Feds: Ex-Warren cop pleads guilty in beating of suspect in city jail

A former Warren police officer will be sentenced in federal court in August, more than a year after authorities said he was caught on video punching a suspect in the city jail and slamming his head onto a floor.

Matthew Rodriguez, 49, pleaded guilty Monday in U.S. District Court to one count of deprivation of rights under color of law, a felony, in the June 13 assault.

Federal prosecutors will move to dismiss a charge of falsification of records if the court accepts Rodriguez's plea, according to court documents. Rodriguez is to be sentenced Aug. 20, with federal authorities saying he faces a maximum penalty of 10 years in prison.

A former Warren police officer was charged in U.S. District Court after assaulting an arrested suspect in the city jail booking area on June 13, 2023.
A former Warren police officer was charged in U.S. District Court after assaulting an arrested suspect in the city jail booking area on June 13, 2023.

Steve Fishman, an attorney for Rodriguez, had no comment Tuesday.

Rodriguez was terminated June 26. Former Warren Police Commissioner William Dwyer previously called the assault on Jaquwan Smith "unjustified" after an internal investigation. The assault was captured on video.

'Police officers are not above the law'

Federal authorities said Rodriguez used excessive force while fingerprinting and photographing the suspect.

"This police officer carried out a violent assault on a man who was doing nothing to harm or endanger him and then tried to cover up his crime," Assistant Attorney General Kristen Clarke of the Justice Department's Civil Rights Division said in a news release.

"Police officers are not above the law in our country and will be held accountable when they violate people's civil and constitutional rights. When law enforcement abuses their authority, it erodes trust between the police and the community they are sworn to protect and serve."

Federal authorities stated that after Rodriguez took Smith's fingerprints, he struck him multiple times and slammed his head against the floor, causing injury.

"When Rodriguez began to assault him, J.S. was not physically resisting Rodriguez and posed no immediate threat to anyone," according to their release, which identified Smith by the initials J.S.

It stated that during the plea hearing, Rodriguez admitted that he knew his use of force was unreasonable and contrary to department policy and that he wrote a report in which he made false statements about the incident and omitted material information.

A complaint filed in federal court last year stated that the victim was provided with medical care for swelling and bruising in the area to the right side of his nose and that Rodriguez caused injury to the victim's face, including bleeding and swelling visible in photographs taken by Warren police after the assault.

City faces lawsuit over incident

Dwyer previously said he reviewed Rodriguez's personnel file after this incident and found at least two older instances of excessive force and prior discipline against Rodriguez, but he declined to comment on the details.

Rodriguez, of Southgate, had been with Warren police for more than 14 years at the time of the June assault.

Smith filed a federal lawsuit — seeking $50 million — against Rodriguez, the city and two other officers. The lawsuit is ongoing.

Dwyer previously said Smith had been arrested just before 5 a.m. June 13, and the booking officer — Rodriguez — took custody of him a little over an hour later.

In video released June 20, Rodriguez is seen seated at a desk with a computer in the city lockup. Smith stands nearby, not handcuffed. Rodriguez gets up and walks over to him. It appears words are exchanged, but there is no audio. Dwyer did not know what the men said to each other.

In the video, Rodriguez strikes Smith with his right hand, pushes him against a wall and takes him to the floor.

Within seconds, two other officers are seen entering the room. Rodriguez punches Smith and slams his head against the floor, the video footage shows.

Rodriguez picks up Smith, apparently by his hair or clothing, holds him and eventually walks him to a cell, pushing or throwing him inside. The video shows Smith falling onto the floor, with Rodriguez shutting the cell door and walking away.

Dwyer said the two officers intervened in the incident, which happened in less than one minute, then reported it to supervisors that day, launching an internal investigation and Rodriguez being placed on leave before he was terminated.

Smith faces a Sept. 24 trial in Macomb County Circuit Court on charges stemming from his June 13 arrest: armed robbery, assaulting/resisting/obstructing a police officer, breaking and entering a vehicle, a felony firearms offense and carrying a concealed weapon.

Contact Christina Hall: chall@freepress.com. Follow her on Twitter: @challreporter.

Support local journalism. Subscribe to the Free Press.

Submit a letter to the editor at freep.com/letters.

This article originally appeared on Detroit Free Press: Feds: Ex-Warren cop to be sentenced in beating of suspect in city jail

Advertisement