Thanks, but No Thanks: When to Reject the Health Plan at Work

Did you know that you could tell your employer "no thanks" and buy health insurance on your own for you and your family members? Employees can choose to leave their employer-sponsored group plan in favor of the individual health insurance market. An employer can force you to take the plan at work only if it pays 100 percent of the premiums or if you agreed to take the plan as part of an employment or union agreement.

Five things you should know before you decide to dump your employer's health insurance plan:

  1. You can enroll in an individual health plan only during open enrollment. This includes plans in the state health insurance marketplaces and plans available directly from health insurers outside the marketplace. The open enrollment period for 2015 coverage is Nov. 15, 2014, to Feb. 15, 2015. You may qualify for a special enrollment if you experience certain life events such as moving to a new state, have changes in your income, losing your group health coverage, marrying, divorcing or having a baby. But otherwise, you'll have to wait, says Cheryl Fish-Parcham, private insurance program director for Families USA, a consumer advocacy group based in Washington, D.C.
  2. If your employer subsidizes your health care premiums, and most do, price shop before you leap. You won't necessarily get better premiums by buying your own plan, but it's possible.
  3. You may be saving money by paying your share of the employer-sponsored plan premiums with pre-tax dollars. If you go out on your own, you can no longer pay with pre-tax dollars.
  4. If you sign up for your employer plan at work, you're stuck with it for a year. Once you opt in during workplace open enrollment, you can't change your mind unless you quit.
  5. If your employer offers coverage that meets "minimum value" standards set by the Affordable Care Act and is "affordable," you can't qualify for a government subsidy on coverage purchased through an exchange, even if your income would qualify you.

When you might want out of your employer's health insurance plan
That said, here are three scenarios where you might want to opt out of the group insurance at work and buyhealth insurance on your own instead.

Your employer offers you health insurance coverage, but it doesn't contribute to the premiums.
Most but not all employers help pay premiums, Fish-Parcham says. And the amount they subsidize can vary from employer to employer. If your employer doesn't help you pay your premiums, you might find a better deal by buying an individual health plan.

Your employer offers coverage, but you think it's a lousy plan.
Under the Affordable Care Act, employer-sponsored plans must cover at least 60 percent of medical expenses for a "standard population"; the employee pays 40 percent of their health care expenses through deductibles and co-payments. Look at the plan your employer offers, Fish-Parcham advises. It will state whether it meets this requirement. Similarly, your boss could be offering you a plan that you think is too expensive "and feel as though you can't afford it," says Lisa Zamosky, author of Healthcare, Insurance and You: The Savvy Consumer's Guide. But that doesn't mean you won't get sticker shock in the individual market, too-make sure to compare prices for the same coverage levels.

You are about to lose your job or you've lost your job and are offered COBRA
COBRA law gives you the right to continue the plan you had through your work after you leave a job, but your employer no longer has to subsidize any of your premiums. "This is where you could do better on your own," Fish-Parcham says. Besides, if you lose coverage through a job loss, it's considered a "qualifying life event" and you are entitled to a special enrollment period. So, if you lose your job in June, long after the regular open enrollment period has ended, you qualify for a special open enrollment of 60 days.

Your employer pays for part of your coverage, but not your dependents' coverage
More employers looking to cut costs as premiums rise are going this route, Zamosky says. You may want to keep your coverage at work but buy for your dependents from the individual market.

Compare health plan benefits before deciding
When choosing a plan on your own, be sure to look carefully at the benefits it offers and whether the health care providers and hospitals you will want to use are part of it, Fish-Parcham advises. Don't make your decision solely on price, she says.

Zamosky says if you are young, healthy and don't use a lot of health care you may make out better with a high-deductible plan and your employer may not offer that option. However, you never know when you might get sick or develop a chronic illness. Always explore your options, she says.

"Factor in all the financial benefits that come with getting insurance at work," she says. "For most people, the employer-sponsored plan is going to be the best deal. But you won't know that for sure until you test it." Consider, too, she says, that some employers offer you incentives such as lower premiums for healthy behaviors such as quitting smoking or getting a gym membership. These incentives should be part of your decision-making equation too.

Note that your employer might have a vested interest in keeping employees on the workplace plan. Under the Affordable Care Act, employers can be penalized if their health insurance is too costly. The smaller the group, the higher its rates may be. If healthy individuals opt out and leave only sicker employees, that will cause the employer-sponsored plan premiums to rise. The government says the coverage is "affordable" when "the employee's share of the annual premium for self-only coverage is no greater than 9.5 percent of annual household income."

This article originally appeared on

With healthcare costs soaring, maybe it's time to take advantage of this little-known tax "loophole"
Recent tax increases have affected nearly every American taxpayer. But with the right planning, you can take steps to take control of your taxes and potentially even lower your tax bill. In our brand-new special report "The IRS Is Daring You to Make This Investment Now!," you'll learn about the simple strategy to take advantage of a little-known IRS rule. Don't miss out on advice that could help you cut taxes for decades to come. Click here to learn more.

You may also enjoy these financial articles:

Customer satisfaction scores of health insurance companies

5 big mistakes when buying health insurance at work

Trends, costs and laws for workplace open enrollment

The article Thanks, but No Thanks: When to Reject the Health Plan at Work originally appeared on

Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

Copyright © 1995 - 2014 The Motley Fool, LLC. All rights reserved. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

Read Full Story