This is America’s No. 1 Thanksgiving pie (Hint: It’s not pumpkin!)

 

Most would agree that Thanksgiving is for friends, family, and—most importantly—food. In other words, this is the one time of year when it’s acceptable to stuff your face with turkey, rolls, and green bean casserole. (And here’s exactly how to eat as much as humanly possible.) But no matter which way you slice it, nothing says Thanksgiving quite like a good, old-fashioned pie.

Some families prefer a perfect piece of pecan, while others like a satisfying slice of sweet potato. But which pie takes the cake, so to speak? Pillsbury, America’s go-to company for all things baked, aggregated data from searches on its website to reveal which pie holds the biggest piece of the country’s heart. And their results aren’t what you might expect.

17 PHOTOS
The best and worst Thanksgiving foods for your health
See Gallery
The best and worst Thanksgiving foods for your health

BEST: White turkey meat

Nutrition (per 3 oz. serving): 115 calories and 7 grams of fat

(Getty)

WORST: Dark turkey meat

Nutrition (per 3 oz. serving): 160 calories and 11 grams of fat

(Getty)

BEST: Green bean casserole

Nutrition (per 3/4 cup serving): 161 calories, 9 g fat 

(Getty)

WORST: Sweet potato casserole

Nutrition (per 3/4 cup serving): 285 calories, 5 g fat 

BEST: Dinner roll with dollop of butter

Nutrition (1 roll): 140 calories and 4.5 g fat

WORST: Stuffing

Nutrition (per 3/4 cup serving): 371 calories and 19 g of fat 

(Getty)

BEST: Gravy

Nutrition (per 1/4 cup serving): 30 calories and 1.5 g fat

(Getty)

WORST: Cranberry jelly

Nutrition (per 1/4 cup serving): 110 calories and 0 g fat

(Getty)

BEST: Pumpkin pie

Nutrition (per slice -- 1/8 of a 9 inch pie): 316 calories and 14 g of fat

(Getty)

WORST: Apple pie

Nutrition (per slice -- 1/8 of a 9 inch pie): 411 calories and 19 g of fat

BEST: Brussel sprouts 

Nutrition (per 1 cup serving): 56 calories and 4 g protein

(Getty)

WORST: Mashed potatoes with whole milk and margarine

Nutrition (per 1 cup serving): 237 calories and 9 g of fat

(Getty)

BEST: Cooked spinach

Nutrition (per 1 cup serving): 41 calories and 5 g of protein

(Getty)

WORST: Corn bread

Nutrition (1 piece -- around 60 oz.): 198 calories and 9 g of fat

(Getty)

BEST: Corn with a pat of butter

Nutrition (per 1 cup serving): 95 calories and 5 g of fiber

(Getty)

WORST: Mac and cheese

Nutrition (per 1 cup of serving): 310 calories and 9 g of fat

(Getty)

HIDE CAPTION
SHOW CAPTION
of
SEE ALL
BACK TO SLIDE

Overall, apple pie took the No. 1 spot as the America’s favorite post-Thanksgiving dinner indulgence. Pillsbury’s data showed that 32.1 percent of people searched for this classic American treat. Surprised? Learn more about how apple pie became America’s favorite dessert.

Pumpkin pie came in a distance second place, making up 23.2 percent of searches on the website. Chicken pot pie (22.1 percent), pecan pie (16.6 percent), and sweet potato pie (6 percent) were among the top five favorite pies, respectively.

Did your favorite make the list? If not, feel free to chow down anyway. It may be called “Turkey Day,” but no holiday dinner is complete without pie. That’s not the only American ritual we love, though; you’ll want to steal these 9 meaningful Thanksgiving traditions for your own family.

The post This Is America’s No. 1 Thanksgiving Pie (Hint: It’s Not Pumpkin!) appeared first on Reader's Digest.

24 PHOTOS
Cocktails perfect for your Thanksgiving meal
See Gallery
Cocktails perfect for your Thanksgiving meal
Pumpkin Pie Martini

Smooth, creamy and rich; this drink is essentially dessert in a glass. Serves 4.

Ingredients:

6 ounces Vodka
4 ounces Rum
2 ounces Half and Half (or full fat coconut milk for a non-dairy option)
6 TBS Pumpkin Puree (canned or homemade)
4 tbsp Maple Syrup
¼ tsp Pure Vanilla Extract
1 tsp Pumpkin Pie Spice
A few Ice Cubes

Rim
Maple Syrup
1 Graham Cracker

Directions:

For the Rim: Crush graham cracker to a fine dust. Dip the chilled martini glass in a shallow bowl of maple syrup, then dip glass into a shallow bowl of the graham cracker. Set aside.

For the Martini: In a cocktail shaker, shake the ice and remaining cocktail ingredients. 

Pour cocktail into the martini glass through a strainer and enjoy! 

(Thumbtack Chef Niko Paranomos)

Apple Cider Mimosa with Cinnamon Sugar Rim

Whether you're celebrating the holiday or just a hardcore brunch-anista, these mimosas are a perfect treat for any occasion. Serves 4.

Ingredients:

4 tbsp. sugar in the raw
1 tsp. ground cinnamon
1 cup apple cider
1 bottle champagne or prosecco

Directions:

In a shallow bowl, combine sugar and cinnamon. In a separate shallow bowl, place a bit of water. Dip champagne glass in the water bowl till the rim is wet, then dip into the cinnamon sugar mixture. Tilt the champagne glass and slowly fill 1/2 of the way with champagne, then top with apple cider. 

(Thumbtack Chef Niko Paranomos)

Truly Thankful Truly Pom-Apple Fizz

Ingredients:

1 oz. cranberry juice
1 oz. apple cider
1 oz. Cinnamon Spice Tea Infused Cognac*
6 oz. Truly Spiked & Sparkling Pomegranate
Rosemary sprig
Apple slices

Directions:

Combine cranberry juice, apple cider and cinnamon spice tea infused cognac in a large rocks glass with ice. Top with Truly Spiked & Sparkling Pomegranate. Garnish with a rosemary sprig and apple slices. 

Black Raspberry Mimosa

Chambord, a French Black Raspberry liqueur, will carry the Black Friday theme through with an elegant and simple way to elevate your favorite Korbel.

Ingredients:

½ oz. Chambord Black Raspberry Liqueur
4 oz. Korbel California Champagne

Directions:

Pour Chambord into a champagne flute and top with Korbel.

Pomegranate Ginger Cosmopolitan

Ingredients:

.75 oz. Cointreau
1 oz. Vodka
.75 oz. Fresh lime juice
.75 oz. pomegranate juice
2 slices fresh ginger

Directions:

Muddle the ginger in the bottom of a shaker tin. Add all remaining ingredients. Shake and fine strain into a cocktail glass. Garnish with a lime wheel.

Spiced Cider

Ingredients:

1 oz. Cointreau
2 oz. Mount Gay Black Barrel Rum
4 oz. Hot Apple Cider
9 Drops Aromatic Bitters
½ squeezed lemon

Directions:

Combine Cointreau, Mount Gay Black Barrel Rum, Aromatic Bitters, Apple Cider and lemon in glass mug. Garnish with cinnamon stick and serve hot.

The Cranberry Mule

Ingredients:

1.5 oz. Captain Morgan Original Spiced Rum
.5 oz. Fresh Lime Juice
2 oz. Cranberry Juice
6 oz. Ginger Ale
1 Rosemary Sprig, for garnish
4-5 Fresh Cranberries, for garnish

Directions:

In a Captain Morgan Tankard glass filled with ice, combine Captain Morgan Original Spiced

Rum, lime juice, and cranberry juice. Top with ginger ale. Garnish with rosemary and cranberries. Light rosemary with a match until smoking.

Pilgrim’s Punch (Created by Pamela Wiznitzer of Seamstress NYC)

Ingredients:

1 oz Kerrygold Irish Cream Liqueur
1 oz Aged rum
4-5 ounces boiling hot chai tea 

Directions:

Add 1 oz of Kerrygold to 6 oz of fresh heavy cream. Shake (or stir) until its becomes thick and turns into whipped cream. Top it onto the drink and finish with a dash of allspice and nutmeg

Cranberry Cosmopolita (Created by Amie Ward of R. Bar, Baltimore, MD)

Ingredients:

1.5 oz. Rosa 22
3/4 oz. lime cordial
3/4 oz. cranberry citrus syrup
Dash of Scrappy’s lime bitters
Cranberry fruit leather (for garnish)

Hey Pumpkin (Created by Smitty of South House, Jersey City, NJ)

Ingredients:

2.oz Slow & Low Rock & Rye Whiskey
.75 aquafaba 
.75 espresso pumpkin spice syrup
.75 Lemon juice 

Full Harvest (Created by Shaun Meglen of Péché, Austin, TX)

Ingredients:

2 oz Basil Hayden
0.75 oz Limoncello
0.5 oz Orange juice
0.25 oz Lemon juice
.25 oz Cinnamon simple syrup
1 dash of Cranberry bitters
1 egg White

Directions:

Shake hard with ice. Serve up in coupe glass.

Share the Pear (Created by Shaun Meglen of Péché, Austin, TX)

Ingredients:

1.5 oz Osborne Fino sherry
.75 oz Saint George Spiced Pear
3 scoops of good quality vanilla ice cream (Péché makes theirs in-house)

Directions:

Add all ingredients to blender and blend until incorporated. Pour in glass, garnish with cinnamon and serve.

Blessed Thistle (Created by Estelle Bossy, Del Posto)

Ingredients:
1 ½ oz Cynar
½ oz Laird’s Apple Brandy
½ oz Drambuie
¼ oz Lime
Pinch sea salt
4 oz Spiced Hibiscus Tea*

Garnish: 
Dehydrated Lime Wheel, Bay Leaf, Amaranth Flower

Directions:
Combine ingredients in a teacup, stir gently
*Spiced Hibiscus Tea--steep ingredients for 10 min, then strain: 16 oz boiling water, 2 Hibiscus tea bags or 1 tbsp dried Hibiscus flowers, 1/2 tbsp dried Rosebuds, 1/2 vanilla bean, 1 cinnamon stick

Alpine Fever (Created by Alan Lam, Eataly in New York City)

Ingredients:
1 oz Braulio
1 oz Vecchia Romagna Brandy
Honey Lemon Granita*
Topped with Lurisia Gazzosa

Garnish: 
Juniper Berries, Mint and Lemon Zest  

Directions:
Combine 1 Tbs. honey, ¼ water in a heated saucepan to dissolve honey. Once mixture has cooled, stir in the juice of ¼ lemon. Freeze. After an hour, scrape and stir the mixture break up the ice crystals. Once firm, stir and scrape again into glassware with Braulio and Vecchia Romagna Brandy. Top cocktail with Lurisia Gazzosa.

Earthly Delights (Created by Ryan Herzog, Sweet Polly)  

Ingredients:
1 oz Averna
1.5 oz Wild Turkey Rye
.5 oz Fresh lemon juice
.75 oz Deniset-Klainguer Fraise des Bois
.75 oz Stumptown Cold Shot

Garnish: 
Blood orange filled with pomegranate seeds and rosemary sprigs

Directions:
Combine all Wild Turkey Rye, Averna, Fresh Lemon Juice, Deniset-Klainguer Fraise des Bois and Stumptown Cold Shot in a shaker with ice. Shake and strain into glass and garnish with a blood orange, pomegranate seeds and rosemary sprigs.

Old World Toddy (Created by Willy Shine, Jägermeister Brand Meister)

Ingredients:
1 part Jägermeister
1/2 part Lemon juice
1/2 part Spiced pomegranate honey* 
2 part Fresh apple cider
1 part Jamaican Aged Rum (Appleton Reserve)
1 part water

Directions:
Combine and batch all the ingredients & heat up over stove. To make spiced honey, steep clove, fresh ginger pieces & cracked cinnamon sticks in POM like making a tea. Bring to boil and let sit to chill. Fine strain the liquid and add equal parts honey. Keep refrigerated  

Agave Flip

Ingredients:
1.5 oz. Patrón Extra Añejo 
.75 oz. Lemon juice
.5 oz. PX Sherry or Malmsey Madeira wine
.5 oz. Maple or Agave Syrup
1 Whole egg

Directions:
Combine ingredients in a cocktail shaker and shake with ice to chill.
Strain into the small tin and dry shake (without ice) to continue emulsification.
Strain into a chilled coupe glass
Garnish with pomegranate slices skewered and star anise.
Top with powdered sugar

Hot Buttered Boulevardier (Created by Kate Bolton, Bartender at Maven in Portland, Oregon)

Ingredients:
3/4 oz Campari
1 1/2 oz Russel’s Reserve Bourbon
3/4 oz. Cinzano 1757
1 Tbsp. Maple Butter*
1 dash Vanilla Extract 
3 oz boiling water

Directions:
In a footed glass or mug add bourbon, Campari, sweet vermouth, maple butter and vanilla.  Pour hot water on top and stir briskly until butter is dissolved and well integrated. Garnish with a clover-studded half orange wheel and a star anise pod
 

*Maple Butter: 
1/2 lb (2 sticks) unsalted butter
5 Tbsp Maple Syrup
1/2 tsp. salt
Using a robot coup or Vitamix whip all ingredients until smooth.

The Founder’s Delight (Created by Brian MacGregor)

Ingredients:
2 oz. Highland Park Magnus
1 oz. Campari
1 oz. Sweet Vermouth

Directions:
Stir and strain over large ice. Serve in a rocks glass and garnish with a broad orange peel.

Apple Orchard (Created by Pete Canny, The Wayland and Goodnight Sonny)

Ingredients:
2 oz. The Macallan Sherry Oak 12 Years Old
¼ oz. Cinnamon-Infused Agave
2 Dashes Angostura Bitters

Directions:
Stir and strain over a large ice cube in a rocks glass and garnish with a fresh red apple slice and a little fresh grated cinnamon on top of an apple slice.

Pomegranate Mule Punch (Created by Natalie Migliarini of @BeautifulBooze)

Ingredients:
1 bottle of NOLET’S Silver Gin
20 ounces of ginger beer
1 cup of lime juice
½ cup pomegranate syrup (or to taste)*
1 lime (sliced)
Rosemary sprigs
Pomegranate seeds

Directions:
Fill a punch bowl with ice
Combine all of the ingredients
Stir to mix everything together
Garnish with lime slices, rosemary sprigs and pomegranate seeds

*Pomegranate Syrup:
Ingredients:
1 cup sugar
1 cup pomegranate juice

Method:
Combine sugar and pomegranate juice in a saucepan on high heat
Stir continuously until all the sugar granules have dissolved
Sit in the fridge or in a cool space to allow it to cool down

Callie Collection Harvest Mulled Wine

Materials:

Muslin Bags or Neutral Colored Cheese Cloth
Bakers Twine
Dried Herb Springs, or fresh whole Cinnamon Sticks for garnish
Pretty Hang Tags or Recycled Paper for Recipe

Ingredients:

3-4 Cinnamon Sticks
1 Vanilla Bean
30 Cloves
20 Allspice Berries
3 Black Cardamom Pods
Optional: Fresh Orange Slices or Dried Orange Peels
Optional: Garnish: Star Anise

Directions:

Prepare your Callie Collection Fresh Red Blend x Harvest Mulled Wine recipe cards in advance on pretty paper with a little handwritten note for a special touch

Measure out appropriate number of spices required per each bottle of Callie Collection Red Blend as it pertains to the recipe

Fill each muslin bag with appropriate amount of ingredients

Loop twine through recipe card and special note

Fasten with a tie or pretty fall colored ribbon

The perfect gift is ready to go for all of your upcoming fall / winter party needs!

Orange Cinnamon Blossom Wine

Ingredients

1 bottle of Santa Margherita Prosecco Superiore

1/2 lemon

1/2 orange

1 tablespoon honey

1/4 cup sugar

3 whole cloves

3 whole allspice

2 cinnamon sticks

Directions

Rinse lemon and orange and thinly slice them, discarding seeds; quarter the orange slices.

Put fruit in a 4- to 5-quart pan.

Add honey, sugar (use the smaller amount if you prefer drinks on the tart side, the larger if you want a sweeter flavor), cloves and allspice. 

With a knife, cut the cinnamon sticks lengthwise into thinner strips.

Add cinnamon and 2 cups water to pan; bring to a boil over high heat, then reduce heat and boil gently for 5 minutes.

Pour Prosecco into hot citrus base and heat until steaming, about 8 minutes. 

Keep warm over low heat. Ladle into heatproof cups or wine glasses.

HIDE CAPTION
SHOW CAPTION
of
SEE ALL
BACK TO SLIDE

Read Full Story

Sign up for the Best Bites by AOL newsletter to get the most delicious recipes and hottest food trends delivered straight to your inbox every day.

Subscribe to our other newsletters

Emails may offer personalized content or ads. Learn more. You may unsubscribe any time.