Budweiser's pro-immigrant Super Bowl ad is 'mostly fiction,' expert says

Budweiser's Super Bowl ad might provide a powerful and timely message about the importance of immigration, but as far as historically accuracy goes, it falls as flat as a half-empty beer left over from last night's rager.

At least, that's the word from William Knoedelseder, the author of the 2014 book "Bitter Brew: The Rise and Fall of Anheuser-Busch and America's King of Beer."

"It's got wonderful production values, it's very expensive and, I think, very effective — and mostly fiction," Knoedelseder told Slate.

The commercial, which has gained resonance due to the current debate over President Trump's travel ban, tells the story of Anheuser-Busch co-founder Adolphus Busch, who immigrated to the U.S. from Germany in the 1850's.

Watch the ad here:

The commercial follows Busch from his time traveling across the Atlantic, to his less than warm welcome to America, to jumping off of a flaming riverboat, to finally arriving in St. Louis to begin brewing beer.

In his interview with Slate's Sam Adams (if that is indeed his real name), Knoedelseder took exception to the notion that Busch encountered hostility upon arriving in America.

"Adolphus Busch did not arrive poor and struggling. He was from a fairly well-to-do, successful family. He wasn't tremendously wealthy, but it would be highly doubtful that he encountered whatever that was at the beginning with him jumping off the boat and people shouting at him," the author said. "He arrived with a ticket and had his own money. Unless they got a hold of some letters from his family, I don't know where they get all that information. It's not something that anyone that's written about Anheuser-Busch has ever seen before."

RELATED: Check out some of your favorite celebrities in Super Bowl ads through the years:

Celebrity super bowl ads
See Gallery
Celebrity super bowl ads

Watch Joe Namath get creamed by Farrah Fawcett! We should all pray that Farrah beats her cancer.

Diet Pepsi Super Bowl XXI ad feat. Michael J Fox - Cute Neighbor (1987)
Funny he did a James Bond-like commercial years before he actually starred in a James Bond movie...
This TV commercial introducing Pepsi's new can designs aired during the 1992 Super Bowl. The ad featured two kids watching as the biggest supermodel in the world, Cindy Crawford, stopped by a vending matchine to purchase a Pepsi. Rather than focus on Crawford and her sex appeal, the two kids marveled at the new Pepsi can.
Dennis Hopper
The infamous SuperBowl 2002 Pepsi ad featuring Britney Spears.
In this Mercedes-Benz Super Bowl ad, a devilish Willem Dafoe tempts a young man with the Mercedes-Benz CLA and everything that comes with it. In this case 'everything' means dating Kate Upton, dancing with Usher, and becoming rich and famous beyond his wildest dreams. Will he sign on the dotted line? Would you? Advertiser Mercedes-Benz Agency Merkley+Partners Ad URL http://www.facebook.com/mercedesbenzusa Mood Active Tagline "The Best or Nothing" Subscribe to our channel for more updates http://www.youtube.com/subscription_center?add_user=everytvcommercials Follow us on our Google+ Page https://plus.google.com/u/0/b/108247707130788640973/
Best Buy Amy Poehler Superbowl 2013 Game Day Commercial Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for fair use for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
Samsung has invited two of Hollywood's funniest, Seth Rogan and Paul Rudd to pitch ideas for their Big Game ad, touting the new Samsung mobile phone. Unfortunately things get a little testy when Seth and Paul try to one-up each other. People love talking babies and Asian rappers. Add Lebron James to the mix and you've got something, but is it The Next Big Thing? Bob Odenkirk - Actor/Actress LeBron James - Athlete Paul Rudd - Actor/Actress Seth Rogan - Actor/Actress Featured Product - Samsung Galaxy S III Electronics & Communication / Mobile Devices / Smartphone Advertiser Samsung Agency 72andSunny Mood Funny Tagline "The Next Big Thing is Here" Subscribe to our channel for more updates https://www.youtube.com/user/everytvc... Follow us on our Google+ Page https://plus.google.com/u/0/b/1082477... ignore this part funny commercials banned commercials super bowl commercials superbowl commercials commercials funny video funny superbowl commercials 2010 funny pranks funniest commercials superbowl commercials 2011 espn commercials allstate mayhem commercials superbowl commercials 2009 trunk monkey commercials funny videos funny cats funny commercials 2011 beer commercials sonic commercials funny commercials 2010 funny babies geico commercials funny accidents doritos commercial funny stuff funny commercial old commercials funny comercials sportscenter commercials commercial old spice commercials banned commercials 2012 bud light commercials funny commercials 2012 banned commercials 2011 funny commercials 2009 old spice commercial funny animals 80s commercials unforgivable commercials funny commercials 2008 condom commercials hilarious commercials funny beer commercials banned commercials funny worlds funniest commercials funny superbowl commercials nike commercials axe commercials bud light commercial funniest commercial ever nostalgia critic commercials budweiser commercials geico commercial superbowl commercials 2008 funny japanese commercials funny banned commercials 2011 superbowl commercials banned commercial soccer commercials tv commercials best commercials badger commercials funny commercials 2013 fantasy football commercials commercials banned 90s commercials budweiser commercial best superbowl commercials 2009 superbowl commercials japanese commercials car commercials etrade commercial baby funny commercials banned funniest video ever funny condom commercials pepsi commercials fred all state commercials 2010 superbowl commercials christmas commercials nickelodeon commercials super bowl funny indian commercials superbowl 2011 commercials band commercials etrade commercials unforgivable cigarette commercials mcdonalds commercials banned condom commercials wow commercials commercial funny budweiser clydesdales commercials michael jordan commercials peyton manning commercials axe commercial trunk monkey t-mobile verizon virgin at&t sprint vonage samsung galaxy iphone android microsoft
A couple of guys haul a recliner passing a couple rottweilers. They need lucky chairs. They use Bud Light to get through a gate, they meet with Zoe Saldana and Stevie Wonder. Zoe Saldana asks, "How much luck do you guys need?" Do what you need to get your lucky chair. It's only weird if it doesn't work.
Check out Bud Light's Super Bowl 2014 commercial following one guy who was truly #UpForWhatever.
Danica Patrick Super Bowl Commercial. Girl falls in pool. Super Hot not seen on TV. Danica Patrick spa 2010 superbowl commercial
Watch hundreds of other classic '90s commercials at youtube.com/MrClassicAds1990s
Charles Barkley Taco Bell Super Bowl Commercial 2010 My MySpace: http://www.myspace.com/ebayneatstuff2008
First Acura Super Bowl Commercial featuring the 2015 Acura NSX, Jerry Seinfeld and Jay Leno. Brought to you by Goodson Acura http://www.goodsonacura.com Posted 2012 Super Bowl Acura Seinfeld and Jay Leno Spot.
Betty White Snickers Super Bowl Commercial 2010 My MySpace: http://www.myspace.com/ebayneatstuff2008
Have you ever wondered why in Hollywood movies, all the villains are played by Brits? Visit http://www.britishvillains.com and let us introduce you to the newest British Villain. #GoodToBeBad Learn more about the F-TYPE Coupe: http://www.jaguarusa.com/all-models/f-type/f-type-models/f-type-coupe.html Connect with Jaguar USA: Website: http://www.jaguarusa.com Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/JaguarUSA Twitter: https://twitter.com/JaguarUSA Instagram: http://instagram.com/JaguarUSA Google+: https://plus.google.com/+JaguarUSA Foursquare: https://foursquare.com/JaguarUSA
Usually at the top of "Best Superbowl Ads" lists. Fun and heartwarming. A Classic
Titled "The Showdown", this is a classic Super Bowl commercial, shown initially at the 1993 Super Bowl. It features two legends of the NBA - Michael Jordan and Larry Bird. These two greats go head-to-head in a humorous and amazing game of basketball Horse. The first shots are easy. Then they get tougher and tougher to the absurd, but they keep making the baskets, like true legends. Due to the success of this ad campaign, McDonalds ran sequels, one featuring basketball player Charles Barkley as well. Might Like: Classic Apple Ad: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CCjKQ7woaVY
Late Show ad featuring David Letterman and Oprah Winfrey, which aired during the Super Bowl on Feb 4, 2007. Letterman and Oprah had a "bitter feud" for years.. The story goes that years ago, Dave (and Merrill Markoe?) were having lunch and saw Oprah eating on the other side of the dining room. Having some fun, Dave tells his waitress something like, "Oprah graciously offered to pay for our lunch" and then enthusiastically waved to Oprah. The waitress looks over to Oprah, as Winfrey politely waves back to Dave. Dave smiles and nods and the waitress takes the check away. Dave gets up and leaves. Oprah is stiffed with the tab. I don't know if that's true or not. I don't think I made it up.. although, that isn't really beyond me. I think it's hilarious. On the air, Dave made Oprah jokes left and right.. and apparently Ms. Winfrey didn't like it. Letterman taped some shows in Chicago and invited Oprah to be a guest, but was told, "Oprah is TOTALLY out of town." Which he mocked on air for weeks. After years of snide jabs at her, Dave started a different approach - he sung Oprah's praises and begged her to be on the show.. even keeping a daily diary of his quest in an "Oprah Log". After weeks, he gave up on his quest and staged a skit where the Oprah Log had been stolen from the glass case he kept it in. When his son was born, Oprah sent Dave a child's swimming pool full of children's books. This made Dave think there was hope yet. He begged her to be on his show to reconcile in what he said would be a "super bowl of love". She ignored him for years.. but eventually DID appear on his show to promote the opening of The Color Purple on Broadway and it was the 4th highest rating his program has gotten in 25 years on the air. This 10-second spot aired during the Colts vs. Bears Super Bowl and makes reference to all of that and hinges upon his being from Indianapolis and her living in Chicago. Watch the Late Show with David Letterman weeknights on CBS, and visit them online at: http://www.cbs.com/lateshow/ - they've got a better copy of this video on their site.
This is what an advertisement should be. Transcript: CHARLES: you know when its right you know when you feel it baby you hold it you hear it you taste it, it's right (uh-huh girls): diet pepsi, uh-huh, uh-huh CHARLES: you got the right one bay-baayyy (uh-huh girls): uh-huh, uh-huh, diet pepsi CHARLES [from what i can gather]: if its irrefreshably lovable and unsurpassably colorful and intimately soul-full you got the right one bay-bayyayy (uh-huh girls): UH-HUH

Knoedelseder added that German immigrants in the mid-1800s likely wouldn't have faced anti-immigrant prejudice of the same magnitude as "the poor Irish who had to fight their way in block by block. By the time he got to St. Louis, there was a very sizable German population there. They all arrived in America with money, and deference comes with cash."

While the ad has gained widespread attention due to current events, Budweiser vice president Ricardo Marques denied that the ad was intended as political commentary in an interview with Ad Week.

"There's really no correlation with anything else that's happening in the country," Marques said. "We believe this is a universal story that is very relevant today because probably more than any other period in history today the world pulls you in different directions, and it's never been harder to stick to your guns."

Read original story Budweiser's Pro-Immigrant Super Bowl Ad Is 'Mostly Fiction,' Anheuser-Busch Expert Says At TheWrap

Read Full Story