The Best Hotels in the Hamptons for Celebrity Sightings
A stay at one of the best hotels in the Hamptons is well worth the crawling traffic it can take to get there. Situated a few hours outside New York City, the South Fork of Long Island has a beach town for every type of beachgoer: the laid-back surfers of Amagansett, the city fleers of East Hampton, the Nancy Myers fans of Southampton, and the trend-loving millennials of Montauk. Regardless of their location, the best hotels in the Hamptons have one thing in common: they're all decidedly low-key.
Before you book a hotel, determine which part of the Hamptons you want to spend most of your time in. First timers, East Hampton is for you. You'll get the full Hamptons experience there, often including celebrity sightings. It has a mix of charming bed-and-breakfasts and Michelin-starred fine-dining restaurants. If you're looking for something quieter, take the ferry to Shelter Island for pristine hiking, biking, and birdwatching. For trendy restaurants and trophy fishing, look to Montauk at the northernmost point of Long Island. It's home to an Airbnb rental that's one of our all-time favorites.
The Hamptons has some of the prettiest places to stay in the country. As for the most luxurious hotel in the Hamptons, Baron's Cove in Sag Harbor and Topping Rose House in Bridgehampton are our picks. They're both incredibly romantic, with spacious rooms and attentive staff. Ahead, we highlight 12 of the best hotels in the Hamptons. Happy vacationing!
Baron's Cove, Sag Harbor
Spacious private gardens with teak picnic tables are just one of the unique amenities you can enjoy at this 67-room harbor-front resort in the heart of the East End. Book it for a romantic couple's weekend, and spend your days taking in the town on the inn's bikes, playing tennis, and lounging by the pool.
Book Now From $363 per night
Pridwin Hotel, Shelter Island
This classic 1927 resort is cozier than ever after a two-year, a floor-to-ceiling renovation. Many of its nautical-themed rooms and cottages have waterfront views. For little ones, it has bikes, board games, and more structured activities to keep them occupied. Pridwin Hotel is accessible only by car ferry, so don't forget your boat shoes.
Book Now From $313 per night
A Room at the Beach, Bridgehampton
With only 10 rooms, A Room at the Beach is a cozy stay that's definitely a step up from your standard mom-and-pop B&B. Imagine an old-school roadside model remade with five-star amenities like soaking tubs, Frette linens and robes, and full-size Malin & Goetz toiletries. Wander under the redwoods in the garden, take a dip in the pool, and then warm up in the cedar-lined sauna—you may never want to leave the grounds.
Book Now From $420 per night
Capri, Southampton
With its bold yellow-and-white-stripe decor, Capri is a slice of Italy in the Hamptons. It's the place for people who love to play, including bachelorette parties. Rent one of its custom Solé bikes to ride to the beach or sip negronis poolside at the Bathing Club.
Book Now From $249 per night
The Roundtree, Amagansett
This minimalist-leaning boutique hotel has a variety of room types to cater to groups, including one- and two-bedroom cottages and a three-bedroom, five-bath gem of a beach house (formerly owned by the playwright Neil Simon, no less). Nightly s'mores and popcorn around its campfires welcome you back after a day at the beach.
Book Now From $495 per night
EHP Resort and Marina, East Hampton
This nine-acre resort with a Greece-by-way-of-Spain vibe is set right on Three Mile Marina for epic sunset views. EHP also has tennis courts, complimentary bikes, a sparkling waterfront pool, and its own sushi and Mediterranean cuisine hot spots, so you can make the most of days when you don't want to do a thing but relax.
Book Now From $550 per night
The American Hotel, Sag Harbor
Built in 1846, The American Hotel is the classic place to stay in Sag Harbor. If you like to be close to everything—including top restaurants, galleries, and shops—you want to be here, at the center of town where an inn has stood since colonial times. Antique furnishings reflect its history of the 19th-century building and are complemented by modern luxuries like Frette linens.
Book Now From $245 per night
Marram, Montauk
With its screen-free rooms, Marram is designed to be a destination to reset, relax, and unplug. Don't worry, you can bring your phone, but you might not want to pick it up. The soothing views of the dunes and soft Frette linens might convince you that even rainy days spent on the Long Island coast are worth the drive.
Book Now From $335 per night
Gurney's, Montauk
The only year-round resort in Montauk, Gurney's is set right on the beach. Complete with a luxurious saltwater spa and 2,000 feet of private beach, Gurney's is best suited to those who prefer to spend their days soaking in the sun.
Book Now From $796 per night
The Ram's Head Inn, Shelter Island
Quiet and relaxing, The Ram's Head Inn feels like an unpretentious version of an old-school member's club with its well-stocked library and antique-filled guest rooms. Built by a woman in 1919, The Ram's Head is classic piece of Shelter Island history—and it's an idyllic place for a family gathering.
Book Now From $280 per night
Surf Lodge, Montauk
The It place to stay right now in Montauk, Surf Lodge is all about fun. Every standard room has its own sun deck and a hammock for the ultimate relaxation. The property also hosts art shows, musical performances, pop-up boutiques, and food trucks.
Book NowFrom $650 per night
Topping Rose House, East Hampton
Classic and traditional, the Topping Rose House is at the center of East Hampton universe. Book a weekend in this 19th-century mansion to experience true luxury at the beach, including its Farmaesthetics spa and Jean-Georges Vongerichten–helmed restaurant.
Book Now From $495 per night
Shou Sugi Ban House, Montauk
More wellness retreat than traditional hotel, Shou Sugi Ban House promotes tranquility with amenities like hinoki wood soaking tubs, organic Japanese bath products, and take-home slippers. Rooms are equipped with in-room kettles and a variety of wellness teas too. Centering activities includes yoga, meditation, and hydrotherapy; the Japanese-inspired spa is a destination unto itself. Book an individual stay or a spot in one of its wellness programs.
Book Now From $1,650 for a package
Canoe Place Inn, Hampton Bays
Recently renovated, Canoe Place Inn was originally established in 1697. (It claims to sit on the site of the nation's oldest inn.) Today, the 20 spacious guest rooms and five cottages still have antique touches, like clawfoot tubs and stone fireplaces. The East End landmark also has a private pool, lush gardens, and its own cozy tavern.
Book Now From $645 per night
The Reform Club, Amagansett
With guest rooms, cottages, and a four-bedroom home, The Reform Club has accommodations for every size group, and it prides itself on top-tier service and hospitality—they'll even pick you up from the train station. The hotel itself has an on-site spa, multiple lush gardens (including a park with picture-perfect arbors), and an impressive collection of contemporary art, and the beach is only a short walk away.
Book Now From $850 per night
You Might Also Like