US nursing home chain faces landlord showdown over default

CHICAGO (Reuters) - The fate of one of the largest U.S. nursing home operators, HCR ManorCare, will reach a critical court deadline on Thursday in a battle over months of unpaid rent, a growing problem in an industry where eviction would put thousands of elderly out on the street.

Many nursing home chains spun off their properties to real estate companies over the last decade to unlock value. Now those landlords need to deal with operators behind on their rent without harming thousands of elderly residents.

In a lawsuit filed in August, HCR ManorCare's landlord, Quality Care Properties Inc, said the chain owes more than $300 million in rent at its 292 skilled nursing and assisted living locations.

ManorCare has until Oct. 18 to respond to the lawsuit Quality Care filed seeking to replace management with a court-appointed receiver who would oversee everything from laundry and meals to patient care at ManorCare's facilities.

Generally, a landlord can evict a tenant who fails to pay rent.

"However, because the leased properties care for approximately 30,000 patients - many of whom are elderly, vulnerable and require specialized care - abrupt eviction could cause substantial harm," Quality Care said in its lawsuit, filed in California state court on August 17.

RELATED: Humanoid robots serve nursing homes in Japan

29 PHOTOS
Japan's humanoid robots in nursing homes
See Gallery
Japan's humanoid robots in nursing homes
NATORI, JAPAN - MARCH 13: The operator watches and talks with the elderly user by using the remote-controlled humanoid 'Telenoid' at the nursing home 'Urayasu' on March 13, 2017 in Natori, Japan. It is the first case of Telenoid to be installed at a nursing home in the world. The 2.7 kg humanoid enables the operator to communicate with the elderly over long distance with its camera and microphone capturing the voice and movements of an operator, and projecting them through the body to the elderly. The nursing home staff have seen the elderly, especially with dementia, have become more active and positive to communicate when they communicate with the Telenoids. Telenoid costs 1,000,000 JPY (approx. 8,700 USD,) and can be rented for 50,000 JPY (about 435USD) per month. (Photo by Taro Karibe/Getty Images)
NATORI, JAPAN - MARCH 13: The face of the remote-controlled humanoid 'Telenoid' at the nursing home 'Urayasu' on March 13, 2017 in Natori, Japan. It is the first case of Telenoid to be installed at a nursing home in the world. The 2.7 kg humanoid enables the operator to communicate with the elderly over long distance with its camera and microphone capturing the voice and movements of an operator, and projecting them through the body to the elderly. The nursing home staff have seen the elderly, especially with dementia, have become more active and positive to communicate when they communicate with the Telenoids. Telenoid costs 1,000,000 JPY (approx. 8,700 USD,) and can be rented for 50,000 JPY (about 435USD) per month. (Photo by Taro Karibe/Getty Images)
NATORI, JAPAN - MARCH 13: An elderly user enjoy talking with the remote-controlled humanoid 'Telenoid' at the nursing home 'Urayasu' on March 13, 2017 in Natori, Japan. It is the first case of Telenoid to be installed at a nursing home in the world. The 2.7 kg humanoid enables the operator to communicate with the elderly over long distance with its camera and microphone capturing the voice and movements of an operator, and projecting them through the body to the elderly. The nursing home staff have seen the elderly, especially with dementia, have become more active and positive to communicate when they communicate with the Telenoids. Telenoid costs 1,000,000 JPY (approx. 8,700 USD,) and can be rented for 50,000 JPY (about 435USD) per month. (Photo by Taro Karibe/Getty Images)
NATORI, JAPAN - MARCH 13: The elderly user sings a song with the remote-controlled humanoid 'Telenoid' at the nursing home 'Urayasu' on March 13, 2017 in Natori, Japan. It is the first case of Telenoid to be installed at a nursing home in the world. The 2.7 kg humanoid enables the operator to communicate with the elderly over long distance with its camera and microphone capturing the voice and movements of an operator, and projecting them through the body to the elderly. The nursing home staff have seen the elderly, especially with dementia, have become more active and positive to communicate when they communicate with the Telenoids. Telenoid costs 1,000,000 JPY (approx. 8,700 USD,) and can be rented for 50,000 JPY (about 435USD) per month. (Photo by Taro Karibe/Getty Images)
NATORI, JAPAN - MARCH 13: Elderly users and the remote-controlled humanoid 'Telenoid' at the nursing home 'Urayasu' on March 13, 2017 in Natori, Japan. It is the first case of Telenoid to be installed at a nursing home in the world. The 2.7 kg humanoid enables the operator to communicate with the elderly over long distance with its camera and microphone capturing the voice and movements of an operator, and projecting them through the body to the elderly. The nursing home staff have seen the elderly, especially with dementia, have become more active and positive to communicate when they communicate with the Telenoids. Telenoid costs 1,000,000 JPY (approx. 8,700 USD,) and can be rented for 50,000 JPY (about 435USD) per month. (Photo by Taro Karibe/Getty Images)
NATORI, JAPAN - MARCH 13: An elderly user enjoy talking with the remote-controlled humanoid 'Telenoid' at the nursing home 'Urayasu' on March 13, 2017 in Natori, Japan. It is the first case of Telenoid to be installed at a nursing home in the world. The 2.7 kg humanoid enables the operator to communicate with the elderly over long distance with its camera and microphone capturing the voice and movements of an operator, and projecting them through the body to the elderly. The nursing home staff have seen the elderly, especially with dementia, have become more active and positive to communicate when they communicate with the Telenoids. Telenoid costs 1,000,000 JPY (approx. 8,700 USD,) and can be rented for 50,000 JPY (about 435USD) per month. (Photo by Taro Karibe/Getty Images)
NATORI, JAPAN - MARCH 13: An operator staff shows the remote-controlled humanoid 'Telenoid' at the nursing home 'Urayasu' on March 13, 2017 in Natori, Japan. It is the first case of Telenoid to be installed at a nursing home in the world. The 2.7 kg humanoid enables the operator to communicate with the elderly over long distance with its camera and microphone capturing the voice and movements of an operator, and projecting them through the body to the elderly. The nursing home staff have seen the elderly, especially with dementia, have become more active and positive to communicate when they communicate with the Telenoids. Telenoid costs 1,000,000 JPY (approx. 8,700 USD,) and can be rented for 50,000 JPY (about 435USD) per month. (Photo by Taro Karibe/Getty Images)
NATORI, JAPAN - MARCH 13: An operator staff shows the remote-controlled humanoid 'Telenoid' to an elderly user at the nursing home 'Urayasu' on March 13, 2017 in Natori, Japan. It is the first case of Telenoid to be installed at a nursing home in the world. The 2.7 kg humanoid enables the operator to communicate with the elderly over long distance with its camera and microphone capturing the voice and movements of an operator, and projecting them through the body to the elderly. The nursing home staff have seen the elderly, especially with dementia, have become more active and positive to communicate when they communicate with the Telenoids. Telenoid costs 1,000,000 JPY (approx. 8,700 USD,) and can be rented for 50,000 JPY (about 435USD) per month. (Photo by Taro Karibe/Getty Images)
NATORI, JAPAN - MARCH 13: An operator staff shows the remote-controlled humanoid 'Telenoid' to an elderly user at the nursing home 'Urayasu' on March 13, 2017 in Natori, Japan. It is the first case of Telenoid to be installed at a nursing home in the world. The 2.7 kg humanoid enables the operator to communicate with the elderly over long distance with its camera and microphone capturing the voice and movements of an operator, and projecting them through the body to the elderly. The nursing home staff have seen the elderly, especially with dementia, have become more active and positive to communicate when they communicate with the Telenoids. Telenoid costs 1,000,000 JPY (approx. 8,700 USD,) and can be rented for 50,000 JPY (about 435USD) per month. (Photo by Taro Karibe/Getty Images)
NATORI, JAPAN - MARCH 13: The operator staff swicth on the remote-controlled humanoid 'Telenoid' at the nursing home 'Urayasu' on March 13, 2017 in Natori, Japan. It is the first case of Telenoid to be installed at a nursing home in the world. The 2.7 kg humanoid enables the operator to communicate with the elderly over long distance with its camera and microphone capturing the voice and movements of an operator, and projecting them through the body to the elderly. The nursing home staff have seen the elderly, especially with dementia, have become more active and positive to communicate when they communicate with the Telenoids. Telenoid costs 1,000,000 JPY (approx. 8,700 USD,) and can be rented for 50,000 JPY (about 435USD) per month. (Photo by Taro Karibe/Getty Images)
NATORI, JAPAN - MARCH 13: An elderly user pat the head of the remote-controlled humanoid 'Telenoid' at the nursing home 'Urayasu' on March 13, 2017 in Natori, Japan. It is the first case of Telenoid to be installed at a nursing home in the world. The 2.7 kg humanoid enables the operator to communicate with the elderly over long distance with its camera and microphone capturing the voice and movements of an operator, and projecting them through the body to the elderly. The nursing home staff have seen the elderly, especially with dementia, have become more active and positive to communicate when they communicate with the Telenoids. Telenoid costs 1,000,000 JPY (approx. 8,700 USD,) and can be rented for 50,000 JPY (about 435USD) per month. (Photo by Taro Karibe/Getty Images)
NATORI, JAPAN - MARCH 13: An elderly user moved by talking with the remote-controlled humanoid 'Telenoid' at the nursing home 'Urayasu' on March 13, 2017 in Natori, Japan. It is the first case of Telenoid to be installed at a nursing home in the world. The 2.7 kg humanoid enables the operator to communicate with the elderly over long distance with its camera and microphone capturing the voice and movements of an operator, and projecting them through the body to the elderly. The nursing home staff have seen the elderly, especially with dementia, have become more active and positive to communicate when they communicate with the Telenoids. Telenoid costs 1,000,000 JPY (approx. 8,700 USD,) and can be rented for 50,000 JPY (about 435USD) per month. (Photo by Taro Karibe/Getty Images)
NATORI, JAPAN - MARCH 13: An user moved by talking with the remote-controlled humanoid 'Telenoid' at the nursing home 'Urayasu' on March 13, 2017 in Natori, Japan. It is the first case of Telenoid to be installed at a nursing home in the world. The 2.7 kg humanoid enables the operator to communicate with the elderly over long distance with its camera and microphone capturing the voice and movements of an operator, and projecting them through the body to the elderly. The nursing home staff have seen the elderly, especially with dementia, have become more active and positive to communicate when they communicate with the Telenoids. Telenoid costs 1,000,000 JPY (approx. 8,700 USD,) and can be rented for 50,000 JPY (about 435USD) per month. (Photo by Taro Karibe/Getty Images)
NATORI, JAPAN - MARCH 13: The operator staff shows the remote-controlled humanoid 'Telenoid' to an elderly user at the nursing home 'Urayasu' on March 13, 2017 in Natori, Japan. It is the first case of Telenoid to be installed at a nursing home in the world. The 2.7 kg humanoid enables the operator to communicate with the elderly over long distance with its camera and microphone capturing the voice and movements of an operator, and projecting them through the body to the elderly. The nursing home staff have seen the elderly, especially with dementia, have become more active and positive to communicate when they communicate with the Telenoids. Telenoid costs 1,000,000 JPY (approx. 8,700 USD,) and can be rented for 50,000 JPY (about 435USD) per month. (Photo by Taro Karibe/Getty Images)
NATORI, JAPAN - MARCH 13: Elderly users and the remote-controlled humanoid 'Telenoid' at the nursing home 'Urayasu' on March 13, 2017 in Natori, Japan. It is the first case of Telenoid to be installed at a nursing home in the world. The 2.7 kg humanoid enables the operator to communicate with the elderly over long distance with its camera and microphone capturing the voice and movements of an operator, and projecting them through the body to the elderly. The nursing home staff have seen the elderly, especially with dementia, have become more active and positive to communicate when they communicate with the Telenoids. Telenoid costs 1,000,000 JPY (approx. 8,700 USD,) and can be rented for 50,000 JPY (about 435USD) per month. (Photo by Taro Karibe/Getty Images)
NATORI, JAPAN - MARCH 13: An operator staff shows the remote-controlled humanoid 'Telenoid' to elderly users at the nursing home 'Urayasu' on March 13, 2017 in Natori, Japan. It is the first case of Telenoid to be installed at a nursing home in the world. The 2.7 kg humanoid enables the operator to communicate with the elderly over long distance with its camera and microphone capturing the voice and movements of an operator, and projecting them through the body to the elderly. The nursing home staff have seen the elderly, especially with dementia, have become more active and positive to communicate when they communicate with the Telenoids. Telenoid costs 1,000,000 JPY (approx. 8,700 USD,) and can be rented for 50,000 JPY (about 435USD) per month. (Photo by Taro Karibe/Getty Images)
NATORI, JAPAN - MARCH 13: The remote-controlled humanoid 'Telenoid' at the nursing home 'Urayasu' on March 13, 2017 in Natori, Japan. It is the first case of Telenoid to be installed at a nursing home in the world. The 2.7 kg humanoid enables the operator to communicate with the elderly over long distance with its camera and microphone capturing the voice and movements of an operator, and projecting them through the body to the elderly. The nursing home staff have seen the elderly, especially with dementia, have become more active and positive to communicate when they communicate with the Telenoids. Telenoid costs 1,000,000 JPY (approx. 8,700 USD,) and can be rented for 50,000 JPY (about 435USD) per month. (Photo by Taro Karibe/Getty Images)
NATORI, JAPAN - MARCH 13: An elderly user enjoy talking with the remote-controlled humanoid 'Telenoid' at the nursing home 'Urayasu' on March 13, 2017 in Natori, Japan. It is the first case of Telenoid to be installed at a nursing home in the world. The 2.7 kg humanoid enables the operator to communicate with the elderly over long distance with its camera and microphone capturing the voice and movements of an operator, and projecting them through the body to the elderly. The nursing home staff have seen the elderly, especially with dementia, have become more active and positive to communicate when they communicate with the Telenoids. Telenoid costs 1,000,000 JPY (approx. 8,700 USD,) and can be rented for 50,000 JPY (about 435USD) per month. (Photo by Taro Karibe/Getty Images)
NATORI, JAPAN - MARCH 13: An elderly user sings a song with the remote-controlled humanoid 'Telenoid' at the nursing home 'Urayasu' on March 13, 2017 in Natori, Japan. It is the first case of Telenoid to be installed at a nursing home in the world. The 2.7 kg humanoid enables the operator to communicate with the elderly over long distance with its camera and microphone capturing the voice and movements of an operator, and projecting them through the body to the elderly. The nursing home staff have seen the elderly, especially with dementia, have become more active and positive to communicate when they communicate with the Telenoids. Telenoid costs 1,000,000 JPY (approx. 8,700 USD,) and can be rented for 50,000 JPY (about 435USD) per month. (Photo by Taro Karibe/Getty Images)
NATORI, JAPAN - MARCH 13: An operation staff carries the remote-controlled humanoid 'Telenoid' at the nursing home 'Urayasu' on March 13, 2017 in Natori, Japan. It is the first case of Telenoid to be installed at a nursing home in the world. The 2.7 kg humanoid enables the operator to communicate with the elderly over long distance with its camera and microphone capturing the voice and movements of an operator, and projecting them through the body to the elderly. The nursing home staff have seen the elderly, especially with dementia, have become more active and positive to communicate when they communicate with the Telenoids. Telenoid costs 1,000,000 JPY (approx. 8,700 USD,) and can be rented for 50,000 JPY (about 435USD) per month. (Photo by Taro Karibe/Getty Images)
NATORI, JAPAN - MARCH 13: The staff shows the remote-controlled humanoid 'Telenoid' to an elderly user at the nursing home 'Urayasu' on March 13, 2017 in Natori, Japan. It is the first case of Telenoid to be installed at a nursing home in the world. The 2.7 kg humanoid enables the operator to communicate with the elderly over long distance with its camera and microphone capturing the voice and movements of an operator, and projecting them through the body to the elderly. The nursing home staff have seen the elderly, especially with dementia, have become more active and positive to communicate when they communicate with the Telenoids. Telenoid costs 1,000,000 JPY (approx. 8,700 USD,) and can be rented for 50,000 JPY (about 435USD) per month. (Photo by Taro Karibe/Getty Images)
NATORI, JAPAN - MARCH 13: An elderly user sings with the remote-controlled humanoid 'Telenoid' at the nursing home 'Urayasu' on March 13, 2017 in Natori, Japan. It is the first case of Telenoid to be installed at a nursing home in the world. The 2.7 kg humanoid enables the operator to communicate with the elderly over long distance with its camera and microphone capturing the voice and movements of an operator, and projecting them through the body to the elderly. The nursing home staff have seen the elderly, especially with dementia, have become more active and positive to communicate when they communicate with the Telenoids. Telenoid costs 1,000,000 JPY (approx. 8,700 USD,) and can be rented for 50,000 JPY (about 435USD) per month. (Photo by Taro Karibe/Getty Images)
NATORI, JAPAN - MARCH 13: An elderly user talks with the remote-controlled humanoid 'Telenoid' at the nursing home 'Urayasu' on March 13, 2017 in Natori, Japan. It is the first case of Telenoid to be installed at a nursing home in the world. The 2.7 kg humanoid enables the operator to communicate with the elderly over long distance with its camera and microphone capturing the voice and movements of an operator, and projecting them through the body to the elderly. The nursing home staff have seen the elderly, especially with dementia, have become more active and positive to communicate when they communicate with the Telenoids. Telenoid costs 1,000,000 JPY (approx. 8,700 USD,) and can be rented for 50,000 JPY (about 435USD) per month. (Photo by Taro Karibe/Getty Images)
NATORI, JAPAN - MARCH 13: An elderly user enjoy talking with the remote-controlled humanoid 'Telenoid' at the nursing home 'Urayasu' on March 13, 2017 in Natori, Japan. It is the first case of Telenoid to be installed at a nursing home in the world. The 2.7 kg humanoid enables the operator to communicate with the elderly over long distance with its camera and microphone capturing the voice and movements of an operator, and projecting them through the body to the elderly. The nursing home staff have seen the elderly, especially with dementia, have become more active and positive to communicate when they communicate with the Telenoids. Telenoid costs 1,000,000 JPY (approx. 8,700 USD,) and can be rented for 50,000 JPY (about 435USD) per month. (Photo by Taro Karibe/Getty Images)
NATORI, JAPAN - MARCH 13: An elderly user enjoys talking with the remote-controlled humanoid 'Telenoid' at the nursing home 'Urayasu' on March 13, 2017 in Natori, Japan. It is the first case of Telenoid to be installed at a nursing home in the world. The 2.7 kg humanoid enables the operator to communicate with the elderly over long distance with its camera and microphone capturing the voice and movements of an operator, and projecting them through the body to the elderly. The nursing home staff have seen the elderly, especially with dementia, have become more active and positive to communicate when they communicate with the Telenoids. Telenoid costs 1,000,000 JPY (approx. 8,700 USD,) and can be rented for 50,000 JPY (about 435USD) per month. (Photo by Taro Karibe/Getty Images)
NATORI, JAPAN - MARCH 13: An elderly user moved by talking with the remote-controlled humanoid 'Telenoid' at the nursing home 'Urayasu' on March 13, 2017 in Natori, Japan. It is the first case of Telenoid to be installed at a nursing home in the world. The 2.7 kg humanoid enables the operator to communicate with the elderly over long distance with its camera and microphone capturing the voice and movements of an operator, and projecting them through the body to the elderly. The nursing home staff have seen the elderly, especially with dementia, have become more active and positive to communicate when they communicate with the Telenoids. Telenoid costs 1,000,000 JPY (approx. 8,700 USD,) and can be rented for 50,000 JPY (about 435USD) per month. (Photo by Taro Karibe/Getty Images)
NATORI, JAPAN - MARCH 13: An elderly user pat the head of the remote-controlled humanoid 'Telenoid' at the nursing home 'Urayasu' on March 13, 2017 in Natori, Japan. It is the first case of Telenoid to be installed at a nursing home in the world. The 2.7 kg humanoid enables the operator to communicate with the elderly over long distance with its camera and microphone capturing the voice and movements of an operator, and projecting them through the body to the elderly. The nursing home staff have seen the elderly, especially with dementia, have become more active and positive to communicate when they communicate with the Telenoids. Telenoid costs 1,000,000 JPY (approx. 8,700 USD,) and can be rented for 50,000 JPY (about 435USD) per month. (Photo by Taro Karibe/Getty Images)
NATORI, JAPAN - MARCH 13: The screen show the image of an elderly user captured by the eye of the remote-controlled humanoid 'Telenoid' at the nursing home 'Urayasu' on March 13, 2017 in Natori, Japan. It is the first case of Telenoid to be installed at a nursing home in the world. The 2.7 kg humanoid enables the operator to communicate with the elderly over long distance with its camera and microphone capturing the voice and movements of an operator, and projecting them through the body to the elderly. The nursing home staff have seen the elderly, especially with dementia, have become more active and positive to communicate when they communicate with the Telenoids. Telenoid costs 1,000,000 JPY (approx. 8,700 USD,) and can be rented for 50,000 JPY (about 435USD) per month. (Photo by Taro Karibe/Getty Images)
HIDE CAPTION
SHOW CAPTION
of
SEE ALL
BACK TO SLIDE

ManorCare declined to comment but said in June it had been negotiating its master lease agreement for several months and remains committed to high-quality patient care.

Toledo, Ohio-based ManorCare is the largest senior housing chain in financial distress. But other leveraged chains are struggling under declining reimbursements, higher costs, lower occupancy and increased federal scrutiny over billing.

Receivers have been appointed to replace management at small regional chains. But many in the healthcare industry are watching to see how the first stand-off between such a large national chain and Quality Care, a specialized real estate investment trust, plays out, analysts and advisers said.

Genesis Healthcare Inc, which describes itself as the largest U.S. operator of skilled nursing facilities, negotiated changes to its master lease agreements with its REIT landlords last year to give it more flexibility. The company's stock has lost about 75 percent of its value this year.

NURSING HOME RECEIVERSHIPS

With more skilled nursing facilities defaulting on leases, property owners are increasingly looking to receiverships as an alternative to evictions or bankruptcy, lawyers and advisers told Reuters.

A receiver can ensure continuity of care for patients and residents while preparing the facility for a transition to a new owner or operator. The process is cheaper and more stable than bankruptcy proceedings.

"It's the ultimate remedy for a landlord or lender," said Suzanne Koenig, president of long-term healthcare facility turnaround company SAK Management Services.

Quality Care has agreed to at least one rent reduction for ManorCare and said it is considering marketing the properties to another operator.

Foreseeing industry headwinds, including uncertainty over Medicaid payments that cover over 60 percent of skilled nursing homes' costs, some of the largest healthcare REITs have diversified away from the industry in the past year.

Quality Care, for example, was spun off in 2016 by larger real estate investment trust HCP Inc, which had acquired the ManorCare assets from private equity fund Carlyle Group LP in 2010 for $6.1 billion.

Industry specialists say another outcome could be Quality Care taking over ManorCare. That would reunite the chain with its real estate but would force Quality Care to give up its REIT status, which enjoys more favorable tax treatment.

 

(Reporting by Tracy Rucinski; Editing by Noeleen Walder and Dan Grebler)

Read Full Story

Can't get enough business news?

Sign up for Finance Report by AOL and get everything from retailer news to the latest IPOs delivered directly to your inbox daily!

Subscribe to our other newsletters

Emails may offer personalized content or ads. Learn more. You may unsubscribe any time.