Baby Sabrina mystery: Woman claims she is child abducted from crib 20 years ago

The parents of baby Sabrina Aisenberg, who disappeared from her crib in Florida 20 years ago, say a 20-year-old woman has reached out to them on Facebook, claiming to be the long-lost child.

Steve and Marlene Aisenberg say the woman is about the same age as Sabrina, and has no baby pictures from the time she was 5 to 9 months old and her photos begin after that period. 

A second woman has also come forward to claim she is Sabrina. 

The Aisenbergs spoke to 20/20's Deborah Roberts in a special airing Friday night.

"What gives the Aisenbergs hope is not only have they put their DNA out there, but now, they have been contacted by two women who are also willing to go that far," Roberts told Inside Edition when asked about the possibility that one of the women could be Sabrina. 

Results of the DNA tests are still pending. 

History's Mysteries
See Gallery
History's Mysteries

First described by Plato thousands of years ago, the legendary lost city of Atlantis has been the subject of endless myth and speculation. Said to have “in a single day and night...disappeared into the depths of the sea”, Atlantis is so mysterious that many doubt it existed at all. For those who believe in this sunken city, the question is not whether it was real, but where it was really located.

The theories range far and wide, from the site of Akrotiri on the island of Santorini to places such as Gibraltar and Cornwall in Britain. There was even one memorable occasion when an underwater theme park in Bali was mistakenly “identified” as the real Atlantis. For those still on the hunt, the latest and most highly credited find of recent times is in Southern Spain, where archaeologists claim a city was overwhelmed by a tsunami.

Isolated in the midst of the South Pacific, tiny Easter Island packs a deceptively hefty punch in the world of historic mysteries. Stumbled upon by the Dutch in the 18th century, this small island is home to around 900 huge head-shaped statues.

Known as the moai and thought to have been created around 1000 AD, each is believed to embody the spirit of an ancestor. Dotted around the landscape, much about the origins of these unusual inhabitants - as well as those of the island’s diminishing Polynesian population - is unknown.

Not only is it unclear how these incredibly heavy statues were moved around the island, but it has yet to be established as to why they were all positioned to face inland, nor why they were toppled before the Dutch arrived, although some have posited that this followed a time of civil war and destruction. Another mystery is that of the Rongorongo, a type of script found on Easter Island that has yet to be translated.

Think of the Vikings and your mind probably travels to Denmark, Scandinavia and perhaps to wider Europe, but what about Canada?

It seems that in around 1000 AD, a group of Vikings became the first European settlers in North America, as evidenced by the ruins of their settlement at L’Anse aux Meadows.

So, how and why did this happen? Nobody is quite sure how these intrepid travellers got quite so far, but the most common suggestion is that their ship was accidentally taken off course and led them to this far-flung destination.

Any reader of the iconic I, Claudius series by Robert Graves would dearly love to know what really went on inside these walls. What ancient writers hinted – and Graves positively embroidered – was that the Roman Empress, wife of Augustus, murdered and manipulated all and sundry to ensure her son Tiberius would inherit the Empire.

What is certain is that no less than three of those who stood to inherit Augustus’ titles died young, while another was exiled in disgrace. Beyond this, the stories tell of a number of other prominent figures who were ‘bumped off’ by Livia – including Augustus himself. Whatever the truth of these tall tales, the fact that it is possible to explore the house of this extraordinary woman is a marvel in itself.

Discovered in 1911, the staggering beauty of Machu Picchu has intrigued historians and archaeologists from around the globe, yet without any written accounts from its heyday, its story remains shrouded in secrecy.

Built in the 15th century, nobody is quite sure why the Inca created this magnificent structural gem, although theories have ranged from it being everything from a convent to a ceremonial site and a retreat for the upper echelons of Inca society.

A monkey, a spider, a tree and what resembles an astronaut; hardly what you would expect to find drawn in a giant scale in the Peruvian plains, but that’s exactly what attracts hordes of tourists to Nazca every year.

Known as “geoglyphs”, what makes these earth drawings so spectacular is their complexity, sophistication and size, especially when you consider that they were probably created sometime between 500BC and 500AD. And, while theories abound as to the origins of these vast etchings, they raise a myriad of questions, not least of which include, why were they created and how?

A majestic city hewn from the rocks of the Jordanian desert, Petra was a well-kept local secret until 1812. Yet, whilst this magnificent Nabataean creation is one of the most famous visions in the world, there are some things we may never know. The best example of this is the star attraction at Petra, its stunning Treasury.

Rising a staggering 12-stories in height and carved with incredible intricacy, the original purpose of this site is unknown, although it was probably a temple, perhaps a tomb.

A vast stone circle built centuries ago, not only is Stonehenge one of the world’s most recognizable historic sites, it is also the subject of intense ongoing debate. While we know roughly when this masterpiece was built - circa 3000 BC to 1600 BC - we have yet to determine why.

Most theories center on the site’s remarkable alignment with the sun and the conclusion that it as a place of cosmic worship, others as part of a magnificent astronomical calendar. Whatever its purpose, Stonehenge was a fantastic feat of engineering, with its builders using only the most basic tools to move and shape tons of material.

Once the vast and thriving city of a great pre-Incan civilization, Tiwanaku has attracted much speculation over the years. Among its greatest remains is the Akapana Pyramid, with its plethora of carved heads, the strange shapes of which have sparked extensive debate. Some theories even went as far as claiming that the site was created by aliens, although they are now seen as representations of defeated enemies.

Indeed, archaeologists have managed to decipher a great deal about Tiwanaku over the years. For example, the intricate canal systems which can be found around its pyramid were once an enigma, but are now known to be an ingenious agricultural tool, a way to protect crops from freezing temperatures with solar heated water. However, though some questions have been answered, the almost endless debate and mystery continues.

The question of what happened to the princes in the Tower is one that has haunted Britons for centuries. These two brothers, the sons of the then recently-deceased King Edward IV, were brought to live in the Tower of London in 1483 and never seen again. 

The most popular theory - one that sparks considerable debate - is that their uncle, who was crowned Richard III that very year, had them murdered. Despite the endless speculation, it is unlikely that the truth will ever be firmly established beyond doubt.

The ancient city of Troy is home to many legends, including the famous stories of the Trojan War and the infamous Trojan Horse, but were any of these stories true?

In the past, Homer’s Illiad and Odyssey poems - from which the tales of the Trojan War originate - were certainly read as works of fact, but whether this is actually the case is more ambiguous.

Many believe that the truth is a mix of fact and legend, with Homer using real events as a basis for a more sensational plot. Today, visitors can tour what is believed to have been the real Troy - also a subject of debate - although little remains to echo Homer’s fantastic stories. 


It's a surprising new turn in a case that first made headlines in 1997, when Sabrina was snatched from her crib outside Tampa. Suspicion quickly fell on her parents, who cops thought "did not appear very upset." They were cleared of any wrongdoing. 

When they made a plea for their baby's return, some called them cold. 

"There are people out there who still look suspiciously at the Aisenbergs but they think now, [the family] may have some vindication because they, through social media now, may have a reason to think that their daughter could be out there," Roberts said. 

Through the years, the Aisenbergs say they've never lost faith that Sabrina was still alive somewhere.

A graphic artist used photos of Sabrina's two older siblings to create an age progression image of what she would look like today, at age 20.

The Aisenbergs have since moved to Maryland, where they still keep a bedroom for Sabrina.

In a message to Sabrina, the couple said they want their daughter in their lives as much as she'd like to be. 

The 20/20 interview with the Aisenbergs airs Friday night on ABC. 


Where is Amy Yu? Missing 16-Year-Old Listed Man as 'Stepfather' So He Could Pick Her Up From School

Discovery of Christina Morris' Remains Is Realization of Family's 'Most Terrifying Nightmares'

Where Is MH370? Malaysia Announces Search for Missing Plane Will Soon End as Anniversary Nears

Read Full Story

Sign up for Breaking News by AOL to get the latest breaking news alerts and updates delivered straight to your inbox.

Subscribe to our other newsletters

Emails may offer personalized content or ads. Learn more. You may unsubscribe any time.