Why Do Our Best and Brightest Young People Want to Work on Wall Street?
The life of an entry-level Wall Street analyst is succinctly described by Kevin Roose in his new book, Young Money:
They made pitch books for clients who will never read them, and get yelled at for improperly aligning cells in Excel, all in hopes of a year-end bonus number that won't make them want to jump in front of the 4 train. They are the young investment bankers of Wall Street, and they just want some sleep.
Who, in their right minds, would even consider signing up for such an awful existence?
We know, of course, that many people would do just about anything for the opportunity to live that life. At Harvard in 2008, 28% of seniors who had jobs at graduation were headed to the financial services sector, according to Roose. At Princeton in 2006, the number was 46%. In 2013, as Wall Street continued to recover from the financial crisis, Goldman Sachs received 17,000 applications for 350 summer internships. As Goldman President Gary Cohn confirmed, "We have no problem attracting people."
These are meaningful numbers, and Roose sets out to better understand them. In the introduction to his book, he says his aim is "to figure out who these people were, and how the crash was changing their initiation process." His approach is to follow eight entry-level analysts as they begin their careers at some of the top Wall Street financial institutions.
So, how awful are they?
One of the most striking things about the book is that the analysts are very likable, even though their Wall Street habitat is just as troubling as you might imagine. As the young bankers struggle with mundane tasks along with the bigger challenges of growing up, we witness a corporate culture that is unapologetically focused on money above all else.
To the question of "what motivates him," one senior Goldman Sachs managing director answered: "Making money. Making as much money for myself and the firm as possible." Roose's big fear is that his cohort of thoughtful analysts will ultimately be transformed into members of an insular elite that is obsessed with money and power.
There is good reason to be worried. In one of the most damning chapters in the book, Roose describes going undercover to a meeting of Kappa Beta Phi -- a secret fraternity of senior Wall Street leaders that dates back to the Great Depression. Each year, the organization -- which is made up of top executives from such firms as Morgan Stanley , Citigroup , and Bank of America -- holds a black-tie dinner welcoming new members. Roose decided to sneak in so he could see what might happen to young Wall Streeters, if they were to make it eventually to the top of the greasy pole.
What we learn isn't pretty. The event consisted of a stream of sexist and homophobic remarks, along with jokes mocking poor people and belittling Wall Street's critics. And, of course, there was a lot of bragging by the industry leaders about their wealth and status.
Roose is disgusted by their desire to "laugh off the financial crisis in private, as if it were a long-forgotten lark." His ultimate takeaway from the event was that "it amounted to a gargantuan middle finger to Main Street."
So what is Roose's conclusion? Will his decent, hopeful group of analysts become corrupted by Wall Street values?
It could go either way
By the end of the book, they haven't been corrupted. Two of them, in fact, leave Wall Street to pursue jobs with technology start-ups. And several seek out lower-key jobs within the financial sector.
It should be mentioned, too, that there are many decent people on Wall Street who care about more than just making money, so there isn't necessarily an inevitable path from newbie to Kappa Beta Phi monster. And Roose notes that Wall Street is changing gradually. The industry has contracted somewhat and the rewards are getting smaller, for the most part. Perhaps fewer of our talented people will flock to Wall Street in the future, and will instead pursue those fields that will truly interest them.
The real lesson for me from this book is that we should try to encourage young people to choose careers that they are passionate about, without worrying too much about finances and other obstacles. If someone loves business and finance, then Wall Street might be an excellent choice. But if someone else really wants to be a doctor -- as is the case for one of the analysts in this book -- he or she should be supported in making that choice. Nowadays, the obscene price tag of a college degree and bleak employment prospects for new grads make the financial sector attractive to many who may not really want to go down that path.
Buy the book
Roose is an excellent writer and fine storyteller, who succeeds in making us wiser about an important but amorphous subject. This book will have wide appeal, and I even think folks like Goldman CEO Lloyd Blankfein and JPMorganChase CEO Jamie Dimon might find it useful for improving their corporate cultures.
One of my favorite persons in the book is a Yale undergraduate named Marina Keegan, who wrote a piece for her school paper about the Wall Street recruiting process. She wrote:
What bothers me is this idea of validation, of rationalization. The notion that some of us (regardless of what we tell ourselves) are doing this because we're not sure what else to do and it's easy to apply to and it will pay us decently and it will make us feel like we're still successful. I just haven't met anyone who is genuinely excited about these jobs. That's super depressing! I don't understand why no one is talking about it.
Inspired by Keegan, Kevin Roose is talking about it. Tragically, she died in a car crash a week after her graduation in May 2012. In a very moving concluding paragraph, Roose dedicates the book to her memory. As I reflect on Keegan's short, but meaningful life, I become very hopeful about the younger generation.
The article Why Do Our Best and Brightest Young People Want to Work on Wall Street? originally appeared on Fool.com.John Reeves has no position in any stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool recommends Bank of America and Goldman Sachs. The Motley Fool owns shares of Bank of America, Citigroup, and JPMorgan Chase. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.
Copyright © 1995 - 2014 The Motley Fool, LLC. All rights reserved. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.