Homeland Security splits with Justice Department on for-profit immigration prisons

A Homeland Security advisory board concluded Thursday that surging numbers of immigrants facing deportation will all but force federal authorities to continue relying on privately run detention facilities, even after the Justice Department said it would phase out its use of such prisons due in part to safety and security concerns.

The report, produced by an advisory council subcommittee formed within the agency after the Justice Department's announcement this summer, did not recommend that Immigration and Customs Enforcement stop using detention centers operated by for-profit corporations.

It did, however, highlight the advantages of ICE-run detention facilities, and it also called for greater oversight by ICE and decreased reliance on county jails to house detainees.

Nearly two-thirds of the nation's roughly 41,000 immigrant detainees are incarcerated at private facilities run by for-profit contractors. Another quarter are held in county jails. Just 10 percent are held in federal facilities.

RELATED: Where the wall already exists along the US-Mexico border

30 PHOTOS
Where the wall already exists along the US-Mexico border
See Gallery
Where the wall already exists along the US-Mexico border
A gap in the U.S.-Mexico border fence is seen outside Jacumba, California, United States, October 7, 2016. REUTERS/Mike Blake 
U.S. customs and border patrol officers inspect a vehicle entering the U.S. from Mexico at the border crossing in San Ysidro, California, United States, October 14, 2016. REUTERS/Mike Blake 
U.S. customs and border patrol officers inspect a vehicle entering the U.S. from Mexico at the border crossing in San Ysidro, California, United States, October 14, 2016. REUTERS/Mike Blake 
Men talk on a street in the town of Calexico, California, United States, October 8, 2016. REUTERS/Mike Blake 
A U.S. customs and border patrol officer stands at a border crossing in San Ysidro, California, United States, October 14, 2016. REUTERS/Mike Blake
Recent arrivals from Mexico wait to board a greyhound bus in San Ysidro, California, United States, October 14, 2016. REUTERS/Mike Blake
Highway 82 towards Douglas, Arizona is seen near Sonoita, Arizona, United States, October 10, 2016. REUTERS/Mike Blake 
Clouds float above the border towns of Nogales, Mexico and Nogales, Arizona, United States, October 9, 2016. REUTERS/Mike Blake 
A sign warning drivers that firearms and ammunition are prohibited in Mexico is seen at the U.S.-Mexico border in Nogales, Arizona, United States, October 9, 2016. REUTERS/Mike Blake
Buildings in Nogales, Mexico (R) are separated by a border fence from Nogales, Arizona, United Sates, October 9, 2016. REUTERS/Mike Blake
An abandoned car sits off the side of a road near Jacumba, California, United States, October 7, 2016. REUTERS/Mike Blake 
A worker makes his way through the water after setting up an irrigation system on an agricultural field, near Calexico, California, U.S. October 7, 2016. REUTERS/Mike Blake
An abandoned car sits off the side of a road near Jacumba, California, United States, October 7, 2016. REUTERS/Mike Blake 
A church at the Museum of History in Granite is seen in Felicity, California, United States, October 8, 2016. REUTERS/Mike Blake
A man drives a tractor plowing a field at sunrise near Calexico, California, United States, October 8, 2016. REUTERS/Mike Blake 
Residential homes are seen next to the fence that borders Mexico, in Douglas, Arizona, United States, October 10, 2016. REUTERS/Mike Blake
Pedestrians wait to cross the street in Calexico, California, Unites States, October 7, 2016. REUTERS/Mike Blake
The town of Bisbee is seen in Arizona, United States, October 10, 2016. REUTERS/Mike Blake
Pedestrians make their way into the the United States from Mexico at the pedestrian border in Nogales, Arizona, United States, October 9, 2016. REUTERS/Mike Blake
A roadside collection of alien dolls and toy UFO saucers is seen next to a roadside residence neat Jacumba, California, United States, October 7, 2016. REUTERS/Mike Blake
A road abruptly ends next to a sign for a cattle ranch near Douglas, Arizona, United States, October 10, 2016. REUTERS/Mike Blake
A boy rides an all-terrain vehicle next Mexican border along the Buttercup San Dunes in California, United States, October 8, 2016. REUTERS/Mike Blake
An old refurbished gas station is seen in Lowell, Arizona, United States, October 10, 2016. REUTERS/Mike Blake 
A man rides a tricycle past a grocery store in a town that borders Mexico, in San Luis Butter, California, United States, October 8, 2016. REUTERS/Mike Blake 
A U.S. customs and border patrol truck drives past the fence that marks the border between U.S. and Mexico, in Calexico, California, United States, October 8, 2016. REUTERS/Mike Blake
A truck drives west towards California along highway 8 near Gila Bend, Arizona, United States, October 10, 2016. REUTERS/Mike Blake
Electronic items are displayed in a shop window in Calexico, California, United States, October 7, 2016. REUTERS/Mike Blake 
A residential home is seen in Nogales, Arizona, United States, October 9, 2016. REUTERS/Mike Blake 
A fence separates the border towns of Nogales, Mexico (R) and Nogales, Arizona, United Sates, October 9, 2016. REUTERS/Mike Blake
HIDE CAPTION
SHOW CAPTION
of
SEE ALL
BACK TO SLIDE

"Fiscal considerations, combined with the need for realistic capacity to handle sudden increases in detention, indicate that DHS's use of private for-profit detention will continue," the subcommittee wrote in its report. "But continuation should come with improved and expanded ICE oversight, and with further exploration of other models to enhance ICE control, responsiveness and sense of accountability for daily operations at all detention facilities."

County jails, it added, were the "most problematic" facilities, prompting the subcommittee to conclude that "ICE should also seek ongoing ways to reduce reliance on detention in county jails."

Homeland Security, in a statement, said that "ICE leadership will review and consider" the report's recommendations.

The report comes at a sensitive time in the immigration debate: Although deportations have reached record levels under President Barack Obama, President-elect Donald Trump has vowed to vastly expand the number of deportations, and on the campaign trail characterized some Mexican immigrants as "rapists" and "criminals" deliberately sent across the border by Mexico.

The Supreme Court, meanwhile, heard arguments Wednesday in a case that could decide whether immigrant detainees held for at least six months are entitled to bail bond hearings to determine whether they are dangers or flight risks. The ruling, combined with Trump's pledges, could greatly increase the number of immigrants placed in detention.

RELATED: Judge deports man who was adopted as a child 38 years ago

5 PHOTOS
Judge deports man who was adopted as a child 38 years ago
See Gallery
Judge deports man who was adopted as a child 38 years ago

A federal judge in Tacoma has ordered the deportation of an Oregon man who was adopted from South Korea 38 years ago.

(Photo credit: KCPQ)

A federal judge in Tacoma has ordered the deportation of an Oregon man who was adopted from South Korea 38 years ago.

(Photo credit: KCPQ)

A federal judge in Tacoma has ordered the deportation of an Oregon man who was adopted from South Korea 38 years ago.

(Photo credit: KCPQ)

A federal judge in Tacoma has ordered the deportation of an Oregon man who was adopted from South Korea 38 years ago.

(Photo credit: KCPQ)

HIDE CAPTION
SHOW CAPTION
of
SEE ALL
BACK TO SLIDE

The American Civil Liberties Union, which represented detainees in the Supreme Court case, expressed disappointment in the report's findings.

"The Homeland Security Advisory Committee's report represents a missed opportunity for the Obama administration to leave office setting forth a more humane alternative to Trump's mass deportation plans," Carl Takei, a staff attorney with the ACLU's National Prison Project, said in a statement. "Instead, the committee has helped to cement President Obama's ugly legacy on detention and deportation, and laid the groundwork for further detention profiteering under President Trump."

The ACLU and other civil rights and immigration advocacy groups, as well as left-leaning lawmakers, have long opposed the use of private prison and detention facilities. Critics allege that private incarceration impedes transparency, hinders oversight and distorts the justice system by turning prisoners and detainees into commodities for corporations. Investigative reports by The Nation and Mother Jones also exposed a range of issues at privately run prisons.

In announcing the Justice Department's plans to curtail its use of private prisons, Deputy Assistant Attorney General Sally Yates cited an extensive review by the Justice Department's Office of the Inspector General, which found higher rates of security and safety incidents at private prisons compared to government-run facilities.

The Justice Department's phase-out of private prisons, however, was aided by a 12 percent drop in the federal prison population in the past three years and the fact that only 15 percent of federal prisoners are held in for-profit facilities.

By contrast, just a fraction of ICE detainees are held in federally owned facilities, and the detainee population has rapidly expanded, driven by migrants fleeing violence in Central America and record numbers of deportations carried out by the Obama administration. Between September and October alone, the number of immigrants apprehended at the border leaped by 12 percent, to 46,195 people in October from 39,501 in September, the subcommittee report said.

In fact, as the Justice Department's Bureau of Prisons was curtailing its use of privately run prisons this fall – some of them with troubling histories of alleged abuse – ICE was apparently entering negotiations to contract with the same facilities.

"Capacity to handle such surges, when policymakers determine that detention will be part of the response, cannot reasonably be maintained solely through the use of facilities staffed and operated by federal officers," the report said. "This leaves essentially two options for coping with sudden detention fluctuations: privately operated facilities or county jails."

RELATED: Pictures capture Kris Kobach's immigration plans

5 PHOTOS
Pictures capture Kris Kobach's immigration plans
See Gallery
Pictures capture Kris Kobach's immigration plans

U.S. President-elect Donald Trump stands with Kansas Secretary of State Kris Kobach before their meeting at Trump National Golf Club in Bedminster, New Jersey, U.S., November 20, 2016.

(REUTERS/Mike Segar)

President-elect Donald Trump and Kris Kobach, Kansas secretary of state, pose for a photo following their meeting with president-elect at Trump International Golf Club, November 20, 2016 in Bedminster Township, New Jersey. Trump and his transition team are in the process of filling cabinet and other high level positions for the new administration.

(Photo by Drew Angerer/Getty Images)

President-elect Donald Trump meets with Kris Kobach at the clubhouse of Trump National Golf Club November 20, 2016 in Bedminster, New Jersey.

(DON EMMERT/AFP/Getty Images)

President-elect Donald Trump and Kris Kobach, Kansas secretary of state, shake hands following their meeting with president-elect at Trump International Golf Club, November 20, 2016 in Bedminster Township, New Jersey. Trump and his transition team are in the process of filling cabinet and other high level positions for the new administration.

(Photo by Drew Angerer/Getty Images)

HIDE CAPTION
SHOW CAPTION
of
SEE ALL
BACK TO SLIDE

County jails pose particular challenges, the report found. They often do not meet ICE standards, and their administrators "can be resistant to changes in their practices in response to identified problems, in part because they do not wish to have sharp differences in treatment for different categories of detainees (ICE vs. local) held at the same facility."

Detention Watch Network, an immigration and detention advocacy group, called the findings "disappointing" but "not surprising," and cited ICE's apparent efforts to use the same facilities being abandoned by the Bureau of Prisons.

"We are outraged that the subcommittee has chosen to recommend small changes that clearly will not address the underlying abuses endemic to the detention system," Detention Watch Network policy director Mary Small said in a statement "The investigation's findings don't respond to the mountain of evidence against private prison facilities, which are rife with abuse, mismanagement and neglect."

The six-member subcommittee, part of the Homeland Security Advisory Committee, included former CIA Director William Webster and Marshall Fitz, a senior fellow at the left-leaning Center for American Progress, and it was led by former Drug Enforcement Administrator Karen Tandy. The members visited an ICE detention facility and another owned and operated by a private prison corporation and also interviewed ICE officials, private detention executives, federal law enforcement officials and immigrant rights groups.

Read Full Story

Sign up for Breaking News by AOL to get the latest breaking news alerts and updates delivered straight to your inbox.

Subscribe to our other newsletters

Emails may offer personalized content or ads. Learn more. You may unsubscribe any time.