Suspects in death of beloved Virginia teacher were in love triangle, victim killed by mistake: prosecutors

NORFOLK, Virginia (WTKR) -- A Norfolk teacher was killed by mistake on New Year's Eve by a 70-year old man in a love triangle, a prosecutor said during a bond hearing for one of the suspects on Monday morning.

Caroline Hendrix was a beloved pre-k teacher at Oceanaire Elementary, but prosecutors say Edward Shaw mistook her for someone else and shot her twice. The bullets hit her in the leg, but traveled to her upper body, killing her. Prosecutors didn't go into further detail on her injuries.

The bond hearing was for Teniqu Cushman, a 22-year old Virginia Beach woman who's charged with conspiracy to commit second degree murder. During the hearing, a prosecutor laid out what happened the night of the shooting.

The prosecutor said Hendrix was in her friend's car outside of a home on Virginian Drive. Shaw thought he was shooting Hendrix's friend, but mistakenly shot her, the prosecutor said. Hendrix died at the scene.

8 PHOTOS
Man charged in fatal shooting of elementary school teacher
See Gallery
Man charged in fatal shooting of elementary school teacher
(Photo: WTKR)
Police have arrested and charged a 70-year-old Utah man with the murder of a Virginia elementary school teacher that happened on New Year’s Eve.

(Photo: WTKR)
Police have arrested and charged a 70-year-old Utah man with the murder of a Virginia elementary school teacher that happened on New Year’s Eve.

(Photo: WTKR)
Police have arrested and charged a 70-year-old Utah man with the murder of a Virginia elementary school teacher that happened on New Year’s Eve.

(Photo: WTKR)
(Photo: WTKR)
(Photo: WTKR)
(Photo: WTKR)
(Photo: WTKR)
HIDE CAPTION
SHOW CAPTION
of
SEE ALL
BACK TO SLIDE

Shaw, Cushman, and Hendrix's friend were part of a love triangle, the prosecutor said. Cushman was not at the scene on the night of the shooting, but she and Shaw were texting, according to the prosecutor. Shaw texted Cushman that he had "shot him," but also said he was shot. Police later caught up with Shaw in Chesapeake, where officers say he told them he was the victim of a road-rage shooting, but police later determined that to not be true. Police have said an acquaintance of Hendrix shot Shaw during the incident. The prosecutor didn't elaborate during the hearing on how Shaw got shot.

The prosecutor said Shaw and Cushman had a "friends with benefits" type of relationship. Cushman also had a sexual relationship with Hendrix's friend, but that relationship soured, the prosecutor added. Cushman texted Shaw that the other man "had to be gone" due to mental abuse from the man, the prosecutor said. Cushman's attorney argued that was not proof she wanted Shaw to shoot the other man, but rather that she wanted their relationship to end.

Hendrix's friend's name was later found by investigators written in Shaw's office, the prosecutor added. During the bond hearing, the prosecutor said Cushman "put the things into action that led to Hendrix's death." In the end, a judge denied her bond request. Prosecutors also added Cushman had a prostitution charge from 2015.

Cushman's fiancé testified in the hearing that the couple is building a home and have plans to move in the next few months. He said the two had been dating on-and-off since 2014. After the hearing, he said he had "a lot to process," but didn't want to comment further.

Shaw was scheduled to have a bond hearing on Friday, but his attorney withdrew the request.

Court officials say that the next scheduled court date for both Cushman and Shaw is on April 11, 2018.

Read Full Story

Sign up for Breaking News by AOL to get the latest breaking news alerts and updates delivered straight to your inbox.

Subscribe to our other newsletters

Emails may offer personalized content or ads. Learn more. You may unsubscribe any time.