The best spaghetti sauce, according to a taste test

When you’re looking for the absolute best, grocery shopping can be quite the ordeal. With dozens of brands, and hundreds of choices, from bacon to brownies, meatballs to mozzarella, it can be daunting to make the picks that will make your recipes sing. That’s where our sister site, Taste of Home comes in. Their culinary and editorial experts put 100+ products to the test. After undergoing a thorough review, their Best Loved Brands emerged.

spaghetti sauce

Finding the Best Spaghetti Sauce

When it comes to pasta sauce, we all enjoy the homemade stuff complete with the best secret ingredient, but we don’t always have the time. That’s why knowing a good store-bought brand is so crucial. A good jar of marinara can make weeknight dinners easy and delicious. During Taste of Home’s Best Love Brands Spaghetti Sauce test, 11 brands were tested—some standards and a few that were totally new to the team. Each pasta sauce was tested blindly and judged according to these criteria:

  • Flavor
  • Texture
  • Appearance

The right combination of tomato, garlic, herbs and olive oil is what makes a marinara sauce so satisfying. When ladled over your favorite pasta or used in a tasty baked pasta dish, the sauce can make the dish. After testing 11 brands, our team can confidently say that we’ve found our best-loved brand, the one that’ll make that spaghetti bake (and your lasagna, manicotti, chicken parmesan and more) really come to life. Check out our picks for what to stock in your pantry. When you’re ready to get cooking, try our favorite hack to make cooking pasta much easier.

First Place: Rao’s

The marinara that testers most wanted topping their plate of spaghetti and meatballs came from Rao’s. This sauce has great tomato flavor—very fresh and bright. Combined with the right balance of onion, garlic, pepper, basil, and oregano, it gave this sauce an authentic Italian taste. What made this sauce the top pick, though, was its spot-on texture—absolutely perfect for coating any pasta.

$7.99 for a 24-oz. jar; available at grocers nationwide and on Amazon.

Second Place: Frescorti

Garlic-lovers, this is the sauce for you. Frescorti offered a garlic-packed sauce with a good helping of onion and black pepper as well. The thicker texture was also notable—great for spooning over your favorite chicken parmesan.

$3.79 for a 26-oz. jar; available at select grocers nationwide.

Third Place: Francesco Rinaldi

For folks looking for an herb-filled sauce, be sure to grab a jar of Francesco Rinaldi sauce (bonus points: it’s less than $2.00 a jar!). This sauce had good basil and oregano flavor. Plus, the good texture—not too thick or thin—make it a good all-purpose sauce perfect for keeping in the pantry for quick dinners.

$1.99 for a 24-oz. jar; available at select grocers nationwide.

What to Make with Spaghetti Sauce

When it comes to a jar of pasta sauce, the options are vast. Want a quick dinner? Just stir in your favorite pasta and add a sprinkle of cheese. Whether you choose to go simple or elevated with your Italian dishes, we’re confident in recommending any of these sauces. Don’t stop with just the best spaghetti sauce! Stock your pantry and home with 40 of the most trusted brands in America.

The post The Best Spaghetti Sauce, According to a Taste Test appeared first on Reader's Digest.

71 PHOTOS
Good Eats: 71 simple Italian recipes
See Gallery
Good Eats: 71 simple Italian recipes

Wild Herb Ravioli by Martha Stewart

Get the recipe here.

Chicken Parmigiana by Now Eat This! Italian | Rocco DiSpirito

Get the recipe here.

Bucatini Carbonara by Food & Wine

Get the recipe here.

Shortcut Ravioli Lasagna by Prego

Get the recipe here.

Sweet Potato, Balsamic Onion and Soppressata Pizza by Food & Wine

Get the recipe here.

Cacio e Pepe by Now Eat This! Italian | Rocco DiSpirito

Get the recipe here.

All'Amatriciana with Extra Umami by Food & Wine 

Get the recipe here.

Caprese Salad by Now Eat This! Italy | Rocco DiSpirito

Get the recipe here.

Braised Chicken all'Arrabbiata by Food & Wine

Get the recipe here.

Fresh Chile Puttanesca by Food & Wine

Get the recipe here.

Hearty Minestrone Soup by Food & Wine

Get the recipe here.

Italian Sundried Tomato, Garlic and Rosemary Chicken Hoagies with Melted Fontina Sauce by An Edible Mosaic | Faith Gorsky

Get the recipe here.

Stuffed Italian Style Cubanelle Peppers by The Kitchen Prep | Dianna Muscari

Get the recipe here.

Penne with Asparagus, Sage and Peas by Food & Wine

Get the recipe here.

Clams and Beans by Kitchen Daily Editors

Get the recipe here.

Tiramisu by Fabio Viviani

Get the recipe here.

Chicken Marsala by Kitchen Joy | Amanda Joy McGovern

Get the recipe here.

Penne with Creamy Vodka Sauce by Campbell's Kitchen

Get the recipe here.

Fish al Cartoccio by Kitchen Daily Editors

Get the recipe here.

Focaccia by Kitchen Daily Editors

Get the recipe here.

Farfalle with Pesto Rosso, Eggplant and Ricotta Salata by The Foodie Physician | Sonali Ruder

Get the recipe here.

Sausage and Peppers by Now Eat This! Italy | Rocco DiSpirito

Get the recipe here.

Big Italian Salad by Food & Wine

Get the recipe here.

Moscato Meatball Skewers by Melanie Makes | Melanie Bauer

Get the recipe here.

Mini Deep Dish Pizzas by Martha Stewart

Get the recipe here.

Sunday Sauce by Food & Wine

Get the recipe here.

Rigatoni with Lemony Kale-and-Pecorino Pesto by Food & Wine

Get the recipe here.

Pan-Seared Calamari with Spicy Red Sauce by Kitchen Daily Editors

Get the recipe here.

Tuscan Bread Salad by Campbell's Kitchen

Get the recipe here.

Chicken Piccata by Chez Us | Denise Woodward and Lenny Ferreira

Get the recipe here.

Arugula Pesto, Ricotta, and Smoked Mozzarella Pizza by Kitchen Daily Editors

Get the recipe here.

Herb-Stuffed Turkey Thighs with White Wine Sauce (Tacchino Ripieno Con Salsa Al Vino Bianco) by Kitchen Daily Editors

Get the recipe here.

Mussels Stuffed with Mortadella by Kitchen Daily Editors

Get the recipe here.

Caprese Mac and Cheese by Simply Delicious | Alida Ryder

Get the recipe here.

Baked Shrimp Risotto by Food & Wine

Get the recipe here.

Oven-Roasted Porchetta by Kitchen Daily Editors

Get the recipe here.

Asparagus Ribbon Pizza Garnish & Glaze | Melanie Dueck

Get the recipe here.

Deconstructed Cassata by Kitchen Daily Editors

Get the recipe here.

Chicken Parmesan Bundles by Philadelphia Cream Cheese

Get the recipe here.

Turkey Sausage & Tortellini in Creamy Tomato Basil Sauce by Campbell's Kitchen

Get the recipe here.

Lemon, Parsley and Parmesan Plus Bread, Prosciutto and Egg by Martha Stewart

Get the recipe here.

Brussels Sprouts and Sausage Pizza by Bacon Egg & Cheese{cake} | Shelley Liu

Get the recipe here.

Homemade Parmesan Marinara by The Cookie Rookie | Becky Hardin

Get the recipe here.

Pasta with Guanciale, Radicchio and Ricotta by Food & Wine

Get the recipe here.

One Pot Spinach and Pea Pasta by Savory Nothings | Nora Rusev

Get the recipe here.

Panzanella by Kitchen Daily Editors

Get the recipe here.

Linguine with White Clam Sauce by Now Eat This! Italy | Rocco DiSpirito

Get the recipe here.

Chocolate Chestnut Torte by Kitchen Daily Editors

Get the recipe here.

Chicken Scarpariello by Food & Wine

Get the recipe here.

Potato Gnocchi with Mushroom Ragu by Food & Wine

Get the recipe here.

Shrimp, Asparagus & Tortellini in Lemon-Dill Scampi by Mom Foodie | Robin Gagnon

Get the recipe here.

Pappardelle with Tomatoes, Almonds and Parmesan by Food & Wine

Get the recipe here. 

Gelato di Gianduia by Kitchen Daily Editors

Get the recipe here.

Spaghetti and Meatballs by Gourmet

Get the recipe here.

Slow Cooker Balsamic Chicken Caprese by Well Plated by Erin | Erin Clarke

Get the recipe here.

Simply Lasagna by Kraft Shredded Cheese with a touch of Philadelphia

Get the recipe here.

Ricotta and Roasted Tomato Bruschetta with Pancetta by Food & Wine 

Get the recipe here.

Baked Mozzarella Chicken Rollups by The Cookie Rookie | Becky Hardin

Get the recipe here.

Roasted Red Pepper and Arugula Whole-Wheat Pizza by Marin Mama Cooks | Jackie Grandy

Get the recipe here.

Lemon-Stuffed Grilled Branzino by Food & Wine

Get the recipe here.

Linguine with Broccoli Rabe and Walnut Pesto by Food & Wine

Get the recipe here.

Lemon, Olive Oil and Almond Biscotti by Kitchen Daily Editors

Get the recipe here.

Mini Kale-Mushroom Calzones with Smoked Mozzarella by Food & Wine

Get the recipe here.

Spaghetti con Broccoli by Garnish & Glaze | Melanie Dueck

Get the recipe here.

Pasta Fagioli by Erren's Kitchen | Erren Hart

Get the recipe here.

Skillet Pizza by PureWow

Get the recipe here.

Spaghetti Pomodoro by Simply Sated | Susie Gall

Get the recipe here.

Toasted Pistachio-Cheese Arancini by Food & Wine

Get the recipe here.

Spaghetti with Smoky Eggplant Sauce by Food & Wine

Get the recipe here.

Orecchiette with Sausage and Broccoli Rabe by Now Eat This! Italy | Rocco DiSpirito

Get the recipe here.

5-Ingredient Gluten-Free Sweet Potato Gnocchi by Heartbeet Kitchen | Amanda Paa

Get the recipe here.

HIDE CAPTION
SHOW CAPTION
of
SEE ALL
BACK TO SLIDE

Read Full Story

Sign up for the Best Bites by AOL newsletter to get the most delicious recipes and hottest food trends delivered straight to your inbox every day.

Subscribe to our other newsletters

Emails may offer personalized content or ads. Learn more. You may unsubscribe any time.