Secret (and Sometimes Shocking) Ingredients That Made Your Nana's Cooking Taste So Good
The Secret Ingredient Isn't Just Love
Some of our families' favorite, time-honored recipes include ingredients that make the dishes incredibly delicious — and make today's health-conscious cooks cringe. So long as you don't overindulge, we think it's perfectly fine to take a journey through time and revisit recipes for everything from Old Fashioned Lard Biscuits (yes, we said lard) to Grandma's Secret Ingredient Chicken Salad (hint: Cool Whip). Bon appétit!
Old-Fashioned Lard Biscuits
"If you have never had a biscuit made with lard, you need to. Read: NEED." So says Kristin Hoffman, who shares this retro recipe for biscuits that forgo the expected butter for lard. We can't wait to try them.
Recipe: Baker Bettie
Beef Fudge
Yes, beef fudge. Apparently back in the 1960s, wives of cattle farmers had an abundance of beef on hand and came up with some pretty creative recipes. The shocker is that a blogger today not only uncovered this recipe in a vintage cookbook but made it and proclaimed it a success. Game?
Recipe: Mid-Century Menu
Vintage Recipe for Easy Bread
This recipe, a favorite of a blogger’s grandmother, is surprising in that it doesn't use yeast. Instead, it features Grape-Nuts cereal, around since 1897, plus buttermilk.
Recipe: Two Healthy Kitchens
Related: Pie Crust and Other Delicious Uses for Cereal Besides Breakfast
Grape Jelly Meatballs
A cocktail party or a casual luncheon at home provided the perfect setting for this dish 1960s hostesses made ad nauseam. Now, it's prepared for their grandkids who've never had anything like it.
Recipe: Spend With Pennies
Whipping Cream Pound Cake
I'd heard of sour cream pound cake, but this is a new one. Thanks to a blogger who cut the retro recipe out of a newspaper (and eventually also found it in a cookbook that claimed it was a favorite of Elvis Presley's), this recipe has been passed down in many families. It's said to make a cake with a nice crust that yields to a velvety inside.
Recipe: Call Me PMC
Grandma's Secret Ingredient Chicken Salad
Have any of the many chicken salads you've had over the years been truly memorable? That might change if you try this recipe in which the "secret sauce" is a mix of sour cream, mayonnaise, and … Cool Whip!
Recipe: Shaken Together
Grandma's Pecan Pie
Pure maple syrup elevates one family's recipe for a dessert that's a time-honored way to end many a holiday meal.
Recipe: The Old Farmer's Almanac
Crispy Duck Fat Potatoes
If your grandmother was French, she might have had Pommes de Terre Sarladaise in her repertoire. What makes this traditional starchy side a delight — crispy on the outside and light and buttery on the inside — is the unexpected method of frying in duck fat.
Recipe: Salt Pepper Skillet
Cornish Pasties
For those who look at a hand pie and expect the payoff to be a mouthful of fruit, Cornish Pasties will be a surprise. Long a British regional favorite, you can find many a gran creating a crust that gets its delicate flakiness from shortening and its savory filling from beef top round steak.
Recipe: Taste of Home
Related: Savory Pies From Around The World
Impossible Pumpkin Pie
Some days, even nana was tired. This recipe — which includes Bisquick mix added right into the batter — creates a creamy seasonal dessert that saves the home cook plenty of time. No pie shell needed.
Recipe: Grandma's Leftovers
Sweet Cookie Salad with Homemade Cookies and Mandarins
Molly Yeh, star of "Girl Meets Farm" on the Food Network, often shares new-to-her recipes that are actually Midwestern staples. This one's a classic — and the word "salad" is the unexpected element. Yes, Yeh shares, it's eaten with the main course, not as dessert. If you insist …
Recipe: Food Network
Sausage and Spinach Tortellini Soup
A recipe contributor from Ohio shares this twist on a minestrone-style soup that was a favorite of her husband's grandmother. But don't expect beef — the rich flavor comes from sausage. Modern cooks will also find it a quick way to add greens to the meal, here with fresh spinach.
Recipe: Taste of Home
Cornflake Cookies
A good cook is always seeking new recipes. This blogger's grandmother, long known for her chocolate chip cookies, tried a recipe from a friend that became a new family favorite. Who would think to use corn flakes in dessert? Someone smart, apparently.
Recipe: Spoon University
Beef Stew in Red Wine
There's always that saucy grandma for whom this option from the "Grandma's Favorite Recipes" collection — a classic comfort dish that gets its richness and depth from red wine — would be a favorite.
Recipe: Eat This, Not That!
Mashed Potatoes
Tyler Florence shared his secret for out-of-the-ordinary mashed potatoes on the Food Network's "Clash of the Grandmas," which put the spotlight on retro dishes with flavors that are "bold, fresh, and timeless." The secret here? You add a bay leaf to the pot when boiling the potatoes for an unexpected flavor infusion.
Recipe: Food Network
Best Ever Vintage Potato Salad
Show me a grandma and I'll show you yet another potato salad recipe. One blogger gives a nod to her Mimi's recipe as "best ever." We can't decide if the one she shares is worthy of the applause because of the evaporated milk or the sugar — both unexpected ingredients caught our attention.
Recipe: Town & Country Living
Lemony Turkey Rice Soup
This untraditional turkey soup comes to us via a Texas grandmother who infused her comfort-food staple with zest in the form of lemon and cilantro.
Recipe: Taste of Home
Mace Cake
Say the word "mace" today and many think of someone using a pepper spray to thwart an attacker. Mace, unrelated, is also a spice, one long used in cooking and similar to nutmeg. Grandmas around the world have relied on it for years, including adding it to this moist and pleasing cake.
Recipe: Epicurious.com
Grandma's Anything Goes Strata
Today's breakfast orders of egg-white omelet with spinach are a far cry from Grandma's Anything Goes Strata, a rich casserole that turns random leftovers into a hearty meal. Tailor to what's on hand, with suggestions including "salty deli meat," leftover bread and lots of cheese. It's also a convenient make-ahead option that can be served any time of the day.
Recipe: Food Network
Related: Foods That are Always Better as Leftovers
Egg-Free Chocolate Pudding with Olive Oil and Sea Salt
Simplicity is key in much of any grandma's cooking, but according to a list of "Grandma's Favorite Recipes," savvy grandmas can add depth and richness to pudding with olive oil.
Recipe: Eat This, Not That!
Related: This Surprising Ingredient Makes These Desserts Irresistible
Grandma's Rice Dish
Back in the day, a good cook was not only creative, but thrifty. Leftover rice and ground beef form the basis of this vintage casserole recipe that gets its spark from onion, green pepper, corn, bacon, and an array of spices.
Recipe: Taste of Home
Grandma's Wartime Orange Drop Cookies
This favorite of one family is another nod to ingenuity in the face of adversity. When sugar was rationed during World War II, one clever grandmother came up with this recipe relying on the jolt of orange rind, orange flavoring, and the juice of a fresh orange. The result was the creation of a flavor profile that erases the belief a cookie has to be made with sugar.
Recipe: LoveFoodies.com
Strawberry Pretzel Salad
I can still remember my utter amazement and delight in tasting this "salad" — featuring a pretzel-based crust –for the first time back in the 1980s. It was presented as a treasured family favorite during a gathering I attended when visiting a college friend's family in rural Missouri.
Recipe: Betty Crocker
The Best Homemade Pancake Recipe from Scratch
Cake flour has been many a grandma's secret ingredient — and among contemporary cooks, too. A blogger sharing this recipe notes: "Cake flour in pancakes is the boss," making for one fluffy breakfast dish.
Recipe: The Kitchen Magpie
Grandma's Gingersnap Cookies
Molasses was a staple in many a grandmother's kitchen; today, many of us just buy it for holiday cookies. This recipe has been called a "melt-in-your-mouth" family favorite, and it dates back to the 19th century and features dark molasses.
Recipe: AllRecipes
Mushroom Sour Cream Gravy
Creamy mushroom-based gravy is a staple. This version, a Thanksgiving tradition from a Florida woman's grandmother, takes flavor to the next level with the addition of sour cream.
Recipe: Taste of Home
Grandma Wells' Tuna Macaroni Salad
Forget having a scoop of macaroni salad on the side of a tuna sandwich. With this recipe, the tuna's in the salad. Don't look for carrots, a traditional macaroni-salad ingredient; this recipe draws further flavor bursts from relish, cheddar cheese, and frozen peas.
Recipe: Just a Pinch
Grandma's Canadian Butter Tarts
The healthy-eating police get a day off for this holiday indulgence with a surprise inside: You get to choose if you use pecans, raisins, or that favorite ingredient of many grandmothers, currants.
Recipe: Dish ‘n' the Kitchen
Grandmother's Beer Batter
Everyone knows the addition of beer can turn a routine batter into something special. This one is billed as being suitable "for all things fried," so you decide if it's going to be fish, shrimp, onion rings, or …
Recipe: Just a Pinch
Related: Chef Secrets for Crisp, Juicy Fried Chicken
Onion Pie
Apple pie. Cherry pie. Peach pie. Nope, one Massachusetts woman shares her grandmother's recipe for this dish that's far from dessert. Onion Pie resembles a frittata, offering up a punch of flavor ideal to complement most meats (or as a vegetarian entrée) and fancy enough for the holiday table.
Recipe: Taste of Home
Grandma's Chocolate Crazy Cake
During the Depression, desserts were created out of what was on hand. The invention of "wacky" or "crazy" cakes offered a way to satisfy the family's sweet tooth with limited ingredients. This recipe, which today's palates will note is vegan, is known not only for what it includes — cocoa, sugar, and white vinegar — as for what it doesn't: milk or eggs.
Recipe: VegFamily
Related: Simple Depression-Era Desserts That Actually Are Indulgent
Pennsylvania Dutch Potato Doughnuts
This family recipe allows you to feel a bit smug — hey, it's got vegetables in it — as you savor a doughnut that has its moistness enhanced by adding potatoes to the batter. Don't worry; the glaze keeps it all sweet, rather than turning into a savory treat.
Recipe: Taste of Home
Related: Expert Tips for Making Doughnuts at Home
Grandma Gwen's Beans
Forget the boring can of baked beans pulled out for every barbecue and try this award-winning family recipe with four kinds of beans, along with brown sugar, mustard, vinegar, and bacon.
Recipe: My Recipes
Related: 55 Big-Batch Meals That Will Last for a Week
Saltine Cracker Candy with Toasted Pecans
A Canadian grandmother shares her ingenious recipe for satisfying the candy craving with a cracker-based recipe.
Recipe: Taste of Home
Marshmallow Puffs
Grandma's the one who never refuses you a treat, right? This recipe shared by a contemporary Grandma doesn't use marshmallow simply as an ingredient — it's basically the focal point of a kid-pleasing (and super easy) recipe that covers marshmallows with a chocolate-peanut butter sauce. Chill, cut, and watch them disappear.
Recipe: Taste of Home
Coca-Cola Meatloaf
No need to pour a soda when eating this dinner — it's in the main dish. A blogger's grandmother got it from her younger sister, and the family's been enjoying this not-your-everyday meatloaf ever since.
Recipe: Just a Pinch
Related: Cheap and Easy One-Pot Meals
This article was originally published on Cheapism
More From Cheapism
Like Cheapism's content? Be sure to follow us.
