The Best Nantucket Hotels That Feel Like Homes Away From Home
"Hearst Magazines and Yahoo may earn commission or revenue on some items through these links."
There's nothing quite like the charm of Nantucket.
The quaint Massachusetts island has become one of the country's most idyllic summer destinations, with sprawling beaches (like Surfside Beach, Jettie's Beach, and Children's Beach), classic clapboard homes, cobblestone streets, winding bike paths, and beloved restaurants. Though the prime months to visit Nantucket are June through August, the shoulder months of April, May, September, and October—though chillier—are less busy and just as magical. (Heads up: Most hotels close during the winter months!)
The Grey Lady has something to offer every visitor, but where you choose to stay on the 14-mile island will have a major impact on your experience. Whether you're a solo traveler hoping to explore the shops and restaurants in the historic downtown district by foot (ideal for spontaneous visits to The Juice Bar to feed ice cream cravings), a honeymooning couple looking for a luxurious, private respite right on the beach, or a family balancing relaxation with kid-friendly activities, the island has a temporary home for you.
The White Elephant
The White Elephant—open from April to October and select weeks during the holiday season—is one of the most iconic hotels on Nantucket, with an unbeatable location on the harbor in town, chic interiors, and the most varied and luxe accommodation options. There are multi-bedroom residences and cottages, expansive downtown lofts, a quaint inn, and, of course, the flagship harborside hotel, appealing to groups of any size, including families.
The property is seconds away from some of the best restaurants in town, Brant Point Lighthouse, and Children's Beach. Or hop on one of the hotel's complimentary bikes to arrive at Jettie's Beach or Steps Beach in minutes.
The Wauwinet
A quintessential luxury Nantucket hotel, the adults-only Wauwinet gives visitors everything they need for their island getaway all in one place, including two private beaches on the Atlantic Ocean and Nantucket Bay. Nantucket's only member of Relais & Châteaux hotels features 32 hotel rooms, suites and cottages, the beloved Toppper's restaurant, and sweeping water views.
While the property, which is open from late April through October, offers shuttles into town and complimentary bikes, the Wauwinet is in a more remote area of the island. It’s an ideal option for couples hoping for a quieter, lowkey oceanfront escape.
The Nantucket Hotel & Resort
While the centrally located Nantucket Hotel first opened in 1891, its popularity has skyrocketed since its beautiful 2012 restoration—especially because it’s the only year-round hotel on the island. Located steps from town, it's the best Nantucket hotel for families, offering standard hotel rooms, multi-bedroom suites, and cottages.
It’s the only hotel on the island so close to the bustling, historic town that also has two heated pools, a fitness center, a spa, and even a complimentary Kids' Club Program. The Nantucket Hotel & Resort is a short walk from the classic Oran Mor Bistro, picture-perfect Brant Point Lighthouse, and the island's favorite ice cream shop, The Juice Bar.
Jared Coffin House
Jared Coffin House, open from May to October, consists of two buildings: the historic Main House and the Daniel Webster House, which sit side by side at the top of Broad Street, right in Nantucket's historic downtown district. The furnishings here are more traditional, but still feel updated and sleek, which is very appropriate for the island. The hotel, which greets guests with complimentary continental breakfast every morning, is located steps from all of the most in-demand spots in town, like Born & Bread bakery, The Juice Bar (again, a must-go for ice cream), the Italian restaurant Ventuno, and The Club Car Piano Bar.
Faraway
Faraway is one of the newest additions to Nantucket and boasts the best location for travelers who would rather walk to everything, rather than rent a car. It's in the heart of Nantucket's historic downtown district, with some 80 accommodations spread across six gorgeous buildings, all centered around a lush central courtyard.
From one-bed rooms to multi-room suites and double bunk bed rooms, Faraway has options for singles, couples, and families—all styled with a chic, modern coastal touch. Guests will also find a coffee bar and the popular all-day restaurant Sister Ship, offering everything from cocktails to dreamy dinners. It's also steps from the popular Black-Eyed Susan's restaurant and the healthy island favorite, Lemon Press.
The Cottages at Boat Basin
These quaint waterfront lofts and cottages, open from early April through October, are unbeatably situated right on Old South Wharf. Picture it: Sipping a morning coffee and soaking up water views as boats pass, before taking a few steps to Provisions for delicious sandwiches.
These recently renovated spaces feature condo-like layouts, complete with kitchens, while still maintaining their Nantucket charm. While the only beach within walking distance is Children's Beach, the Cottages offer guests complimentary bikes or a beach bus shuttle.
Life House
Located right outside of town, at the start of the iconic Cliff Road, Life House is a boutique hotel with an intimate bed-and-breakfast feel. The updated guest rooms in the nearly 200-year-old Federal-style home have a distinct Nantucket ambience with modern touches and luxury amenities, like Le Labo products and Revival New York linens.
Life House is within walking distance of Nantucket's iconic Something Natural sandwich shop and Steps Beach. To reach the heart of town, walk 10 minutes the other way.
You Might Also Like