Colton Underwood reveals who he thinks will be the 'Bachelor' (Exclusive)

Colton Underwood knows a thing or two about committing to a decision — even when that decision involves jumping over a fence

Now, the former "Bachelor" is throwing his weight behind the guy he thinks should star in the show's 24th season. AOL caught up with Underwood at an event in support of his partnership with MorningStar Farms, where he talked with us about who he believes will be the next "Bachelor."

"I'm a betting man, and my bet would be on Peter [Weber]," Underwood told AOL.

Weber, a pilot from Westlake Village, Ca., who placed third in the most recent season of "The Bachelorette," has been in the conversation ever since his heartbreaking goodbye with Hannah Brown. The 27-year-old pilot only gained more momentum after the season finale, during which Brown revealed that her and Weber's now-infamous windmill date was even steamier than previously thought. 

6 PHOTOS
Colton Underwood at MorningStar Farms' 'Veginity' Event
See Gallery
Colton Underwood at MorningStar Farms' 'Veginity' Event
Colton Underwood
Colton Underwood
Colton Underwood
Colton Underwood
Colton Underwood
Colton Underwood
HIDE CAPTION
SHOW CAPTION
of
SEE ALL
BACK TO SLIDE

For his part, Weber has said he's open to the idea, telling People last month that he "wouldn't say no" to it. And now he's got a former "Bachelor" in his corner too. 

"I think Peter would be a great choice," Underwood told AOL. 

Still, Underwood isn't betting it all on Weber. The former NFL player also discussed the emergence of "Bachelor in Paradise" star Derek Peth, who has joined the "Bachelor" conversation after a heartbreaking rejection on one of the show's recent episodes. 

Peth, who's now reportedly said he's "open" to becoming the next "Bachelor," vaulted into the spotlight earlier this week, after a "Paradise" episode in which his love interest, Demi Burnett, rejected him in favor of her girlfriend, Kristian Haggerty. Underwood said Peth, 32, makes sense as a return to the show's interest in slightly older contestants. 

"I could also see them moving toward Derek," Underwood told AOL. "Just for them getting back to the traditional age range that they’ve been used to operating with."

RELATED: A look back at "The Bachelor" over the years: 

20 PHOTOS
'The Bachelor' and 'The Bachelorette' over the years
See Gallery
'The Bachelor' and 'The Bachelorette' over the years
UNITED STATES - SEPTEMBER 17: 67530_9926_06 -- THE BACHELORETTE - 'Episode 202' - Chris Harrison introduces the 15 remaining men to their new 'Bachelor Pad,' and Meredith goes on three dates with her suitors, one individual date and two group dates. On the individual date, which is the result of the 'white rose' Meredith handed out the first night, she and Rick go on a romantic date in a Hollywood mansion. On the two group dates, which are both 7-1, she goes on a 'Mad Max' date, where a helicopter drops them off in the middle of nowhere and she and the men ride ATV's; and then on a rodeo-themed date, where they go horseback riding, have a BBQ and sit by a campfire. At the end of the episode, Meredith must narrow the field from 15 to 10, on 'The Bachelorette,' WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 21 (9:00-10:00 p.m., ET), on the ABC Television Network. (Photo by Craig Sjodin/ABC via Getty Images)
THE BACHELOR - 'Episode 1905' - The next day, Chris sneaks into Britt's hotel room in the early morning hours and whisks her away on one of the most romantic dates of the season: a hot air balloon ride as the sun rises. Part two of the couple's passionate date might put this woman's way ahead of the group. Too bad the other bachelorettes don't think she is being truthful about her intentions, on 'The Bachelor,' MONDAY, FEBRUARY 2 (8:00-10:01 p.m., ET), on the ABC Television Network. (Photo by Lewis Jacobs/ABC via Getty Images)
UNITED STATES - JANUARY 12: 67517_1782 -- THE BACHELORETTE - 'Episode 202' - Chris Harrison introduces the 15 remaining men to their new 'Bachelor Pad,' and Meredith goes on three dates with her suitors, one individual date and two group dates. On the individual date, which is the result of the 'white rose' Meredith handed out the first night, she and Rick go on a romantic date in a Hollywood mansion. On the two group dates, which are both 7-1, she goes on a 'Mad Max' date, where a helicopter drops them off in the middle of nowhere and she and the men ride ATV's; and then on a rodeo-themed date, where they go horseback riding, have a BBQ and sit by a campfire. At the end of the episode, Meredith must narrow the field from 15 to 10, on 'The Bachelorette,' WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 21 (9:00-10:00 p.m., ET), on the ABC Television Network., (Photo by Craig Sjodin/ABC via Getty Images)
THE BACHELOR - 'The Women Tell All' - There were highs and lows during Sean's unforgettable season - and then there was Tierra, the most controversial bachelorette of the group. Tierra, who has been the woman viewers and the other bachelorettes have loved to hate all season, will return to have her chance to defend herself. Will she apologize for her behavior? Will she fight back and be her fiery self, or will viewers see another side of her? It's an explosive reunion viewers won't want to miss, as the most memorable and fan favorite bachelorettes from this season - including AshLee, Desiree, Lesley M., Tierra, Selma, Sarah, Kacie B. -- return to confront each other and Sean one last time on national television to tell their side of the story. Sarah seeks closure from Sean; Desiree explains about her journey of self-discovery; and a devastated AshLee reveals what she was thinking when Sean let her go in Thailand. Follow Sean and Chris on the Bachelor Bus as they shock fans at their viewer parties in the Los Angeles area, and take a sneak peek at the Season Finale and the final two bachelorettes - Catherine and Lindsay -- on 'The Bachelor: The Women Tell All,' MONDAY, MARCH 4 (8:00-10:01 p.m., ET), on the ABC Television Network. (Photo by Rick Rowell/ABC via Getty Images) CHRIS HARRISON, SEAN LOWE
UNITED STATES - CIRCA 2007: 67497_3399_23 -- THE BACHELORETTE - Meredith Phillips, former participant and romantic hopeful from Bob Guiney's season of 'The Bachelor,' is the star of the latest installment of 'The Bachelorette.' Meredith, 30, a make-up artist originally from Portland, Oregon, who currently resides in Los Angeles, hopes to meet a man who shares her desire for a serious, long-term relationship, and even possibly marriage. 'The Bachelorette,' an original one-hour primetime romance reality television series, returns for a second season on the ABC Television Network on WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 14 (9:00-10:00 p.m. ET). (Photo by Craig Sjodin/ABC via Getty Images)
THE BACHELOR - 'Episode 2008' - The stakes are high as Ben crisscrosses the country on an exciting, emotionally charged journey to visit the final four women's hometowns. Ben travels to Orange County, CA to meet Amanda, the single mother with two adorable little girls, but her concerned parents wonder if he is ready to be an immediate full-time dad. Lauren B. shows Ben around her hometown of Portland, OR, but he must face serious questions from her sister. Caila shares some places with Ben that she holds near and dear to her in Hudson, OH; however, her father subjects the Bachelor to a grilling to see if he is worthy of his daughter. Finally, Ben is off to Dallas to meet Jo Jo, only to find her in tears as an unexpected surprise threatens to derail their romance. Ben must make a gut-wrenching decision to narrow the field to three women. Will one of them be his wife? Find out on 'The Bachelor,' airing MONDAY, FEBRUARY 22 (8:00-10:01 p.m. EST) on the ABC Television Network. (Levy Moroshan/ABC via Getty Images) LAUREN B., BEN HIGGINS
UNITED STATES - JULY 18: 67116_18_16 -- THE BACHELOR -- INVITATION NIGHT, (Photo by Craig Sjodin/ABC via Getty Images)
UNITED STATES - FEBRUARY 08: 65519_8_10 -THE BACHELOR - , (Photo by Craig Sjodin/ABC via Getty Images)
UNITED STATES - OCTOBER 16: THE BACHELOR - 'Episode 1301' - Jason, 32, an account executive in estate and legacy planning, met 25 potential soul mates as he began his exciting search for true love. In the premiere episode, '1301,' Jason prepared for the night of his life, as the 25 beautiful bachelorettes, who can think of nothing but him, arrived. Then Jason, in his first rose ceremony, eliminated ten of the 25 women, leaving 15 to compete for his affection and, in the end, his heart. The 13th edition of ABC's popular romance reality series, 'The Bachelor,' premiered with a two-hour special, MONDAY, JANUARY 5 (8:00-10:00 p.m., ET), on the ABC Television Network. (Photo by Craig Sjodin/ABC via Getty Images)
UNITED STATES - APRIL 26: THE BACHELOR: LONDON CALLING -- THE WOMEN TELL ALL - 'The Women Tell All' -- It's an explosive reunion viewers won't want to miss, as the most memorable bachelorettes from this season - including Ashlee, Carri, Marshana, Robin and Stacey -- return to confront each other and Matt one last time on national television to dish the dirt and tell their side of the story, on 'The Bachelor: London Calling -- The Women Tell All,' MONDAY, MAY 5 (10:02-11:00 p.m., ET), on the ABC Television Network. (Photo by Greg Zabilski/ABC via Getty Images)
UNITED STATES - APRIL 26: THE BACHELOR: LONDON CALLING -- THE WOMEN TELL ALL - 'The Women Tell All' -- It's an explosive reunion viewers won't want to miss, as the most memorable bachelorettes from this season - including Ashlee, Carri, Marshana, Robin and Stacey -- return to confront each other and Matt one last time on national television to dish the dirt and tell their side of the story, on 'The Bachelor: London Calling -- The Women Tell All,' MONDAY, MAY 5 (10:02-11:00 p.m., ET), on the ABC Television Network. (Photo by Greg Zabilski/ABC via Getty Images)
BARBADOS - MARCH 03: THE BACHELOR: LONDON CALLING - 'Episode 1208' - Matt faces an excruciating decision between Chelsea and Shayne before making the commitment of his life, on the gripping Season Finale that ends with one heartbroken bachelorette in tears and other engaged to be married, on 'The Bachelor: London Calling,' MONDAY, MAY 12 (10:02-11:00 p.m., ET), on the ABC Television Network. (Photo by Adam Larkey/ABC via Getty Images)
THE BACHELOR - 'Episode 1510' - In this dramatic conclusion, Brad, who came back for a second chance at love, prepared to make one of the most difficult choices of this life. His search for love was narrowed down to two very different women - Chantal and Emily -- and he fell in love with both of them. Now, after having his family meet them in Cape Town, South Africa, and under immense pressure, he made one final heart-wrenching decision that could change his life forever. After three years of soul-searching, he proposed to Emily Maynard on the season finale of 'The Bachelor,' MONDAY, MARCH 14 (8:00-10:01 p.m., ET), on the ABC Television Network. (Photo by Mark Wessels/ABC via Getty Images)EMILY MAYNARD, BRAD WOMACK
THE BACHELOR - 'Episode 1505' - The Bachelor must face the difficult task of taking Ashley H. and Ashley S., two women he's fond of, on the famed two-on-one date, vowing to have fun - even with a painful choice looming at the end of the night. What a surprise Brad has in store for the ladies! They go backstage of the hit show 'Viva ELVIS by Cirque du Soleil,' where they discover they'll be a part of the performance later that night. But there's a catch: the number they'll perform is a duet, and Brad will need to decide which woman will stay and perform with him. The tension filled dinner does nothing to make Brad's decision any easier, as he sends one woman home in tears, on 'The Bachelor,' MONDAY, JANUARY 31 (8:00-10:01 p.m., ET), on the ABC Television Network. (Photo by Isaac Brekken/ABC via Getty Images)BRAD WOMACK, ASHLEY S.
THE BACHELOR - In 'Episode 1601,' Ben returns to the mansion for the first big cocktail party. He explains to Chris Harrison that, as painful as his experience was last season, he has no regrets. When Ben began his journey with Ashley, he was emotionally shut down due to his grief over his father's death. Ultimately, he was able to open himself up again to love. Because of that journey, he is a different man and ready to try and find love again, when 'The Bachelor' premieres MONDAY, JANUARY 2 (8:00-10:01 p.m., ET), on the ABC Television Network. (Photo by Rick Rowell / ABC via Getty Images) BACHELORETTES, BEN FLAJNIK
THE BACHELOR - In 'Episode 1601,' Ben returns to the mansion for the first big cocktail party. He explains to Chris Harrison that, as painful as his experience was last season, he has no regrets. When Ben began his journey with Ashley, he was emotionally shut down due to his grief over his father's death. Ultimately, he was able to open himself up again to love. Because of that journey, he is a different man and ready to try and find love again, when 'The Bachelor' premieres MONDAY, JANUARY 2 (8:00-10:01 p.m., ET), on the ABC Television Network. (Photo by Rick Rowell / ABC via Getty Images) BACHELORETTES
THE BACHELOR - In 'Episode 1601,' Ben returns to the mansion for the first big cocktail party. He explains to Chris Harrison that, as painful as his experience was last season, he has no regrets. When Ben began his journey with Ashley, he was emotionally shut down due to his grief over his father's death. Ultimately, he was able to open himself up again to love. Because of that journey, he is a different man and ready to try and find love again, when 'The Bachelor' premieres MONDAY, JANUARY 2 (8:00-10:01 p.m., ET), on the ABC Television Network. (Photo by Rick Rowell/ABC via Getty Images)SHERYL, BEN FLAJNIK
BACHELOR IN PARADISE - 'Episode 101' - This summer, 25 of 'The Bachelor's' biggest stars and most controversial contestants are back looking for a second chance at love on 'Bachelor in Paradise.' They all left 'The Bachelor' or 'The Bachelorette' with broken hearts, but now they are back to find their soul mates. 'Bachelor in Paradise' begins with 14 former cast members, eight women and six men, who travel to beautiful Tulum, Mexico hoping to turn a potential summer fling into the real thing. However, in true 'Bachelor' fashion, there is always a surprise. 'Bachelor in Paradise' premieres MONDAY, AUGUST 4 (8:00-10:00 PM ET/PT), on the ABC Television Network. (Photo by Francisco Rmoan/ABC via Getty Images)
THE BACHELOR - 'Episode 1904' - It's off to San Francisco for Chris and six bachelorettes for the last group date. Dressed in wedding gowns, the women have to complete a difficult mud run with the losers going home and the winner spending a romantic night with Chris. Just so happens the winner is a frontrunner in the race for the Bachelor's heart, and she leaves the other five women in the dust. An amorous mood is set at dinner overlooking the glittering city by the bay, and Chris has a chance to find out about another side of this stunning beauty. Will she capture his heart or leave without a rose? - on 'The Bachelor,' MONDAY, JANUARY 26 (8:00-10:01 p.m., ET), on the ABC Television Network. (Photo by David Moir/ABC via Getty Images)
BACHELOR IN PARADISE - 'Episode 306A' - In the gorgeous resort town of Sayulita, Mexico, the drama continues for the hopeful contestants in the two-night season finale of the highly anticipated 'Bachelor in Paradise,' MONDAY, SEPTEMBER 5 (8:00-10:01 p.m. EDT). (Rick Rowell/ABC via Getty Images) AMANDA STANTON, JOSH MURRAY
HIDE CAPTION
SHOW CAPTION
of
SEE ALL
BACK TO SLIDE

And there may be something to Underwood's logic. Before his season, during which he was just 26 years old, four of the previous five "Bachelors" were over the age of 30

Underwood also briefly discussed Mike Johnson, another standout from Hannah Brown's season who's been seriously discussed for the part. He also touched on "Bachelorette" runner-up Tyler Cameron, who was being considered as a "Bachelor" frontrunner before rumors of his relationship with model Gigi Hadid began surfacing. 

"I know Tyler’s been mentioned," Underwood told AOL, laughing. "But he’s doing his thing now — so he’s fine."

It's unclear when the next "Bachelor" will be announced, but the decision will likely come sooner rather than later. For example, Underwood was officially named as the star of his season on Sept. 4 of last year.  

Read Full Story

Sign up for Entertainment Insider by AOL to get the hottest pop culture news delivered straight to your inbox!

Subscribe to our other newsletters

Emails may offer personalized content or ads. Learn more. You may unsubscribe any time.