Fab or Flop: Kim Kardashian's completely sheer look, Scarlett Johansson's sexy leather top and more

Fab or Flop week of 9/9
See Gallery
Fab or Flop: Kim Kardashian's completely sheer look, Scarlett Johansson's sexy leather top and more

Fab: Scarlett Johansson

Scarlett Johansson looks FIERCE in this all-black getup. The leather top adds extra edge and those shades are so Hollywood glam. We also love the flared pants. Looking hot, Scarlett!

(Photo by Nancy Rivera/Bauer-Griffin/GC Images)

Flop: Pink

While denim dresses are all the rage right now, We don't love how Pink paired hers with knee-high suede boots that don't reveal even an inch of leg. It's not the most flattering look as it makes her legs appear shorter than they are. We also don't love the finish at the bottom of the dress.

(Photo by Alo Ceballos/GC Images)

Fab: Gigi Hadid

As if Gigi could ever be a flop. The fashion-forward model known for her athleisure tastes looked cool and comfortable in black waxed jeans, heeled leather booties, and a loose sleveless top. The yellow cross-body bag adds the perfect pop of color!

(Photo by Alo Ceballos/GC Images)

Flop: Kim Kardashian

While we actually love the peep-toe leather boots and velvet two-piece set, this outfit altogether is just a bit too much. From the ultra-sheer top to the head-to-toe black, Kim looks extremely intense. We suggest she show a little more leg and a little less upper body. Plus, wasn't it like 100 degrees out in NYC this week? The things we do for fashion!

(Photo by Alo Ceballos/GC Images)

Fab: Kendall Jenner

Seriously, Kendall? It's like she intentionally looked perfect just for our benefit. Jenner looks absolutely flawless in this all white getup. She's pulling off almost every trend of the season with her crop top and high waisted skirt, long coat, white-on-white outfit, and slip-on sneakers. All hail queen Kendall!

(Photo by Raymond Hall/GC Images)

Flop: Alison Brie

While Alison Brie always looks adorable, we can't help but think this outfit makes her appear older than she is. Perhaps it's the fit, but the top just seems like too much material for her small figure and we don't love the material of the skirt. Love the red hot shoes, though!

(Photo by Ray Tamarra/GC Images)

Fab: Emily Ratajkowski

Ratajkowski looks sleek and sexy in a simple black shirt dress, studded pointy toe booties, and sophisticated black leather bucket bag. It doesn't get much hotter than this!

(Photo by Alo Ceballos/GC Images)

Flop: Fergie

While Fergie's fanny pack is definitely a notch above the throwback packs we saw in the 80s, we're just not sure it works. It seems to cut her off which is a shame because that dress could really elongate her figure. Maybe save the fanny pack for occasions like Coachella and Bonaroo?

(Photo by Bauer-Griffin/GC Images)

Fab: Kimberley Garner 

Garner looks amazing in her all-over fringe outfit! Who knew fringe and lace would pair so well together? We love the pointy toe booties and of course her puppy is the best accessory. So cute!

 (Photo by Keith Hewitt/GC Images)

Flop: Meg Matthews

It seems Matthews was going for an athleisure look with leggings and a sweater. However, Uggs are not the way to mix fashion and comfort. We would consider letting the guilty pleasure shoes slide if they weren't bedazzled. We also think the look would be a bit nicer if her tote had more shape.

(Photo by Alex Huckle/GC Images)

Fab: Reese Witherspoon

reese Witherspoon is just a ray of sunshine! She looks adorable in her cropped jeans and heeled wide-strap sandals. We're obsessed with her sunhat and chic shades and her long chain necklace is the perfect touch.

(Photo by Bauer-Griffin/GC Images)

Flop: Pia Mia

This outfit is all over the place. While we would understand the look Mia was going for if she left it with the crop top, damaged jeans and gingham chambray, the white coat and suede boots leave us frankly confused. Is she going for grunge chic or Hollywood glam? Some things just don't mix.

(Photo by Neil Mockford/Alex Huckle/GC Images)

Fab: Emily Blunt

Even the lighting in this photo suggests that Emily Blunt radiates sunshine. She looks amazing in the semi-revealing gray top and classic black pencil skirt. This is how to make simplicity look fabulous! Minimalism FTW.

(Photo by RB/Bauer-Griffin/GC Images)

Flop: Sienna Miller

The clog shoe may be back this season, but the shag coat definitely isn't. We're not even sure what material this coat is made of, but we're not loving it. Maybe if Sienna accessorized a bit with oversized shades and some trendy rings, the look would tie together better.

(Photo by Keith Hewitt/GC Images)

Fab: Hailey Baldwin

Baldwin re-defines "golden girl" in this stunning silk number. The black booties and gold chain bag are the perfect accessories to complement the outfit. Looking great, Kailey Baldwin!

(Photo by MPI67/Bauer-Griffin/GC Images)

Flop: Tracy Anderson

While each of these items would be acceptable individually, together they make Anderson look a bit frumpy. We suggest she sport the skirt in an off-white shade and maybe choose a long-sleeve button up as opposed to this tan sweater. The shades are fun but definitely don't work with the outfit.

(Photo by Josiah Kamau/BuzzFoto via Getty Images)

Fab: Emma Watson

Yass Emma Watson! The star looks chic and edgy in all black. We love the leather jacket paired with ankle-high leather boots. The V-neck cotton top is the perfect edge to make the look extra casual chic. Loving it, Emma Watson!

(Photo by GVK/Bauer-Griffin/GC Images)


As Thursday marked the start of New York Fashion Week, dozens of stylish celebs stepped out in the Big Apple this week to show off their trendy fall looks. Even those who stayed around L.A. and London seemed to put their best fashion feet forward in honor of the momentous week ahead.

The biggest trend this week was definitely the all-black look. Celebs looks chic and sleek in head to toe black, and the best trendsetters added fun accessories for a unique pop of color. We especially loved Gigi Hadid's yellow cross-body bag that perfectly complemented her casual black getup. Scarlett Johansson also brought a Hollywood glam vibe to NYC with a sexy black leather top and oversized shades that scream "Breakfast at Tiffany's."

SEE ALSO:Fab or flop: Selena Gomez's plunging neckline, Halle Berry's barely-there top, and more

The winner of the week, of course, was Kendall Jenner. While Jenner never ceases to amaze us with her dazzling tastes, the star stepped out in all white this week and looks absolutely flawless. She somehow mixed slip-on-sneakers with a long fabulous peacoat while managing to maintain a full-on regal appeal.

While many celebs looked fab this weekend, there are always a handful of flops in the mix. Kim Kardashian took the head-to-toe black trend a bit too far and came off looking more intimidating than trendy. Others, like Pink, disregarded the fall vibe altogether and went with a denim dress and knee-high boots that did nothing for her figure and looked frankly frumpy.

Click through the gallery to check out all of the best and worst of this week's celeb style and come back and VOTE in our poll below!

Watch this video for a look at NYFW 2015:

NYFW Fall 2015: Joie

More from AOL.com:
Who wore what this weekend: Kylie Jenner's epic birthday party, Teen Choice Awards and more
Fab or flop: Kim Kardashian's skin-tight two piece, Meryl Streep's funky jumpsuit
The best summer clothing trends of 2015
Read Full Story