TV upfronts: Superhero fare, 'Scream Queens' among new shows making the biggest social splash

This Is What You Will Be Watching This Fall
This Is What You Will Be Watching This Fall

Upfronts week is over, but the battle among the broadcast networks' new offerings has only just begun.

Much like the new 2015-16 broadcast schedules themselves, superheroes and other hot comic book properties are leading the pack so far in terms of social buzz. According to Way to Blue, CBS' Supergirl ranks second among all new shows with more than 117,000 total social mentions. DC's Legends of Tomorrow, The CW spinoff of Arrow and The Flash, is third with just over 63,000.

Way to Blue measured the total number of mentions about a show -; including title variations and misspellings -; across Twitter, blogs, online forums and news items over a one-week period.

Read MoreTV Upfronts: Seven Studio Chiefs on Trends, Surprises and That Major Disappointment

Shows with built-in brand recognition like the revivals of The Muppets (39,072) and The X-Files (28,340), as well as the TV adaptations of hit films Minority Report (17,818) and Limitless (13,021) are also trending high.

However, top among the 39 new shows listed is Ryan Murphy's new horror comedy Scream Queens with more than 122,000 social mentions. The Fox entry starring Jamie Lee Curtis and Emma Roberts was picked up straight to series in October and Fox has taken full advantage of its early head start. Special teaser clips for the series were released Feb. 13 and March 13, and have since notched 1 million and 2.6 million views, respectively. Additionally, the series already has more than 65,000 followers on Twitter and more than 42,000 YouTube channel subscribers.

Read MoreTV Upfronts By the Numbers: Total Orders Drop as Superheroes, Doctors and Remakes Take Over

On YouTube, Supergirl is by far the winner with 10.1 million views clocked since the trailer was released late Wednesday. Once again, the trailer for DC's Legends of Tomorrow is close behind with 4.2 million views. Promos for Minority Report (1.2 million) and The Muppets (881,000) are also leading the pack.

But it's not all good news. So far, new comedies appear to be having the toughest time breaking through the heavy social media static. Fox's The Guide to Surviving Life, ABC's The Real O'Neals and The CW's Crazy Ex-Girlfriend all have garnered less than 2,000 social mentions each. Despite its big-screen pedigree, the trailer for ABC's Uncle Buck has the lowest number of views among all the new shows with just a little more than 32,000.

Keep up with all the renewals, cancellations and new series orders with THR's handy Scorecard.