Harvard gave Asian-American applicants lowest scores on 'positive personality' traits out of all racial groups, lawsuit claims

A controversial new study claims Harvard routinely gave Asian-American applicants the lowest score of any racial group on subjective traits such as “positive personality,” “likeability” and “kindness.”

The study, disputed by the elite Ivy League, tracked 160,000 student records over several years and was filed in federal court in Boston Friday by the conservative-leaning nonprofit Students for Fair Admissions, which is suing the school.

The author of the study, Duke Professor Peter Arcidiacono, purportedly found “overwhelming evidence that Harvard’s admissions process disproportionately harms Asian-American applicants,” according to the group’s filing.

“There is no excuse for this, and Harvard cannot offer a single exculpatory explanation that a rational factfinder could accept. Asian-American applicants to Harvard are just as ‘helpful,’ ‘courageous,’ and ‘kind’ as white applicants,” the filing states.

16 PHOTOS
Notable Harvard University alumni
See Gallery
Notable Harvard University alumni

Harvard University at Night

(Photo via Shutterstock)

Vice President and Democratic Presidential candidate, Al Gore makes a forceful point during his acceptance speech at the DNC Convention August 17, 2000 in Los Angeles, CA. (Pool Photo/Newsmakers)
Bill Gates, founder of the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, takes part in a discussion organized by British magazine The Economist about expected breakthroughs in the next 15 years in health, education, farming and banking on January, 22, 2015 in Brussels.(Photo by Emmanuel Dunand, AFP/Getty Images)
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu delivers a statement during the traditional photograph in honor of the swearing in of the 34th Government of Israel on May 19, 2015 at the presidential compound in Jerusalem. (Photo by Gali Tibbon, AFP/Getty Images)
US President George W. Bush attended Harvard Business school. (Photo by Shawn Thew, AFP/Getty Images)
U.S. President Barack Obama attended Harvard Law School. (Photo by Pete Souza/Obama Transition Office via Getty Images)
Henry David Thoreau (1817 - 1862) US essayist, poet and naturalist, who was known to be a recluse. (Photo by Hulton Archive/Getty Images)
Actress Rashida Jones arrives for the 21st Annual Screen Actors Guild Awards, January 25, 2015 at the Shrine Auditorium in Los Angeles, California. (Photo by Frederic J. Brown, AFP/Getty Images)
Ryan Fitzpatrick #14 of the Houston Texans rushes for a touchdown during the first half of the game against the Jacksonville Jaguars at EverBank Field on December 7, 2014 in Jacksonville, Florida. (Photo by Rob Foldy/Getty Images)
Japanese Crown Prince Naruhito (L) and Crown Princess Masako (R) leave Haneda Airport after seeing off Emperor Akihito and Empress Michiko for their flight to New Delhi, in Tokyo on November 30, 2013. (Photo by Toru Yamanaka, AFP/Getty Images)
Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg speaks at the F8 summit in San Francisco, California, on March 25, 2015. (Photo by Josh Edelson/AFP/Getty Images)
Portrait of John Adams, second President of the United States who served from 1797 to 1801. (Photo by National Archive/Newsmakers)
US statesman John F Kennedy, 35th president of the USA, making a speech. (Photo by Central Press/Getty Images)
Liberian President Ellen Johnson Sirleaf speaks to the press following a meeting on the response to the Ebola crisis at the IMF/WB Spring Meetings in Washington, DC, on April 17, 2015. (Photo Nicholas Kamm, AFP/Getty Images)
Portrait of the 6th U.S. President John Quincy Adams. (1767-1848) (Courtesy of the National Archives/Newsmakers)
Portrait of 32nd United States President Franklin D. Roosevelt. (1882-1945) (Courtesy of the National Archives/Newsmakers)
HIDE CAPTION
SHOW CAPTION
of
SEE ALL
BACK TO SLIDE

“Any explanation Harvard does offer would be a thinly veiled racial stereotype about Asian Americans,” the paperwork argues.

According to Arcidiacono, Asian-American applicants received overall scores by alumni interviewers that were “virtually identical” to those of white applicants. But the school’s 40-member admissions committee allegedly gave them the worst scores of any racial group, sometimes without meeting them, his study found.

Students for Fair Admissions, based in Arlington, Va., is run by Edward Blum, a longtime crusader against affirmative action.

Harvard is attacking the group’s analysis as flawed.

“Thorough and comprehensive analysis of the data and evidence makes clear that Harvard College does not discriminate against applicants from any group, including Asian-Americans, whose rate of admission has grown 29% over the last decade,” the school said in a statement.

Harvard said the report submitted by Students for Fair Admissions paints “a dangerously inaccurate picture of Harvard College’s whole-person admissions process.”

23 PHOTOS
Harvard University's campus
See Gallery
Harvard University's campus
Entrance gate and East facade of Sever Hall at Harvard Yard in Harvard University in Cambridge, Massachusetts, MA, USA. It is used as the library, lecture hall and classroom for different courses.
Students sitting on the grass at Harvard Yard. (Photo by: Jeffrey Greenberg/UIG via Getty Images)
CAMBRIDGE, MA - JANUARY 27: Students play football at the Quad, on the campus of Harvard University on January 27, 2015 in Cambridge, Massachusetts. Boston, and much of the Northeast, is being hit with heavy snow from Winter Storm Juno. (Photo by Maddie Meyer/Getty Images)
ALLSTON, BOSTON, MASSACHUSETTS, UNITED STATES - 2015/10/18: Soldiers Field or Harvard Stadium on the Allston Campus of Harvard University. (Photo by John Greim/LightRocket via Getty Images)
Baker Library at Harvard Business School
Harvard is the oldest institution of higher learning in the United States
Aerial view of F Kennedy Street in the Harvard University Area in Cambridge, MA, USA
Harvard is the oldest institution of higher learning in the United States
The high gothic Memorial Hall at Harvard University in Cambridge, Massachusetts, USA. Completed in 1877, it is a monument to the memorial of graduates who fought for the Union cause in the Civil War. Today it is a National Historic Landmark.
BOSTON, MA - JULY 26: The campus of Harvard Business School, July 26, 2016 in Boston, Massachusetts. Harvard, one of the most prestigious business schools in the world, emphasizes the case method in the classroom. (Photo by Brooks Kraft/Corbis via Getty Images)
BOSTON, MA - JULY 26: The campus of Harvard Business School, July 26, 2016 in Boston, Massachusetts. Harvard, one of the most prestigious business schools in the world, emphasizes the case method in the classroom. (Photo by Brooks Kraft/Corbis via Getty Images)
BOSTON, MA - JULY 26: The campus of Harvard Business School, July 26, 2016 in Boston, Massachusetts. Harvard, one of the most prestigious business schools in the world, emphasizes the case method in the classroom. (Photo by Brooks Kraft/Corbis via Getty Images)
BOSTON, MA - JULY 26: The campus of Harvard Business School, July 26, 2016 in Boston, Massachusetts. Harvard, one of the most prestigious business schools in the world, emphasizes the case method in the classroom. (Photo by Brooks Kraft/Corbis via Getty Images)
BOSTON, MA - JULY 26: The campus of Harvard Business School, July 26, 2016 in Boston, Massachusetts. Harvard, one of the most prestigious business schools in the world, emphasizes the case method in the classroom. (Photo by Brooks Kraft/Corbis via Getty Images)
BOSTON, MA - JULY 26: The campus of Harvard Business School, July 26, 2016 in Boston, Massachusetts. Harvard, one of the most prestigious business schools in the world, emphasizes the case method in the classroom. (Photo by Brooks Kraft/Corbis via Getty Images)
CAMBRIDGE, MA - APRIL 5: Wadsworth Hall on the Harvard University campus in Cambridge, MA is pictured on Apr. 5, 2016. (Photo by Dina Rudick/The Boston Globe via Getty Images)
HARVARD UNIVERSITY, CAMBRIDGE, MASSACHUSETTS, UNITED STATES - 2015/10/18: Dunster House dormitory with clock tower, Harvard University. (Photo by John Greim/LightRocket via Getty Images)
Wigglesworth Hall dormitory. (Photo by: Jeffrey Greenberg/UIG via Getty Images)
A group sits on the steps of Widener Library at the Harvard University campus in Cambridge, Massachusetts, U.S., on Tuesday, June 30, 2015. Harvard University, established in 1636, is the United States' oldest institution of higher learning. Photographer: Victor J. Blue/Bloomberg via Getty Images
The school motto 'Veritas' is inscribed over a gate at the Harvard University campus in Cambridge, Massachusetts, U.S., on Tuesday, June 30, 2015. Harvard University, established in 1636, is the United States' oldest institution of higher learning. Photographer: Victor J. Blue/Bloomberg via Getty Images
Workers take down an American flag next to a statue of John Harvard in Harvard Yard at the Harvard University campus in Cambridge, Massachusetts, U.S., on Tuesday, June 30, 2015. Harvard University, established in 1636, is the United States' oldest institution of higher learning. Photographer: Victor J. Blue/Bloomberg via Getty Images
Students on the campus of Harvard Law School in Cambridge, MA. Harvard Law School is the oldest continually-operating law school in the United States and is home to the largest academic law library in the world. (Photo by Brooks Kraft LLC/Corbis via Getty Images)
Students on the campus of Harvard Law School in Cambridge, MA. Harvard Law Schoolt is the oldest continually-operating law school in the United States and is home to the largest academic law library in the world. (Photo by Brooks Kraft LLC/Corbis via Getty Images)
HIDE CAPTION
SHOW CAPTION
of
SEE ALL
BACK TO SLIDE

Harvard said the report failed to consider “critical data and information factors, such as personal essays and teacher recommendations.”

“Harvard will continue to vigorously defend our right, and that of other colleges and universities nationwide, to seek the educational benefits that come from a class that is diverse on multiple dimensions, from its capacity for academic excellence to its ability to help create a campus community that gives every student the opportunity to learn from peers with a wide variety of academic interests, perspectives, and talents,” the school said in a statement to the Daily News.

The school also disputed claims that an internal study at Harvard found evidence of bias against Asian-Americans in 2013.

It said the 2013 report was incomplete and preliminary.

Both sides filed motions Friday asking for summary judgment, meaning immediate rulings that would end the pending lawsuit in their favor.

If the case moves ahead, a trial is scheduled to begin in October.

Considering the resources on both sides, the battle could rage all the way to the Supreme Court, where it could put the issue of affirmative action back in play for all schools.

Harvard admitted 2,037 students for its class of 2012, out of 39,506 applicants, according to its website. The class is 14.6% African-American, 22.2% Asian-American, 11.6% Latino and 2.5% Native American or Pacific Islander, the school says on its website.

Read Full Story