The Coming Catalyst for Bank of America's Stock


There are few serious investors who don't realize the significance of this week for Bank of America .

On Thursday, the bank concluded a lengthy court proceeding into whether a multibillion-dollar settlement between it and a number of Wall Street's biggest institutional investors should be approved by the New York judiciary. The case is now in the hands of Justice Barbara Kapnick, who could deliver her ruling anytime between now and, presumably, the early part of next year.

Make no mistake about it: This is a very big deal for Bank of America. If the $8.5 billion accord dating back to 2011 isn't approved, not only will its shares trade under an even deeper cloud of uncertainty, but there's every reason to believe that renewed negotiations between the parties would cost the Charlotte-based bank billions of dollars in added fees and expenses.

The underlying issue before the court is relatively straightforward. Governed by New York trust law, Kapnick must decide whether The Bank of New York Mellon , serving as the trustee over securities backed by Countrywide-issued mortgages, violated its fiduciary duty to investors in the securities by entering into the accord with Bank of America. That is, given what BNY Mellon knew at the time, did it act reasonably in agreeing to the terms of the deal?

The objectors -- spearheaded, at this point, principally by American International Group -- argue that the agreement should be rescinded because it wasn't the result of an arms-length transaction, was tainted by multiple conflicts of interest, and resulted in a "pennies on the dollar" bottom line that doesn't adequately compensate the aggrieved investors. To prove their case, they brought in experts, marshalled reams of data, and employed some of the top legal minds in the country.

But that's all in the past. The only thing that matters now is Judge Kapnick's decision.

Being a former law clerk myself -- and thus the author of numerous federal judicial opinions -- I can attest to one thing: It's impossible to predict how Kapnick will rule, or, for that matter, how long it will take her to do so. She may not even know at this point. In a case of this size, there is invariably plenty of evidence to justify a ruling in either side's favor.

As a result, trying to game the outcome from an investment perspective is fruitless at best. Will its shares move when the decision is announced? I can't help but think that they will -- and that they'll do so aggressively. But besides the inherent unpredictability, there are any number of intervening forces that could render the associated move irrelevant.

What if the U.S. government goes after Bank of America like it did JPMorgan Chase? What if the Federal Reserve begins to taper its third round of quantitative easing? What if, heaven forbid, unemployment plummets unexpectedly? What if the holiday shopping season drops like a rock, as many analysts and commentators have forecast?

The point I'm trying to make is this: The BNY Mellon settlement is hugely important to Bank of America. There's no use denying that. But for prudent investors in the company, myself included, it's critical, albeit hard, to look past these short-term catalysts in favor of a much greater payoff down the road.

One explosive stock for opportunistic investors
The market stormed out to huge gains across 2013, leaving investors on the sidelines burned. However, opportunistic investors can still find huge winners. The Motley Fool's chief investment officer has just hand-picked one such opportunity in our new report: "The Motley Fool's Top Stock for 2014." To find out which stock it is and read our in-depth report, simply click here. It's free!

The article The Coming Catalyst for Bank of America's Stock originally appeared on

John Maxfield owns shares of Bank of America. The Motley Fool recommends American International Group and Bank of America. The Motley Fool owns shares of American International Group and Bank of America and has the following options: long January 2016 $30 calls on American International Group. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

Copyright © 1995 - 2013 The Motley Fool, LLC. All rights reserved. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

Originally published