The Do's and Don'ts of Closing Credit Cards

Two cut credit cards
Tuomas Marttila/Getty ImagesCutting up your cards might do more harm than good.
By Jenna Lee

Do you remember your first credit card? Whether a salesperson on your college campus convinced you to sign up in exchange for a slice of pizza, or you and your parents intentionally visited your local bank or credit union, one thing is almost certain: Unless it's your only card, it's probably not the best card in your wallet. After all, lenders don't want to give just any card to someone who has no credit history. Most likely, it has a low credit limit, high interest rate and/or few rewards.

Once consumers build up their credit health and add better cards to their inventory, they're often tempted to cancel their oldest cards, thinking they're not needed. And in most cases, those "starter" cards probably aren't needed. However, closing your credit cards, whether old or new, could affect your credit score, so this decision shouldn't be made lightly. If you're considering closing any of your cards, here are a few tips to keep in mind:

Do ...

Know how it will affect your credit.
Sadly, while closing your cards will never help your score, it definitely has the potential to hurt it. Here are some areas of your credit it may affect:
  • Credit card utilization rate. When you close a card, you reduce your overall available credit. Unless you scale back your spending, this will negatively affect your credit utilization rate, which is one of the most significant factors used to calculate your score. Therefore, even if you don't want a card anymore, it may be worthwhile keeping the card open -- just to lower your utilization rate.
  • Average age of accounts. Closing a credit card won't affect your average age of accounts right away, as closed accounts in good standing will typically remain on your report for 10 years, and negative payment history will remain on your report for seven years. However, if you close a card that is significantly older than your other cards, it could lower your average age when it finally falls off your credit history and subsequently lower your score. Bottom line: If you're relatively new to credit, it's best to keep your oldest card open, especially if it has a positive payment history. Closing it can hurt your score more significantly than it would for someone who has a much longer credit history.
  • Number/mix of accounts. Again, this won't impact your score for a while. However, most scoring models take into account your number of accounts and mix of credit types, so closing your only credit card could come back to haunt you.
Try bargaining with your credit card provider. In many situations, it costs lenders more to find new customers than to retain old ones, so if you want to cancel a card simply because it has a high APR or an annual fee, first try requesting a lower interest rate or ask the issuer to waive your fees. The lender doesn't have to entertain your request, of course, but it never hurts to ask! And if you can save some money while keeping your positive payment history, it'll be well worth the trouble.

%VIRTUAL-article-sponsoredlinks%Consider canceling cards that are costing you money. If your card has an extraordinarily high interest rate or miscellaneous fees, and your provider isn't willing to compromise, you may want to consider closing the card -- especially if you don't use it. Your credit score is important, but wasting money just doesn't make sense.

Know that canceling a card involves more than snipping it in two. Closing a credit card is a big decision, so if you make it, commit to it. Even if you cancel via telephone or online, follow up and ensure it's cancelled by sending a certified letter to the customer service department and asking for a confirmation letter. It can take a while for your lender to process the change, so sit tight! Once you're certain it's closed, you can cut up your card.

Monitor your credit. The credit bureaus don't always have your credit history 100 percent accurate, and it's up to you to watch your credit and dispute errors. Remember: While your closed accounts and their payment histories will stay on your report for seven or more years, they should be marked as "closed."

Don't ...

Close all your cards.
In addition to potentially damaging your score in the future, closing all your cards may put you in a bind if you're ever in an emergency and need credit -- trust us, you don't want to have to take on a predatory loan aimed at those with subprime or no credit. There are less drastic ways than closing all your accounts to handle your debt load, so take a moment to breathe and consider alternative solutions before making any rash decisions.

Close cards before financing a major purchase. When applying for a mortgage or auto loan, you want your score to be as high as possible so you can score the lowest interest rates. Plan ahead. Now that you know canceling a credit card may affect your score, don't let a spur-of-the-moment decision cause you to pay thousands of extra dollars in interest over the life of your loan.

Close cards with favorable terms. Of course, no card is perfect. But if your card has a low interest rate, no annual fee and other perks, it may be worth keeping it open just in case you need it in the future. If you close the card, hurt your score and end up having to apply for more credit later, you may not be able to get as good a card as the one you closed.

Forget to use your open cards. It costs money for lenders to report to the bureaus, so if you don't use your cards for a while, the company may stop reporting them. This could impact your score, so if you're keeping cards open just to keep them open, try placing one small, monthly, recurring payment on your cards (and paying them off every month, of course) to ensure they remain active.

The Bottom Line: Ultimately, the decision to close a credit card is yours alone. However, by taking into account your personal situation and remembering these tips, you should be able to make an informed decision you won't regret.

Jenna Lee writes for Credit Karma. You can follow her on Twitter @leejennaa, connect with her on LinkedIn or circle her on Google Plus.

7 Money Issues to Understand Before Accepting a New Job
See Gallery
The Do's and Don'ts of Closing Credit Cards
Is the position hourly or salaried? Is there an option for a bonus or the possibility of commission? Understand what portion of your income will be guaranteed and fixed vs. what's variable. Work to create a household spending plan on the fixed portion, or manage your finances on a variable income. It's important that you understand how your new income will affect your spending and goals.
Life happens, and you want to make sure you have time to enjoy it. Find out about the rules on vacation days and paid time off for medical appointments or unexpected events. Some companies combine all of your paid time off into a single time bank. Knowing the benefits package will clarify your understanding of what these events may cost you in terms of time or lost wages. And find out whether that vacation time offer is negotiable: Some companies may be more flexible about it than you'd expect.
Health insurance premiums can eat up a significant chunk of your monthly income. If possible, gauge what the company offers ahead of time and ask about the average cost of coverage for employees to compare to what you're currently paying. Company-provided life insurance or disability coverage can help supplement the coverage you buy for yourself, or cut your expenses for it.
Saving for your future is a priority no matter where you're working. Ask about company retirement plan options, such as a 401(k) and determine if there's a company match. (Free money!) If there isn't a 401(k) option, (or a match), recognize that's money out of your pocket. Then, look outside to setting up your own traditional or Roth Individual Retirement Account. Are there stock options or other company incentives?
Having clarity around expectations for performance and salary reviews will help you to gauge whether you can expect structure and streamlined growth, or if you need to proactively ask for reviews.
Are you in a position that requires you to hold a license and take annual continuing education credits? Will your new employer share or cover the costs for you to maintain these designations? Are there professional development or educational reimbursements for courses that will help you advance your skills within your new position? You'll want to know how much your company invests in its employees.
Corporate culture may not seem like a money-related question, but the price you can pay for a not having a flexible or family-friendly employer is significant. Knowing whether you'll be able to step away for a few hours one afternoon when your child is sick or if you'll need to secure paid care is something you'll need to factor into the family budget. A highly demanding job that will have you away from home or neglecting personal care could factor into higher costs to treat stress. The ability to telecommute from time to time can be a godsend both logistically and financially. So, evaluate how your current employer's culture impacts your lifestyle, and ensure you understand what changes you'd face if you joined your potential new company.
Read Full Story