Man proposes to girlfriend at BroadwayCon, Michael Urie's reaction takes center stage

Drama took center stage with a surprise proposal at New York’s BroadwayCon.

Actor and director Anthony Logan Cole was on stage in the middle of a speech when he summoned his girlfriend Natalie Chernicoff, who works with him as an equity stage manager.

Once she finally made it through the crowd, it’s hard to tell who was more excited for the moment — the couple or all of the other celebrities on stage. Chief among them? Actor Michael Urie.

“Michael Urie's reaction was my favorite thing I've ever seen. He was 100 percent there and in the moment and loving every second of it,” Chernicoff told InsideEdition.com.

For Cole, the moments leading up to the excitement were nerve-wracking.  

“The ring has been in the apartment for about a month changing hiding places every couple of days. Bringing it to the hotel [and] walking around all day with it in my pocket, [I was] trying not to lose it,” said Cole.

Cole and Chernicoff have been together since 2016. Cole had been planning the proposal for eight months and popped the question with his grandmother’s ring from the 1940s. Everyone there was in on the surprise except for Chernicoff, who revealed she was ready to go home.

She said her friends were able to convince her to stay without blowing the cover.

“I kept trying to leave. [I kept saying] 'I don't want to be here until 10:30. Or what if I go change into pajamas?' They were like, 'What if you don't?'”

Chernicoff said it’s up to Cole for the wedding to be as showstopping as the proposal.

30 PHOTOS
Celebrity Weddings in 2018
See Gallery
Celebrity Weddings in 2018
10.18.2018 ❤️
Took me a minute to get it together, but at long last, for those who have requested, a little look inside the best day of our lives. Link in bio for more. #thefaltrows
Meghan, Duchess of Sussex begins her carriage procession with Britain's Prince Harry, Duke of Sussex in the Ascot Landau Carriage after their wedding ceremony at St George's Chapel, Windsor Castle, in Windsor, on May 19, 2018. (Photo by CHRIS JACKSON / POOL / AFP) (Photo credit should read CHRIS JACKSON/AFP/Getty Images)
WINDSOR, ENGLAND - OCTOBER 12: Princess Eugenie of York and Jack Brooksbank leave St George's Chapel in Windsor Castle following their wedding at St. George's Chapel on October 12, 2018 in Windsor, England. (Photo by Pool/Samir Hussein/WireImage)
Happiest day of my life. @priyankachopra
And forever starts now... ❤️ @nickjonas
Happy ever forever 💏 🐶 wearing custom @reemacra in my dream cape and @jenniferbehr in my hair!.. 💫 @claudcraig 📷
Was gonna wait a while to say anything but word travels fast, listen plain and simple Hailey I am soooo in love with everything about you! So committed to spending my life getting to know every single part of you loving you patiently and kindLY. I promise to lead our family with honor and integrity letting Jesus through his Holy Spirit guide us in everything we do and every decision we make. My heart is COMPLETELY and FULLY YOURS and I will ALWAYS put you first! You are the love of my life Hailey Baldwin and I wouldn’t want to spend it with anybody else. You make me so much better and we compliment eachother so well!! Can’t wait for the best season of life yet!. It’s funny because now with you everything seems to make sense! The thing I am most excited for is that my little brother and sister get to see another healthy stable marriage and look for the same!!! Gods timing really is literally perfect, we got engaged on the seventh day of the seventh month, the number seven is the number of spiritual perfection, it’s true GOOGLE IT! Isn’t that nuts? By the way I didn’t plan that, anyways My goodness does feel good to have our future secured! WERE GONNA BE BETTER AT 70 BABY HERE WE GO! “He who finds a wife finds a good thing and obtains FAVOR from the Lord!” This is the year of favor!!!!
Wow what a day I’m so in love!!
The Reception... #VirginiaIsForTerrence 7.21.18
Okay, so we went and did it. And damn are we happy. Bride: @eattravelrock Photographer: @NicoleGoddard
#oneweek (and they said it wouldn’t last) #happiestmanonearth #happiestplaceonearth @waltdisneyworld
It happened...my dream came true. I married the man of my dreams in the middle of an enchanting redwood grove with all our loved ones around, including my rescue, Kai as our ring bearer. 🙌🏽💫💞 8.18.18 #Philary Check out the link in my bio for more! 👆🏽 Thanks to the genius @aspictures for capturing the magic! 📸 And @voguemagazine, @vogueliving_us, @overthemoon for your beautiful story.
@robandlindsayweddings
11.24.18. Pimentel life moments! New levels and unforgettable memories shared with our closest friends and family. So much love and gratitude for everyone that made our special day truly unforgettable. We love you all. You can see more photos @voguemagazine put a link in my story !!
2.23.18
Mr. & Mrs Harington! ♥️
Yesterday was rehearsal dinner today wedding! Everything turned out amazing 📸 by @chardphoto #bigday #wedding
Robin Wright and Clement Giraudet
More pictures and details of Felicity Jones and Charles Guard wedding. Courtesy of Felicity Jones's sister and Hannah Teare. #felicityjones #eddieredmayne #thetheoryofeverything #fantasticbeastsandwheretofindthem #thedanishgirl #jupiterascending #rogueone #amonstercalls #inferno #stephenhawking #janehawking #hannahbagshawe #charlesguard
Trying to give the kids something to remember
Thank you to all of our friends and family who made their way to celebrate with us! We are eternally grateful. And to @lelarose and your incredible team for creating my dream dress... Thank you times a million 💕💕💕 📷 @charliedailey
Thanks to Joey, Andrew, Katherine, Jack and Elijah for sharing this special day with us!
5 years ago today I met my best friend and the love of my life! I can’t believe it has been 5 years. Time flies when you have the most amazing woman on earth by your side ❤️
With my love @emmaportner at #thecured premiere...in select theatres tomorrow! @ifcfilms @_samkeeley Hair @hairbyjohnd Makeup @tobyfleischman
🌴☀️🌴
Well we did it finally! It was an amazing day despite the miserable British weather. Fabulous service conducted by Trish Harrogate, chief Registrar for Devon, who set the perfect but lighthearted tone for what is a serious occasion. The accompanying gospel choir were amazing. Thank you so much to Bristol’s Teachers Rock Choir for your superb singing. Also @venetianorrington for the great photos. Most importantly a massive thanks to my 3 gorgeous girls for being so understanding and supportive, without their support this could never have happened! And finally the biggest thank you to James for being just perfect......#wedidit #wonderfulday #despitetherain
5 years ago today I met my best friend and the love of my life! I can’t believe it has been 5 years. Time flies when you have the most amazing woman on earth by your side ❤️
One month later and still in awe by all of the love and incredible energy this weekend... Happy one month my love 🐣💘 #TessaBarron2018
HIDE CAPTION
SHOW CAPTION
of
SEE ALL
BACK TO SLIDE

RELATED STORIES

Dolphin Lends a Fin for Man's Proposal: 'Will You Marry Me?'

From Puppies to Lost Rings: All the Greatest Proposal Moments of 2018

How Woman Finally Tracked Down Mystery Couple in Proposal Photo After 8 Years

 

Read Full Story