Stop and Think: How Much House Can You Really Afford?
By Stacy Johnson
If you're thinking now's the time to pull the trigger on a home purchase, you'll be jumping in at a time when housing prices are rising, and in some markets, you may find yourself competing with other buyers for a property you want. All the more reason to think carefully about how much house you can afford.
Consider this recent email:
Now let's add more detail on Chris' situation, as well as my advice.
Like most Americans, my dream was to own a house. My goal was to do it before 30. Well, I turned 30 this January and still have not gotten my first house. After reading your book "Life Or Debt 2010," I have slowly climbed out of deep student debt -- I had over $15,000 on just one loan.
My question is: Do you think a house that's $110,000 with yearly taxes in the $4,200 range is too much for a person making $34,000 a year? I currently have $10,000 saved for closing costs and hopefully some down payment. The VA loans don't require a down payment, but I never want to be in debt again!
My parents told me that's a normal tax range here in Buffalo, New York. I am going back to school towards a degree in accounting, so I'll hopefully make more after school is over. (I'm going back to school free on GI Bill.)
Also, with the VA loan there is no PMI. Should I keep saving until I have a more sizable down payment? Or buy the amazingly priced 1,900-square-foot home or one of the others like it in my area?
How to Figure Out How Much House You Can Afford
No matter how good the deal or strong the desire, buying anything you can't afford is traveling down the road to ruin.
Let's start with one of a plethora of online calculators available to answer this question. I used this one from Bankrate, but there's also one at Zillow and many other sites.
Here are the questions it asked, along with the answers I provided for Chris:
- Income and expenses: Annual Income: $34,000; monthly child support: $0; monthly car loan: $0; monthly credit card payments: $0; monthly association fees: $0; other monthly obligations: $0.
- Mortgage assumptions: Annual interest rate: 4 percent; mortgage term: 30 years; down payment: $5,000 (I assumed he'd use half his available savings for the down payment, half for closing costs); annual property taxes: $4,200; annual insurance: $500 (I pulled this number out of the air).
- Result: The maximum house Chris can afford is $89,134. As you can see, the $110,000 house Chris has his eye on is a bit out of reach. And that's in the best-case scenario, since I assumed he has no other debts or monthly obligations.
What should Chris do? Here are several options Chris could consider:
Get a Partner
I bought my first house in 1978 at the age of 22. It was a four-bedroom, two-bath home with a pool. The cost was $85,500 and my income was -- believe it or not -- $12,000 a year. How did I do it? I went in on the house with a friend. Together, we were able to come up with the down payment, and because the seller owned it free and clear, they carried back the mortgage so we didn't have to qualify for a loan. After we moved in, we rented the remaining bedrooms to other friends to make ends meet.
I'm still using a version of that technique today. In 2012, I bought a house with a friend. This one was more expensive, neither of us will live in it, and we paid cash. But the principle is the same: Bringing in a partner requires half the money and results in half the risk.
The potential nightmare of choosing the wrong person for any financial partnership should be obvious and therefore approached with extreme caution. (My rule of thumb: Never partner with anyone with less money than you.) But at least it's something to consider.
Buy a Cheaper House
If Chris can buy a 1,900-square-foot house for $110,000, he can surely find something livable for less. He doesn't say whether he needs that much space -- we don't know if he has a family, for example -- but that's a lot of house for one person. One of the dumbest things Americans do is buy the biggest, fanciest things they can possibly afford. And nowhere is this mistake more evident than in home shopping. When you work with a real estate agent, the first thing many do is what I did with Chris above: use a formula to determine the most expensive house possible. They then proceed to show you houses at that upper limit and often above it. Result? You let vanity replace common sense, buy more house than you need, leave no margin for error, and end up furnishing, heating, cooling, maintaining and paying taxes on rooms you don't use. Dumb.
Granted, because of the leverage offered by real estate, there's an argument to be made for buying as much property as you can, especially if your goal is to maximize returns. But if you're buying simply because you want your piece of the American dream, determine what you need (as opposed to want) and spend as little as possible to get it. There's no reason to create unnecessary risk by over-leveraging.
Housing prices are going up, and going up more quickly than others in some places, but sometimes it's better to wait. It gives you time to save more for a larger down payment, and maybe get a promotion at work that comes with a bigger paycheck. Something to think about, especially considering houses require time, and he'll soon be working and going to school.
Bottom line? My advice to Chris is to either somehow share the cost, set his sights a bit lower price-wise, or wait until he has more money and more time.
Ari Cetron contributed to this report.
Like this article? Sign up for our newsletter and we'll send you a regular digest of our newest stories, full of money saving tips and advice, free!