How companies can crack the brand trust code

Tom Werner—Getty Images

Brands are looking over their shoulder these days. With consumer trust on the decline, annual trust rankings and barometers remind companies that they also face a skeptical new generation. Oh, and don’t forget growing expectations to do good.

For brands that want people to trust them, shrugging off those social changes is foolhardy. But can they cut through the noise? Are there any universal principles that help build a solid foundation of trust, leaving a brand less reactive to, say, the whims of Gen Z?

Yes, according to Daryl Travis, founder and CEO of brand research and strategy agency Brandtrust. “Trust is created by making and keeping promises,” says Travis, noting that his Chicago-based firm draws on social and behavioral science. For him, brand trust boils down to three elements. The first is connection: This brand is for people like me. Second is consistency—the customer experience and how the brand is living up to its promises.

Third—and most crucial—is care. “The brand always has the customer’s back,” says Travis, whose client list spans FedEx, General Electric, and Pfizer. “The care is where the emotion and the feeling comes into it,” he adds. “That’s when trust really starts to take root.”

Care helps explain why Band-Aid, Lysol, and Kleenex occupy three of the top five U.S. spots in Morning Consult’s latest Most Trusted Brands ranking. “You trust them because they’re part of your insurance, if you will, in a brand sense, for quality of life,” says Kevin Lane Keller, professor of marketing at Dartmouth College’s Tuck School of Business.

Trust is just one dimension of a brand’s credibility, along with expertise and likability, Keller notes. “Expertise and trust are kind of core,” says the author of the influential Strategic Brand Management: Building, Measuring, and Managing Brand Equity. “Are you good at what you do? And do you have my interests in mind?”

Another driver of trust is frequent use. “When you use products a lot, you have a chance to see if they work,” observes Keller, an adviser to marketers for the likes of American Express, Intel, and Nike. By earning trust over time, a brand gains stability.

Apple is a brand trust standout for Travis, who says the tech giant has recovered from many mistakes “because they stick to their higher-order purpose, the democratization of technology.”

Consumers sense that Apple’s elegantly designed products will be easy to use, he explains. “That’s why they have this brand that people are irrationally drawn to, because it feels like I’m going to be better if I engage with that brand.”

But remember: Trust can be fragile. “It just takes one misstep, and then you start to raise doubts in people’s minds,” Keller says.

When people feel that a brand has betrayed their trust, sometimes the reaction is visceral. “The opposite of trust is not distrust, but it’s disgust,” Travis says. “Once you’ve gotten into the disgust level, that’s hard to fix.”

Nick Rockel

This story was originally featured on Fortune.com

Advertisement