Dolphins coach Adam Gase blames ridiculous new rule for player's ACL tear

When Miami Dolphins coach Adam Gase met with media on Monday, he announced that veteran defensive end William Hayes would be out for the rest of the season after suffering a torn ACL.

Hayes was injured on the second play of the second quarter of Miami’s win over Oakland, as he sacked the Raiders’ Derek Carr.

Gase blames new rule for injury

Gase blamed the NFL’s new and much-ridiculed point of emphasis this season which prohibits defensive players from using “all or part” of their body weight to take a quarterback down for Hayes’ injury.

Miami Dolphins defensive end William Hayes is out for the rest of the season after tearing his right ACL on this play. (AP)
Miami Dolphins defensive end William Hayes is out for the rest of the season after tearing his right ACL on this play. (AP)

“He was trying not to put his body weight on the quarterback and that happened,” Gase said. “He is one of the leaders; our best run defender.”

It sounds like some sour grapes from Gase at first, but watching the clip of the play (above), it doesn’t seem so far-fetched, and he may have a point. It looks like Hayes was doing what he could in the moment to position himself in such a way as to not land fully on Carr, swinging his right leg out wide. When Hayes lands, he clutches his right knee.

‘Trying to land unnaturally’

The above tweet is from Matt Chatham, who won three Super Bowl rings as a reserve linebacker with the New England Patriots. Chatham posted it Sunday afternoon, when the play happened, and he believed as soon as it happened that Hayes was trying to adhere to the new rule and injured himself in the process.

While Hayes, a 33-year-old who is in his 11th season in the NFL and second with the Dolphins, has played a backup role with Miami, as Gase said he is the team’s best run defender and edge-setter.

Player safety for which players?

The NFL listed the body weight emphasis as protection of quarterbacks, and players should be as safe as possible on the field. But how fair is it if defensive players suffer injuries in the interest of protecting quarterbacks?

One of the league’s more outspoken players, San Francisco 49ers cornerback Richard Sherman, took note of the disparity, tweeting, “They don’t care about the rest of us getting hurt. Long as the QB is safe,” on Monday.

Defensive players have decried the unfairness of the new rules and points of emphasis directed at the safety of quarterbacks and offensive skill players, and their concerns are justified, and even more so if players are going to end up hurting themselves trying to unnaturally move themselves and avoid making a tackle that up until a few months ago was a textbook takedown.

Hayes appears to wrap Carr around the shoulders and didn’t make helmet-to-helmet contact.

Subscribe to The Yahoo Sports NFL Podcast
Apple PodcastsStitcherGoogle Podcasts

More from Yahoo Sports:
Tiger’s win is the greatest comeback in sports history
White Sox star says what many think about umpire
Charles Robinson: Latest flag on Packers’ Matthews may be worst yet
Rams’ Gurley really isn’t a fan of Thursday games