Police are making it impossible to use drones to document protests

Last November, an aerial drone flown by a member of the resistance camp opposing the Dakota Access Pipeline captured dramatic footage of riot police blasting crowds with water cannons as temperatures dipped below freezing, sending 17 of the camp's occupants to the hospital with injuries and hypothermia.

The video quickly spread on social media, spurring global news coverage of the fight against the oil pipeline, which saw activists clash with police and security forces in tense standoffs last year. A few weeks later, the Army Corps of Engineers halted construction of the pipeline, which had encroached on Native American sacred lands and threatened water supplies near North Dakota's Standing Rock reservation.

It was another example of how drones have become a crucial technology, allowing activists and journalists to document protests and hold police accountable for abuses. But as a new era of civil resistance dawns under the Trump administration, at the Standing Rock site and in anti-Trump demonstrations across the country, drone experts say police and government have made it unnecessarily difficult — sometimes impossible —for civilians to deploy drones at large protests.

SEE ALSO: Anti-Trump protesters eyeing Tax Day march

Just a few days after the video from Standing Rock went viral, the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) gave permission to local authorities to effectively ban all civilian drone flights in 4 mile radius above the Oceti Sakowin resistance camp and drill site. The same thing happened two years earlier, during the civil unrest in Ferguson, Missouri: Police were granted what is called a Temporary Flight Restriction, or TFR, which legally restricts airspace above a designated area to law enforcement and emergency aircraft. In Ferguson, the explicit goal was to stop news helicopters and drones from observing the Black Lives Matter protests, where cops were firing tear gas and menacing protesters with military vehicles and weapons.

While these ad hoc no-fly-zones are ostensibly created for air safety reasons, like clearing the way for rescue helicopters during a natural disaster, some drone journalists say law enforcement are abusing them as a way to block news coverage.

RELATED: Amazing aerial views shot with a drone

Amazing aerial views shot with a drone
See Gallery
Amazing aerial views shot with a drone
Making the most of Sydney's Spring weather, tag your beach squad! πŸ™ŒπŸΌβ˜€οΈ @riseabovedrones
Been shooting in Outback SA the past few days, get ready for some hot desert scenes. Shot possible thanks to @riseabovedrones
Feeling the heat! It's days like today that make me grateful for these spots β˜€οΈπŸ’¦ @riseabovedrones
Every time I look into this pool it feels like I'm looking at a reflection of the globe. Looking forward to another great week in Sydney πŸ™ŒπŸΌβ˜€οΈ
Chalkboard cliff face, embracing the English weather in Sydney today.
Looks like someone's having a pool party. Who would you invite? πŸŒŠβ˜€οΈ
If you ever find yourself in California do yourself a favor and drive along the PCH for a few hours and explore the coastline! What's one thing you've always wanted to do but haven't yet? β˜€οΈπŸŒŠ #california #visitcalifornia #calilife #america #bigsur #PCH #hbouthere
Witnessing first hand why California is called The Golden State. One of the best sunrises ever πŸ™ŒπŸΌπŸ”₯
It's finally the end of the week! Tag your boat squad below. Where are you headed? πŸŒŠβ˜€οΈ
If only beach-side parking was this easy! Missing my days on the West Coast. Where too next? β˜€οΈ
Things are starting to heat up in Sydney. What a way to start the weekend πŸŒŠβ˜€οΈ • @riseabovedrones
Another one ticked off the bucket list. The view of the half dome from Glacier Point is insane! πŸ™ŒπŸΌ
Sometimes waking up at 5am is worth it for views like this. Jetting off again tomorrow, be sure to follow along πŸ‘» gabscan
The hike. One of my many highlights already in 2016
My winter adventures are coming to a close. Last few days in Europe until I head back to Australia. Thanks to the guys at @riseabovedrones for the drone! Make sure you follow them and get in touch if you're looking to get one!
Adventure is just around the corner. En route to Florence today! Shot taken with my phantom 3 thanks to @riseabovedrones
Walking the plank

"The main problem is the FAA is not supposed to grant TFRs to law enforcement just because they ask for them, and yet that's pretty much what they do," said Robert Levine, a Minneapolis, Minnesota-based photographer and drone pilot. "Once you put up a TFR over a news site like in Standing Rock, you're de facto criminalizing the drone pilots who were there covering news events."

More from Vocativ: Police Crack Down On Dakota Pipeline Protesters

Temporary Flight Restrictions have been around forever, but it's only recently that they've been used at large protests and disrupted citizen drone users. Once a TFR is in place, citizen pilots need to apply for a waiver before flying, in addition to having obtained a license from the FAA under its rules for small unmanned aircraft.

Last December, Levine was the only civilian pilot to be granted a waiver to legally fly in the restricted airspace over Standing Rock. At the time, Forbes described the waiver as a "dramatic reversal" by the FAA, which six months earlier had released long-awaited rules for the commercial use of small unmanned aircraft.

SEE ALSO: 'American masculinity is broken': Men explain their Women's March activism

Even with the waiver, its restrictions made it practically impossible for Levine to get any useful footage, he said. Rather than granting him access to the entire 4-mile restricted zone, Levine was limited to only a half-mile radius centered around a pre-determined point. He also couldn't fly over crowds or at night, and needed to report in to local authorities before and after every flight.

"Even with a really judiciously placed center point for my waiver, I wouldn't have been able to cover the two main areas of news interest," Levine told Vocativ. Those two locations are the oil pipeline's drill pad and Backwater Bridge, where many clashes occurred between residents of the Oceti Sakowin and Sacred Stone resistance camps and police and security forces.

More from Vocativ: U.S Government Wants System Of Drones To Monitor Civilian Drones

The waiver also took several days to get approval. And if Levine had applied to fly his drone after dark, when the police had deployed water cannons, the process would have taken even longer.

Matt Waite, a professor who heads the University of Nebraska-Lincoln's Drone Journalism Lab, said Levine's case is especially telling because it should be relatively easy for drone operators to get access to a remote, sparsely-populated area like Standing Rock.

Getting approval to fly drones over protests in metropolitan areas, like at the Women's Marches that took place across the country following Trump's inauguration, would have taken weeks or months, he said. The pilot would also have to be much more careful not to fly over crowds. And even if the area hasn't been given a special flight restriction, some cities are covered in large swaths of permanently restricted airspace due to nearby airports.

"For breaking news, that's not workable," Waite told Vocativ. "If a spontaneous protest were to break out, I'd have to wait weeks."

Waiting is also not an option for activists, who rely on independent citizen journalists to hold police accountable during demonstrations. That means more pilots will be flying illegally in the future, and if the past is any indication, police will respond with force — sometimes by shooting drones down. At Standing Rock, police fired bean bag rounds to take down drones, Levine says. But several companies are now offering "drone guns" that allow police to jam a drone's radio signal, force it to land, or take control of it outright.

RELATED: Mesmerizing photos taken by drones

Mesmerizing photos taken by drones
See Gallery
Mesmerizing photos taken by drones

Aerial view of Taichung Metropolitan Opera house and the surrounding buildings.

(Photo by EDWARD TIAN via Getty Images)

Natural waterfall coming out of the cliff, cascading into the sea, shot using a drone, Borgafjordur East, Iceland

(Photo by Arctic-Images via Getty Images)

Top view of The Pearl (Perlan) shot using a drone, Reykjavik, Iceland. The Pearl (Perlan) is built on the top of huge tanks in which natural hot water is stored for heating Reykjavik. Restaurants, meeting halls and a museum are housed in the dome.

(Photo by Arctic-Images via Getty Images)

AIDAcara cruise ship is part of a German fleet of ships. Image is shot with a drone. Reykjavik Harbor, Reykjavik, Iceland

(Photo via Arctic-Images via Getty Images)

Image shot with a drone,Harpa Concert and Convention Center, Reykjavik, Iceland

(Photo via Arctic-Images via Getty Images)

Crowded parking lot of shopping mall during Christmas time, Reykjavik, Iceland. Image is shot using a drone.

(Photo via Arctic-Images via Getty Images)

Wongwian Yai, also spelled 'Wong Wian Yai' or 'Wongwien Yai', is a large roundabout (traffic circle) in Thon Buri, western bank of the Chao Phraya River in Bangkok, Thailand, where the Statue of King Taksin is situated. It is located in the district of Thon Buri and Khlong San in the centre of Bangkok, at the intersection of Prajadhipok/Inthara Phithak/Lat Ya/Somdet Phra Chao Taksin Roads. Nearby there is Wongwian Yai Station, historical commuter railway terminal to Mahachai and Mae Khlong (Samut Songkhram) in south-western suburb of Bangkok.

(Photo by Thanapol Marattana via Getty Images)

Tremola road, the world-famous serpentine road on slopes of the Val Tremola was created with the construction of the Gotthard pass road.

(Photo by Sandro Bisaro via Getty Images)

East Java, Indonesia - April 09, 2015: A bridge span across Java Sea. Its name is Suramadu bridge, span for 5 km.

(Photo by Fadil Aziz via Getty Images)

Top view of The Pearl (Perlan) shot using a drone, Reykjavik, Iceland. The Pearl (Perlan) is built on the top of huge tanks in which natural hot water is stored for heating Reykjavik. Restaurants, meeting halls and a museum are housed in the dome.

(Photo via Arctic-Images via Getty Images)

Arundel castle can be dated back to 1067 when it was established by Roger de Montgomery,he was the 1st to hold its Earldom of Arundel granted by William the Conqueror. The castle was damaged in the English Civil War and then restored in the 18th and 19th centuries. In 1846, Queen Victoria and her husband, Prince Albert, visited Arundel Castle for a few days, it has been the seat of the Dukes of Norfolk and their ancestors for over 850 years up to the present day,where they still live today.

(Photo by Andrew Thomas via Getty Images)

The Democracy monument is a public monument in the centre of Bangkok It is located at the heart of RajadamnoenAvenue. The monument is roughly halfway between Sanam Luang, the former royal cremation ground in front of Wat Phra Kaew, and the temple of the Golden Mount. It's built to commemorate the establishment a constitutional monarchy in 1932.

(Photo by Pathompat Meelarp via Getty Images)

Aerial image of SUV vehicle driving on a dusty road through a pine forest plantation in Australia, with Glasshouse Mountains in the distance.

(Photo via Getty Images)

Aerial view-section of Reykjavik in the winter, Iceland. Image is shot with a drone.

(Photo by Arctic-Images via Getty Images)

Drone shot above beachy head during sunrise

(Photo by Andrew Thomas via Getty Images)

Grass roofs on farmhouses shot using a drone, Bakkagerdi, Borgafjordur East, Iceland

(Photo by Arctic-Images via Getty Images)

Shot of frozen harbor in city

(Photo by Mathieu Colin / EyeEm via Getty Images)

Stunning Aerial Photo of Avalon Bay at Catalina Island in California, USA. Taken with a UAV Quadcopter.

(Photo by Aerial Hollywood via Getty Images)

Bonfires are a long time tradition on Iceland's New Years Eve, a great way to say goodbye to another year gone while you welcome a new one. Image is shot using a drone.

(Photo by Arctic-Images via Getty Images)


"It was law enforcement that was creating the dangerous situation out there [at Standing Rock]," Levine says. "If the FAA is concerned about safety, wouldn't it have been better to send a representative out there to talk to those drone pilots?"

Not all pilots will play by the FAA's drone rules, which are still less than a year old. But Waite says the agency must create a better system for drone pilots to get legal access to restricted airspace – whether it's for flying in a temporary "no drone zone" over a protest, like Levine did, or for general news-gathering and recreation.

"What really needs to occur is the process for granting access to airspace needs to become more automated. Why shouldn't I be able to pull up my smartphone, tap into an FAA app, and get on-demand access to the airspace?" Waite told Vocativ. "It's not gonna stay this way forever, but the basic problem here is that the FAA's system and their culture is still built around manned aviation."

The post Police Are Making It Impossible To Use Drones To Document Protests appeared first on Vocativ.

Read Full Story