Coverdell ESA vs. 529: Which Is Better for You?
College tuition has skyrocketed by over 179% in the last two decades, going up 9% per year on average. As education costs continue to rise, securing your child’s future through an educational savings plan becomes more critical. Coverdell ESAs and 529 plans are two popular tax-advantaged education savings accounts designed to help families save for these expenses. Understanding their benefits and eligibility requirements can help you make the most of these powerful savings tools. Read on to learn about the following:
Trending Now: 5 Genius Things All Wealthy People Do With Their Money
Understanding the Key Differences
Both Coverdell ESAs and 529 plans offer significant benefits for educational savings, including tax advantages and the ability to cover a wide range of educational costs. However, there are key differences between them that can help you decide which plan is right for you and maximize the value of your savings.
Ownership and Beneficiaries
Coverdell accounts and 529 plans have a custodian (the person who opened the account) and a beneficiary (the person who receives the money saved in it). You can change the beneficiary of either account at any time without penalty, an option that’s useful if you want to use the account for more than one child.
The beneficiary of a Coverdell account must be under the age of 30 and a family member — including step-siblings, first cousins and spouses. 529 plans do not have an age restriction, which means you can make anyone the beneficiary — even the owner.
Contribution Limits: Coverdell ESA vs. 529 Plans
Coverdell education savings accounts have an annual contribution limit of $2,000 per beneficiary, a relatively low limit that can be restrictive for families aiming to save large amounts for education or for those who get a late start.
In contrast, 529 plans offer much higher contribution limits, often exceeding $300,000 per beneficiary, depending on state regulations. These higher limits make 529 plans more suitable for families looking to invest substantial amounts for future educational expenses and those who have less time to save.
Additionally, 529 plans do not impose income restrictions on contributors, allowing anyone to contribute. On the other hand, Coverdell ESAs restrict full contributions to individuals with a modified adjusted gross income below $110,000 for single filers or $220,000 for joint filers. These differences in contribution limits and eligibility make 529 plans a more flexible option for long-term educational savings.
Tax Benefits: Coverdell ESA vs. 529 Plans
Both of these accounts allow contributions to grow tax-free — unlike investment products subject to capital gains tax. Even though contributions to both types of accounts are not tax-deductible, tax-free growth significantly enhances their value.
Withdrawals for qualified educational expenses are also tax-exempt in both accounts, but the list of qualified education expenses differs slightly between the two. Here are some key points to know:
Coverdell ESAs offer the flexibility to use funds for a broader range of educational expenses, including K-12 education and higher education costs like tuition, books, supplies, and even computers and internet access.
529 plans primarily focus on college expenses but also cover up to $10,000 per year in K-12 tuition.
Non-qualified withdrawals from either account are subject to income tax on the earnings portion and an additional 10% penalty, underscoring the importance of using the funds for their intended educational purposes.
Investment Options
When comparing the investment options of Coverdell ESAs vs. 529 plans, significant differences in flexibility and management arise.
Coverdell ESAs provide a high degree of self-directed investment flexibility, allowing account holders to choose from a broad range of options, including stocks, bonds, mutual funds, ETFs and certificates of deposit. This enables investors to tailor their portfolios according to their financial goals and risk tolerance.
In contrast, 529 plans typically offer professionally managed investment choices, with options often limited to a selection of mutual funds and age-based portfolios that automatically adjust asset allocation as the beneficiary nears college age. While this can simplify investment decisions and reduce the need for active management, it also means less control over specific investment choices.
These differences highlight that Coverdell ESAs are suited for those who prefer a hands-on approach to investing, whereas 529 plans appeal to those seeking a more streamlined, professionally managed solution.
Flexibility and Qualified Expenses
Coverdell ESAs offer broader flexibility in qualified expenses, covering not only higher education costs but also K-12 expenses, including tuition, books, supplies, and even computers and internet access. This makes Coverdell ESAs highly versatile for families with diverse educational needs.
On the other hand, 529 plans primarily cover post-secondary education expenses but can also be used for up to $10,000 per year in K-12 tuition. 529 plans offer significant flexibility in contributions, with no income restrictions on contributors — anyone can contribute regardless of their federal tax bracket. They also have higher overall contribution limits, often exceeding $300,000 per beneficiary. Additionally, 529 plans allow for rollovers to an IRA or other family members without tax penalties, providing a flexible way to adapt to changing educational needs.
These features make Coverdell ESAs ideal for broad educational expenses, while 529 plans offer robust flexibility in funding and beneficiary management.
Qualified Expenses and Restrictions
Here’s a detailed look at the types of educational costs these accounts can cover.
What Can You Use a Coverdell ESA For?
Coverdell education savings accounts provide a versatile way to save for a wide range of educational expenses. Here’s a list of qualified expenses you can cover with a Coverdell ESA:
K-12 tuition and fees: Payments for elementary and secondary school tuition and related fees at public, private or religious schools.
Books and supplies: Costs for textbooks, workbooks and other necessary educational materials.
Computers and technology: Expenses for purchasing computers, peripheral equipment, internet access and related services if used primarily by the beneficiary during school.
Special needs services: Expenses for special needs services for a beneficiary with special needs, including therapies and educational aids.
Post-secondary education: Tuition, fees, books, supplies and equipment required for enrollment or attendance at an eligible post-secondary institution.
Room and board: For students enrolled at least half-time in a post-secondary institution, expenses for room and board are covered.
What Can You Use a 529 Plan For?
A 529 plan offers tax-advantaged savings for a variety of educational expenses, primarily focusing on higher education costs. Qualified expenses for 529 plans include:
College tuition and fees: Payments for tuition and mandatory fees at eligible post-secondary institutions.
Room and board: Costs for housing and meal plans for students enrolled at least half-time. This includes both on-campus housing and, within certain limits, off-campus living expenses.
Books and supplies: Expenses for textbooks, supplies and equipment necessary for courses.
Computers and technology: The cost of purchasing computers, software and internet access if used primarily by the student during their time in school.
Recent legislation updates have expanded the scope of 529 plans, potentially including apprenticeships and student loan repayments as qualified expenses. This broadening of eligible uses makes 529 plans an even more flexible tool for educational savings.
Impact on Financial Aid
Both Coverdell ESAs and 529 plans can impact a student’s financial aid eligibility, as they can be treated as assets. This treatment can be beneficial because parental assets are assessed at a lower rate, up to 5.64%, compared to student assets, up to 20%, when calculating the expected family contribution for financial aid purposes. Consequently, funds in a Coverdell ESA or 529 plan have a less significant impact on financial aid eligibility than if they were held directly in the student’s name.
Strategies To Minimize Financial Aid Impact
Ownership structure: Keep the account in the parent’s name rather than the student’s to reduce its impact on the EFC.
Timing of withdrawals: Since student assets have a greater impact on the EFC for financial aid, it’s helpful to spend assets held in the student’s name before those owned by the parent.
Coordination with other aid: Coordinate the use of Coverdell ESA and 529 plan funds with other financial aid packages to avoid reducing need-based aid.
State Benefits and Scholarships With 529 Plans
529 plans offer significant state tax benefits, making them an attractive option for education savings. Many states provide tax deductions or credits for contributions to their state’s 529 plan, allowing families to reduce their state income tax liability and increase their potential tax refund. These benefits vary by state, with some offering deductions of up to $10,000 or more per year for contributions. It’s essential to check your state’s specific rules to maximize these tax advantages.
In addition to state tax benefits, 529 plans also provide opportunities for free financial aid. Some states offer matching grants or scholarships to incentivize saving in a 529 plan. These programs can provide additional funds that enhance the value of your education savings, easing the financial burden of college expenses.
A key advantage of 529 plans is their portability. Funds saved in a 529 plan can be used at any eligible institution nationwide, regardless of the state in which the plan was opened. This means that even if you save in your home state’s 529 plan and receive state tax benefits, your child can use those funds to attend college out of state without penalty.
Taxes and Penalties for Early Withdrawals
Withdrawing funds from a Coverdell ESA or 529 plan for non-qualified education expenses can result in significant tax implications and penalties. The earnings portion of the withdrawal is subject to federal income tax, and an additional 10% penalty is imposed to discourage the misuse of these tax-advantaged accounts. For both Coverdell ESAs and 529 plans, it is key to use the funds for qualified education expenses, such as tuition, books, and room and board, to avoid these financial repercussions.
Smart Investment Strategies for Educational Savings
Implementing smart investment strategies for educational savings involves considering several key factors such as time horizon, risk tolerance and financial goals. For families with young children, a longer time horizon allows for a more aggressive investment strategy, focusing on stocks and growth-oriented mutual funds that offer higher potential returns. As the beneficiary approaches college age, gradually shifting to a more conservative investment mix, emphasizing bonds and money market funds, can help preserve capital and reduce risk.
By spreading investments across various asset classes — such as stocks, bonds and mutual funds — families can protect their savings from market volatility. Using diversified mutual funds or ETFs can simplify this process and provide a balanced approach to growth and risk management.
Age-appropriate asset allocation is another useful strategy. Many 529 plans offer age-based portfolios that automatically adjust the investment mix as the beneficiary gets closer to college age. These portfolios become more conservative over time, reducing exposure to high-risk assets and focusing on capital preservation. This hands-off approach ensures that the investment strategy aligns with the changing needs and time horizon of the beneficiary.
Coverdell ESA vs. 529 Plan: Which One Is Right for You?
Choosing between a Coverdell ESA and a 529 plan depends on your specific financial situation and educational savings goals. Here’s a comparison of key factors to help you make an informed decision:
Feature | Coverdell ESA | 529 Plan |
|---|---|---|
Contribution Limit | Lower — $2,000 per year per beneficiary | Higher — often exceeding $300,000 depending on the state |
Income Eligibility | Phase-outs for full contributions — MAGI below $110,000 for single filers, $220,000 for joint filers | No income limits |
Investment Options | More flexibility, self-directed in some cases | Managed investment choices, including age-based portfolios |
Qualified Expenses | Broader range includes K-12 expenses like tuition, books, supplies, computers and special needs services | Primarily college costs, with some K-12 limitations — up to $10,000 per year for K-12 tuition |
State Tax Benefits | No | Potential state tax deductions and free financial aid opportunities |
If your priority is flexibility in investment choices and covering a broad range of educational expenses, including K-12, a Coverdell ESA might be the better option. However, if you need higher contribution limits and want to take advantage of state tax benefits and scholarships, a 529 plan could be more suitable.
How To Open an ESA or 529 Plan
You can follow these steps to open your new account:
Research and compare plans: Use online resources to compare different Coverdell ESA and 529 plan options, focusing on fees, investment choices and state benefits.
Choose a financial institution: Select a bank, brokerage or mutual fund company that offers the plan you’ve chosen.
Complete the application: Fill out the necessary application forms, providing information about the account owner, beneficiary and your investment selections.
Fund the account: Make your initial contribution by transferring funds from your bank account.
Monitor and adjust: Regularly review your account’s performance and make adjustments to your investment strategy as needed.
FAQ
Here are the answers to some of the most frequently asked questions regarding Coverdell ESAs vs. 529 plans.
What are the disadvantages of a Coverdell ESA?
Compared to other education savings options, Coverdell ESAs have lower contribution limits. You also cannot open this type of account if your income exceeds the annual threshold -- $110,000 for a single filer and $220,000 for joint filers in 2024.
Can Coverdell be used for a private school?
Yes, you can use the funds in a Coverdell to pay for qualified K-12 expenses, which includes private schools.
Should I use a Coverdell or a 529 account first?
Choosing which account to use first depends on your circumstances. For some people, it makes sense to start withdrawing from a Coverdell first because all funds must be distributed when the beneficiary turns 30. Consider Coverdell first to maximize K-12 benefits if applicable.
Can you have both a 529 plan and a Coverdell account?
Yes, you can have both a 529 plan and Coverdell ESA as long as you meet the income requirements for Coverdell and are opening the account for a child under the age of 18.
Information is accurate as of May 22, 2024.
This article originally appeared on GOBankingRates.com: Coverdell ESA vs. 529: Which Is Better for You?
