Here's When Crying Can Actually Help You Win a Negotiation
For most people, crying at work sounds mortifying — and may even bring up humiliating memories.
But new research finds that sometimes shedding a few tears can be used to your advantage.
A study published in the Journal of Applied Psychology shows that expressing sadness in a face-to-face interaction can sometimes help you during a negotiation.
The study, called "Weep and Get More," found that expressing sadness can increase your ability to claim value in negotiations because it can "make recipients experience greater other-concern."
But it only happens in specific situations and depends on the relationship and status of the negotiators.
Researchers from INSEAD, the University of Michigan, the University of Paris, and EMLYON examined face-to-face negotiations in a series of three experiments. The first experiment focused on structural features of the situation, and the second and third experiments focused on the relationship-related features.
The study found a few specific situations where the expresser of sadness is at an advantage:1. If the crier is perceived as being in a lower-power position
Whether you're in tears in front of your supervisor or the company's CEO, your chances of leaving a negotiation happy are increased if you're viewed as a lower power.
"A person who perceives you as having lower power and feels concern for you may help you or make more concessions, leading you to gain relatively more," said Shirli Kopelman, one of the researchers and a professor at the Ross School of Business at the University of Michigan.
2. If the recipient expects a future interaction
Crying during a bombed job interview may provide no benefits for you because the interviewer may never see you again.
But if you're negotiating for a raise or extra time off with your current employer, they may be more sympathetic and concede to your request because you will most certainly be in contact again.
3. If the relationship is collaborative
There's a good chance a coworker would show you sympathy simply because they see you on a daily basis. (However, it is also safe to assume they would become very fed up with you if the sobbing became a common occurrence.)
Just like being in a lower-power position, expressing sadness can be beneficial if the other party perceives the relationship as collaborative, Kopelman says.