J. Crew customers have one major complaint — and it reveals why the company is falling apart

  • J. Crew is struggling – same-store sales have been down at J.Crew for the past three years, dropping by 8% in 2016 following a 10% decrease the year before.
  • The store has increasingly lost out to fast fashion stores such as Zara and H&M.
  • To win back customers it has lowered prices but customers say this is destroying the brand's image and sacrificing quality.

J. Crew is trying to win back customers with lower prices, but it's backfiring.

Furious customers are complaining that J. Crew is destroying the quality of its clothing. This could help explain why so many customers are fleeing the brand.  

The most popular stores in America:

50 PHOTOS
The most popular stores in America
See Gallery
The most popular stores in America

ALABAMA: Target 

Photo credit: Reuters 

ALASKA: Walmart

Photo credit: Reuters 

ARKANSAS: Target 

Photo credit: Reuters 

ARIZONA: Walmart 

Photo credit: Reuters 

CALIFORNIA: Target  

Photo credit: Getty

COLORADO: Target 

Photo credit: Reuters 

CONNECTICUT: Target 

Photo credit: Reuters 

WASHINGTON, D.C.: Macy's 

Photo credit: Reuters 

DELAWARE: Target 

Photo credit: Reuters 

FLORIDA: UNIQLO 

Photo credit: Reuters 

GEORGIA: Target 

Photo credit: Reuters 

HAWAII: Walmart 

Photo credit: Reuters 

IOWA: Target

Photo credit: Reuters 

IDAHO: Fred Meyer 

Photo credit: Getty

ILLINOIS: UNIQLO 

Photo credit: Getty

INDIANA: Target 

Photo credit: Getty

KANSAS: Target 

Photo credit: Getty

KENTUCKY: Target 

Photo credit: Getty

LOUISIANA: Target

Photo credit: Getty

MASSACHUSETTS: Primark 

Photo credit: Reuters 

MARYLAND: Walmart

Photo credit: Reuters 

MAINE: Target 

Photo credit: Reuters 

MICHIGAN: Walmart 

Photo credit: Reuters 

MINNESOTA: Target 

Photo credit: Getty 

MISSOURI: Target

Photo credit: Shutterstock 

MISSISSIPPI: Target 

Photo credit: Getty

MONTANA: Walmart

Photo credit: Getty 

NORTH CAROLINA: Target 

Photo credit: Reuters 

NORTH DAKOTA: Target 

Photo credit: Reuters 

NEBRASKA: Target 

Photo credit: Reuters 

NEW HAMPSHIRE: Walmart 

Photo credit: Reuters 

NEW JERSEY: Target 

Photo credit: Reuters 

NEW MEXICO: Walmart 

Photo credit: Reuters 

NEVADA: Walmart 

Photo credit: Reuters 

NEW YORK: Bloomingdale's 

Photo credit: Reuters 

OHIO: Walmart

Photo credit: Reuters 

OKLAHOMA: Target 

Photo credit: Reuters 

PENNSYLVANIA: Walmart 

Photo credit: Reuters 

RHODE ISLAND: Target 

Photo credit: Reuters 

SOUTH CAROLINA: Walmart 

Photo credit: Getty 

SOUTH DAKOTA: Walmart 

Photo credit: Getty 

TENNESSEE: Target 

Photo credit: Getty

TEXAS: Target 

Photo credit: Getty 

UTAH: Walmart 

Photo credit: Getty

VIRGINIA: Bloomingdale's

Photo credit: Reuters 

VERMONT: Walmart 

Photo credit: Reuters 

WASHINGTON: Fred Meyer 

Photo credit: Getty 

WISCONSIN: Target 

Photo credit: Getty 

WEST VIRGINIA: Walmart 

Photo credit: Reuters 

WYOMING: Walmart

Photo credit: Reuters 

HIDE CAPTION
SHOW CAPTION
of
SEE ALL
BACK TO SLIDE

"J. Crew is turning into H&M," one customer wrote on the store's Facebook page. "Generic, cheap, and wannabe trendy. Quality has slipped a lot," she said.  

J. Crew is struggling –  same-store sales have been down at J.Crew for the past three years, dropping by 8% in 2016 following a 10% decrease the year before. In its most recent quarter, sales dropped by 12%. Fast fashion retailers such as Zara, on the other hand, have dominated the market by luring customers in with cheap prices and a constant turnover of products. Zara's parent company, Inditex, reported a 9% increase in gross profit during the first nine months of 2017.

To fight back, J. Crew has made a push to lower prices. Former CEO Mickey Drexler, said in an interview with The Wall Street Journal in May 2017, that they would be lowering prices on around 300 items but assured customers that this wouldn't impact quality. 

But the response on social media suggests otherwise. 

Some are claiming they won't shop in the store again.

Retail expert Neil Saunders claims that while quality has decreased, prices haven't.

J. Crew did not immediately respond to Business Insider's request for comment. 

During the early to mid-2000's, at its peak and under the creative direction of Jenna Lyons,  J. Crew became a stylish and desirable brand but it also became more expensive. 

In April 2015, writer Tricia Louvar wrote an open letter to J. Crew's Lyons, onThe Hairpin, prefacing it with "you are pretty dope." However, all dopeness aside, the clothes J. Crew was selling were unaffordable and not practical, Louvar said.

"If only I, an ordinary mother on a modest income, could afford to wear a $400 cashmere skirt, silk barely-there blouse and belt to a one-time business-casual event," she wrote.

Former CEO Mickey Drexler said that the biggest mistake the company made in the past few years was raising prices at a time when customers were increasingly cost-conscious. 

"We became a little too elitist in our attitude," Drexler told The Wall Street Journal in an interview May 2017. "We gave a perception of being a higher-priced company than we were — in our catalog, online, and in our general presentation. Very big mistake," he said. 

Now, as the company tries to execute a turnaround, it may be experiencing an identity crisis. Customers don't want to fork out $300 for a sequined blazer like the old days but they also want to know that they are shopping at a premium brand. 

On one Instagram post, a commenter wrote: "Bring the old J. Crew back," in response to a photo of its new denim trench coat. 

"It's no wonder you’re sales have been plummeting. You all need to update and freshen up your style/collections," another wrote.

NOW WATCH: Take a look inside Amazon's grocery store of the future — there are no cashiers, registers or lines

See Also:

SEE ALSO: Before-and-after photos show how much J.Crew has changed in the last 35 years

Read Full Story

Can't get enough business news?

Sign up for Finance Report by AOL and get everything from retailer news to the latest IPOs delivered directly to your inbox daily!

Subscribe to our other newsletters

Emails may offer personalized content or ads. Learn more. You may unsubscribe any time.