12 real women on their biggest renovation regret ever

Home renovations: We Pin for them, pine for them...and make ourselves sick with worry over all the expensive decisions we may later regret. But planning for your next project will be infinitely easier if you know which common pitfalls to look out for. Below, our friends and family spill on their biggest reno lessons learned.

Renovation regrets
See Gallery
Renovation regrets

When Wood Is a Wouldn’t 

“We decided to get real hardwood plank floors installed in our new kitchen rather than laminate flooring and it was honestly the worst decision ever. The real wood was supposed to be able to hold up against everything, but it dents and dings and scratches like crazy. Meanwhile, the faux hardwood floors we installed in the office have lasted ten years and still look like new!” –Rachel, NY

Dirty Dancing

“I wish I had known that no matter how clean your contractor keeps things, dust still gets everywhere. I ruined a pair of suede shoes by leaving them in the work zone.” –Martha, MN

Cabinet Disappointments

“When it comes to kitchen cabinets, get the best quality you can afford—plywood boxes and solid wood fronts with high-end closers, rollers and hardware. Our inexpensive stuff started to wear out day one.” –Andie, NY

The Bathtub That Never Was

“When we redid our upstairs bathroom, I let my husband convince me that adding a walk-in shower would be a better use of space and money than the antique claw-foot tub I’d been pining for. Every time I walk into that bathroom, I think, I wish I had a bathtub. Splurge—and in some cases, fight—for your dream pieces.” –Nancy, MA

DIY Oh Why

“Never take on a task without knowing what you’re getting into. I decided to remove grass cloth off the wall on my own and the entire plaster wall underneath fell apart. I had to learn how to plaster and skim...and eventually hire a handyman to finish the job. In the end, SO much extra time and money to DIY!” –Katy, CA

Counter Intuitive

“In retrospect, I regret my butcher block countertops. They were gorgeous and cheap AF, but over by the sink, it's really hard to keep them dry (and, in turn, rot and mold-free).” –Jill, PA

Stainless Isn’t Painless

“I chose classic stainless-steel appliances for the kitchen (fridge, oven, etc.), and while they all look stunning immediately after they’ve been cleaned, the second someone touches them, there are visible fingerprints, like, everywhere. In retrospect, I wish I’d picked a more low-maintenance material.” –Abby, TX 

Lonely Island

“We had a shiny new island installed in our kitchen, and while useful and beautiful, it gives us so much less space to move around in. Ultimately, it wasn’t worth the trade-off—and we’re stuck with it!” –Corley, LA

Natural Selection

“Our soapstone countertops are very high-end, but very high maintenance—they need regular oiling/waxing, and without the maintenance they can look very splotchy, old and discolored. The oil looks oily, the wax looks waxy and it’s very cold to the touch in winter. I’m a purist, but the fact is synthetic is sometimes the best decision for counters.” –Mallory, NY

Bring It on Home Now

“Never make decisions in store: Get samples and take them home to see how they look in your house with other furniture, finishes and lighting. We ordered our flooring finish in-showroom, and had to cancel the order after we returned home with the chip in hand: It was all wrong in person paired with the beams on our ceiling!” –Annie, CA

Hood Winked

“Before you buy an appliance, double-check the store’s return policy. We got an oven hood that was just slightly the wrong size and couldn’t take it back, since the store didn’t do returns on 'major appliances.'” –Stephanie, NY

Scrimper’s Whimpers 

“Over the years, I’ve occasionally regretted going with the cheaper options I’ve chosen—looking back, it would have been really nice to have sprung for heated floors in the bathroom.” –Marjie, VA


Refresh your home for less!

Nordstrom Home Sale Section
See Gallery

Read Full Story

Sign up for the Best Bites by AOL newsletter to get the most delicious recipes and hottest food trends delivered straight to your inbox every day.

Subscribe to our other newsletters

Emails may offer personalized content or ads. Learn more. You may unsubscribe any time.