2018 election viewer’s guide: Your cheat sheet for acing the midterms
After months of primaries, debates, positioning ads, attack ads, closing ads and the occasional federal indictment, the 2018 midterm elections will come to a close on Tuesday night — except for the races that will be decided by absentee ballots, go into recounts, or require a second-round runoff to determine a final winner. As the votes are counted, the immediate future of the country will be decided: Who will control Congress, and how will the policies they enact affect Americans? Will ballot initiatives legalize weed, bolster voting rights, eliminate gerrymandering and/or expand Medicaid? Can Democrats recover from years of losses at the state level, or will Republicans hold on to power in Capitol buildings across the nation?
What follows is a guide of races to watch as the night rolls on — hour-by-hour indicators of what might be happening in the House (where Democrats are projected to have a good chance of taking control), the Senate (which Republicans are projected to have an equally good chance of retaining) and at the state level. You’ll see this general theme play out a lot overnight: Vulnerable Senate Democrats trying to hold on to their seats, and dozens of House Republicans scrambling to escape a potential blue wave.
As in every election, bear in mind that the early returns in some races may be lopsided, depending on which areas count their ballots first. Unless you’re familiar with the precinct-level voting history of a particular district, don’t put too much weight on those early numbers. News organizations will call races when the outcome is statistically settled. Yahoo News will call races based on projections by the Associated Press.
(All race ratings mentioned come from the nonpartisan Cook Political Report, and all times are Eastern.)
Our first House indicator of the night will come in the Kentucky’s Sixth Congressional District, where GOP Rep. Andy Barr is trying to fend off a challenge from former fighter pilot Amy McGrath in a toss-up race. Indiana will also provide the first piece of the Senate puzzle as Democratic Sen. Joe Donnelly attempts to hold on against businessman Mike Braun in a state Trump won by nearly 20 points. That race is now rated a toss-up.
For more early indicators in the House, look to Virginia first. If incumbent Republican Rep. Barbara Comstock is holding her own against Democratic challenger Jennifer Wexton in the 10th District, which went to Hillary Clinton by ten points and is rated lean Democrat, that’s a good sign for Republicans. The toss-up races are in the Second and Seventh districts, where GOP incumbents Rep. Scott Taylor and Rep. Dave Brat hope to survive. If Democrat Leslie Cockburn can win the open seat in the Fifth — a race rated lean Republican — that could be an early warning sign for the GOP that a blue wave is materializing.
And for a marquee race that has drawn President Trump, Vice President Mike Pence, Oprah Winfrey and a number of lawsuits about voter suppression, 7 p.m. is when polls close for the Georgia gubernatorial contest between Democrat Stacey Abrams, who could become the first African-American woman to serve as governor, and Republican Brian Kemp, who is also overseeing the race in his capacity as secretary of state. (This could head to a Dec. 4 runoff if neither candidate hits 50 percent.) Also keep an eye on the Sixth District and the Seventh District, which have GOP incumbents and lean Republican ratings.
On the Senate front, Democrat Sherrod Brown is looking safe in Ohio while Joe Manchin’s West Virginia race is rated lean Democrat, so focus there. The race to replace Republican Gov. John Kasich in Ohio is rated a toss-up.
On the House side, Republicans are defending toss-up seats in Ohio’s 12th District (the special election in which Rep. Troy Balderson barely scraped by Danny O’Connor a few months ago), in North Carolina’s Ninth District (open seat, Mark Harris vs. Dan McCready) and North Carolina’s 13th District (Rep. Ted Budd vs. Kathy Manning). Your potential blue wave indicators in races rated lean Republican are in Ohio’s First District (Rep. Steve Chabot vs. Aftab Pureval) and West Virginia’s ThirdDistrict (an open seat where Democrat Richard Ojeda has drawn national attention for his unconventional campaign style against Republican Carol Miller).
The pace picks up now with polls closed in part or all of 21 states. For the Senate, the big ones here are Florida (Democratic Sen. Bill Nelson defending against current Gov. Rick Scott), Missouri (Democratic Sen. Claire McCaskill vs. state Attorney General Josh Hawley) and Tennessee (Rep. Marsha Blackburn, hoping to keep an open seat Republican, is being challenged by former Gov. Phil Bredesen). There is also a three-way race in Mississippi that could go to a runoff. Keep an eye on New Jersey, where scandal-plagued Democrat Sen. Bob Menendez is probably safe (the New Jersey Star Ledger’s endorsement had the inspiring headline “Choke it down, and vote for Menendez”) but a loss here would be an embarrassment for Democrats who failed to support a potential primary challenge that could have resulted in a stronger candidate on the ballot.
We will also start to see more results from moderate Republican districts where the working thesis is suburban white women’s antipathy toward Trump, combined with the GOP’s attempts to repeal Obamacare, might hurt them. In New Jersey, Republicans are on the defense in toss-up races in the Third District (Rep. Tom MacArthur vs. Andy Kim) and Seventh District (Rep. Leonard Lance vs. Tom Malinowski).
For the House, there are so many seats in play here that we’re going to turn to bullet points the rest of the way. Here are the toss-up seats now held by Republicans:
- Florida’s 15th (Open; Ross Spano vs. Kristen Carlson)
- Florida’s 26th (Rep. Carlos Curbelo vs. Debbie Mucarsel-Powell)
- Illinois’s 14th (Rep. Randy Hultgren vs. Lauren Underwood)
- Maine’s Second (Rep. Bruce Poliquin vs. Jared Golden)
- Pennsylvania’s First (Rep. Brian Fitzpatrick vs. Scott Wallace)
If Democrats get a healthy chunk of those, they’re in good shape to take the House. They’ll be in great shape if they can start flipping the following, which are GOP seats rated as lean Republican:
- Florida’s Sixth (open, Michael Waltz vs. Nancy Soderberg)
- Florida’s 16th (Rep. Vern Buchanan vs. David Shapiro)
- Florida’s 18th (Rep. Brian Mast vs. Lauren Baer)
- Illinois’s 12th (Rep. Mike Bost vs. Brendan Kelly)
- Illinois’s 13th (Rep. Rodney Davis vs. Betsy Dirksen Londrigan)
- Missouri’s Second (Rep. Ann Wagner vs. Cort VanOstran)
- Pennsylvania’s 10th (Rep. Scott Perry vs. George Scott)
- Pennsylvania’s 16th (Rep. Mike Kelly vs. Ron DiNicola)
Among the races for governor, focus on toss-ups in Oklahoma and Connecticut and then Florida, where Andrew Gillum is attempting to become the state’s first black governor. The other result in the Sunshine State to keep an eye on is Amendment 4: it requires 60 percent of the vote, but if it passes, it will return the right to vote to convicted felons who’ve completed their sentences, altering the electorate — 1.4 million people, including one in five African-Americans, are now ineligible to vote — in a major way in a state that could help Democrats in the 2020 presidential election and beyond.
The final polls close in Texas, where there is a Senate race between Republican Sen. Ted Cruz and Democratic Rep. Beto O’Rourke that you may have heard about. We’ll also start to get Senate results in Arizona (a toss-up race for a Republican open seat between GOP Rep. Martha McSally and Democratic Rep. Kyrsten Sinema) and Minnesota (Democratic Sen. Tina Smith, who was appointed to replace Al Franken, defends against Karin Housley in a race rated lean Democrat). Minnesota also has two of the only House seats where Democrats are on the defense, with competitive open seats in the First and the Eighth districts.
At this point of the night, we should have some indication of how the House is trending. The lean Republican seats in play here — where a high percentage of Democratic wins would mean something big — are Texas’s 22nd (Rep. Pete Olson vs. Sri Preston Kulkarni), Texas’s 23rd (Rep. Will Hurd vs. Gina Ortiz Jones), Nebraska’s Second (Rep. Don Bacon vs. Kara Eastman), New York’s 11th (Rep. Dan Donovan vs. Max Rose), New York’s 24th (Rep. John Katko vs. Dana Balter), New York’s 27th (Rep. Chris Collins, facing an indictment on insider-trading charges, vs. Nate McMurray) and Wisconsin’s First (for the seat House Speaker Paul Ryan is stepping down from; Bryan Steil vs. Randy Bryce). We’ll also have results from some of the big gubernatorial races in Kansas, Wisconsin, Colorado and Michigan.
Bonus Michigan: Three interesting ballot initiatives here to keep an eye on: one would legalize marijuana for recreational use, one would expand voting rights and one would eliminate partisan gerrymandering through the creation of an independent redistricting commission.
The biggest races here are in the Senate. The first polls close in North Dakota, where Sen. Heidi Heitkamp is the most vulnerable Democratic incumbent in a race against Rep. Kevin Kramer, now rated lean Republican. In Nevada, GOP Sen. Dean Heller is attempting to survive a challenge from Rep. Jacky Rosen in a state Clinton won in 2016, and in Montana, Democratic Sen. Jon Tester is trying to hold on against Matt Rosendale in a state Trump won. (Both races are rated toss-ups.) This is also when the polls close in Utah, so this is when you’ll get the official alert that Mitt Romney has been elected senator from the Beehive State.
On the House side, this is where we will find out if GOP Rep. Steve King’s consistent coziness with white nationalists costs him against J.D Scholten in Iowa’s Fourth District. We’ll also see whether Republican Rep. Mia Love, the only black woman in the GOP caucus, can survive a challenge by Ben McAdams in Utah’s Fourth (a toss-up) and how Montana Rep. Greg Gianforte, who pled guilty to assaulting a reporter prior to last year’s special election, fares against Kathleen Williams.
We’ll also get results from Washington, where Republicans are defending a toss-up open seat (in the Eighth District) and two lean Republican districts (Rep. Jaime Herrera Beutler in the Third and Rep. Cathy McMorris Rodgers in the Fifth).
This is also when California closes, so if the House is yet to be decided, it’s going to be a late night as votes are counted in a half-dozen Republican seats are rated as either toss-up or lean Republican. If it comes down to the wire, those races are:
- 10th District (Rep. Jeff Denham vs. Josh Harder)
- 25th District (Rep. Steve Knight vs. Katie Hill)
- 39th District (Open, Young Kim vs. Gil Cisneros)
- 45th District (Rep. Mimi Walters vs. Katie Porter)
- 48th District (Rep. Dana Rohrabacher vs. Harley Rouda)
- 50th District (Rep. Duncan Hunter vs Ammar Campa-Najjar)
If the Democrats take the House and you’re interested in the final margin, there are four races rated likely Republican — the First, Fourth, 21st and 22nd districts — that could flip in a blue wave.
GOP Rep. Don Young, 85, first won Alaska’s congressional seat in a 1973 special election, when his opponent this time around — Democrat Alyse Galvin — was 8 years old. This Galvin’s first campaign, having never run for anything prior to attending the 2017 Women’s March, but she has a chance in a race rated lean Republican. (The final poll closing times anywhere in the nation are in the western Aleutian Islands, which shut things down at 1 a.m.)
Read more Yahoo News midterms coverage:
- In Texas Senate race, both parties are at the door — all 7.4 million of them
- In Arizona, Democrat Kyrsten Sinema runs hard to the middle
- Battle for the soccer-mom vote plays out in suburban Detroit
- Menendez race pits ethical concerns against party loyalty, and loyalty is winning
- A House rematch sheds light on how landscape changed from 2016
- Virginia Republican congressman tries to weather scandal and wave of spending
- Photos: Scenes from the Texas Senate race
- See the rest of our midterms coverage >>>