidden fees and fine print included. Arm yourself with knowledge so you can navigate the refi process successfully and lock in major savings your bank account will thank you for. Let’s review where other borrowers go wrong so you can go into your own refinance with eyes wide open.

Not Knowing Your Credit Score

Matt Stevens, home financing expert and CEO of The Mortgage Genie, said it’s not uncommon to find that a customer did not realize that their score changed since they received their initial mortgage loan.

“One of the main steps when buying a house is to make sure that your credit score is spot on,” he said. “A higher score means your application will more likely be accepted, and lenders will offer you better rates because you are low risk — and this applies to home refinance too.”

Read Next: ​ChatGPT Unveils: 5 Worst Cities to Buy a House in 2024

Not Talking To an Experienced Loan Officer

“There are a lot of internet/call center lenders out there that do offer good rates,” said Tony Grech, a licensed mortgage loan officer. “But you are just a number to them and they are often simply there to take orders rather than advise you on the best program options you qualify for. You want a 30- year fixed? Sure, Mr. Customer, here you go. Now on to the next one.”

He continued, “But a true professional is going to take the time to get to know you and your unique situation, your goals etc. and is going to provide custom recommendations. They are going to get into the discussion and comparison of interest rates and the costs associated with getting each rate. They are going to explain the pros and cons of a 30-year loan vs. a 20 or 15, and are going to educate you so that you can make the best decision for you.”

Not Choosing the Right Mortgage Product

“In our current environment, especially, it is good to make sure you are choosing the correct and most efficient mortgage product,” said D. Shane Whitteker, owner and chief broker of Principle Home Mortgage.

“There are a lot of people that have used an FHA mortgage in the past that may qualify for a conventional loan currently, and possibly remove mortgage insurance or drastically improve the mortgage insurance terms. VA is a great option as well and I find that some veterans end up using different loan programs that are not as beneficial to the veteran. It is also good to consider streamline refinance options that are offered by FHA and VA. The FHA program is called a ‘streamline’ refinance. The VA program is called an ‘IRRRL’ which stands for interest rate reduction refinance loan.”

I’m a Real Estate Agent: 12 Costly Red Flags I Look for During a Home Inspection

Not Shopping Around

“The most common mistake I see for borrowers who are eager to refinance their home loan [is that] they stick with the bank they are familiar with,” said Leonard Ang, CEO at iPropertyManagement.

“Although you may be comfortable with banks and terms you are familiar with, it can pay big time to shop around for other lenders whose rates may be even better, thus saving you thousands of dollars down the line. Do not be afraid to browse for lenders until you are confident and comfortable with your choice.”

Refinancing for the Same Length of Time as Your Previous Loan

“One of the biggest mistakes I see homeowners making is trying to refinance for the same length of time,” said John Li, co-founder and CTO of the financial lending company Fig Loans.

“If you initially financed for a 25-year mortgage, you shouldn’t refinance 10 years later for another 25-year mortgage — you’ll end up paying off your mortgage well into your golden years, and paying far more in interest than you should. Instead, look to refinance your mortgage at a better rate for a shorter-term loan that closely resembles the remaining time on your mortgage.”

Ignoring How Long You Plan To Live in the Home

“Interest rates are near historic lows but that doesn’t automatically mean it is a good idea for everyone to refinance their mortgage,” said Brian Walsh, senior manager and CFP at SoFi.

“You should do a break-even analysis to make sure refinancing is the right move. This can be as simple as dividing your total closing costs associated with the refinancing by your reduction in monthly payments. Then compare that breakeven period with how long you plan to live in the home. If you plan on selling the home before your break-even point, then it might not be the best idea.”

Getting Other Loans While Refinancing

“Do not apply for other loans, like credit cards, cars, boats, etc.,” said Realtor Khari Washington. “Applying for other loans can lower your credit score and also makes mortgage underwriters nervous. Lenders recheck your credit before closing a loan, and they will catch other loans. Those loans could get your deal denied. Wait till your loan is closed.”

Going With a Lender That Underestimates Your Taxes and Insurance Costs

Washington said sometimes lenders do this to make your closing costs look lower.

“When looking at an estimate, do not include your taxes and insurance in your calculations,” he said. “No matter what lender you use, those fees will be the same, even if one lender wants to quote them for less to make their deal look better.”

Focusing on the Rate and Not the Closing Costs

“Lenders may quote a low rate by raising the closing costs for a loan,” Washington said. “If a lender beats a quote you received from another lender by raising the closing costs, the loan might not be cheaper. If lender A quotes 3% with no closing costs and lender B quoted 2.875% with $6,000 in closing costs, you are paying a lot of money for a .125% difference in rate. In addition, lender A might have given a 2.875% interest rate for less closing costs than lender B. Always look at how much you have to pay for a rate.”

Using Home Equity Too Freely

“It can be tempting to use home equity to tackle home improvement projects or even buy big ticket items that you have always wanted,” Walsh said. “Before succumbing to that temptation, think about the long-term impact of tapping into your home equity. You should still evaluate the ROI of home improvement projects even if you are using home equity.”

Laura Beck contributed to the reporting for this article.

More From GOBankingRates

This article originally appeared on GOBankingRates.com: Don’t Waste Money: Avoid These 10 Costly Mistakes When Refinancing Your Mortgage

Advertisement