Valve: Console Gaming Will Die, Player-Created Content Is the Future

Valve: Console Gaming Will Die, Player-Created Content Is the Future

Known for hit gaming titles like Left 4 Dead and Dota 2, Valve appears to be preparing an all-out assault on the traditional console companies.

Valve has long been a cornerstone of PC gaming. Its digital distribution platform, Steam, functions as sort of an iTunes for PC games. By some estimates, Steam accounts for 50% to 70% of the market for digital downloads.

Soon that dominance could extend to the living room. Gabe Newell, Valve's managing director, hinted at the long-rumored Steam Box console during a speech at LinuxCon on Monday, while at the same time, arguing for the inevitable decline of the existing console players.

PC gaming leads in innovation
Gaming has changed dramatically in recent years. Radical new genres, new business models, and new features have sprung up -- all thanks to PC gaming, at least according to Newell.

He has a point. Social games, the genre of games popularized by (relatively new) companies like Zynga, started on the PC. Although they eventually migrated to mobile platforms, games like FarmVille and Mafia Wars owe their early success to the traditional PC's browser.

Massively multiplayer games (MMOs) also originated on the PC, and outside of a handful of titles, they've never really made the jump. Activision-Blizzard's World of Warcraft has been, since 2004, one of the most profitable and most popular games ever created. It remains a PC exclusive to this day.

At the same time, gaming companies are increasingly embracing alternative ways of doing business. Many PC MMOs (including World of Warcraft -- to some extent) have embraced the free-to-play model (f2p), as an alternative to traditional, up-front costs. Although no gamer is obligated to pay, f2p can often be more profitable for the game creator, as a larger player base may be more likely to purchase optional in-game items or upgrades.

To date, this business model remains almost wholly in the realm of the PC and mobile devices, but there is some evidence that it's beginning to cross over. Microsoft's upcoming console, the Xbox One, will launch with Killer Instinct, a f2p fighting game.

Open systems dominate closed systems
Fundamentally, Valve believes that the PC's advantage over the traditional consoles lies in its ability to offer an open experience.

By nature, traditional consoles are closed systems. Generally speaking, you can only play the games console creators approve -- Nintendo's Wii, for example, is only capable of playing Nintendo-approved games. For the most part, the hardware is not (legally) modifiable, and only controllers that fit the console manufacturers' design can be used.

In contrast, as an open platform, just about anyone can create a game for a PC, and hardware modifications are prevalent. Even software alternations in the form of "mods" are common. Some of the most popular games in the world, including Counter-Strike and Dota 2, originated as player-created mods of pre-existing games (Half-Life and Warcraft III, respectively).

In fact, it is this player creation that underscores Valve's confidence in the future of PC gaming.

Team Fortress 2, one of Valve's more popular PC games, has used player-created content to great success. Through Valve's Steam Workshop, players can create and submit new items for the game. Over time, this has resulted in a multitude of new content -- according to Newell, the Team Fortress 2 community has created more than 10 times more content for the game than Valve itself.

Over time, Newell believes this system of user-generated content will result in more, and better games. Newell characterized the future of gaming as economy of connected nodes, where the vast majority of game content will be created by the players themselves.

But traditional, closed consoles are designed to stifle this sort of innovation. Valve believes they are "antithetical" to the very idea of a user-generated future, and "at odds with the evolution of gaming."

Is Valve about to step into the living room?
That said, perhaps the more general idea of a console -- a box that you plug into your TV -- isn't going away. There have been reports for months that Valve is preparing to launch its own console -- the so-called Steam Box -- and while Newell didn't explicitly announce it on Monday, he made statements to strongly suggest its forthcoming appearance.

Right now ... you're sort of in this bizarre situation where, as soon as you sit on your couch, you're supposed to have lost connection with all of your other computing platforms.... Well, just buy your games all over again!..."Yes, you can have music, but you need to buy it from us".... We thought that was an incorrect way.... You could build something that spanned like the desktop and the 10-foot living room experience.... People are sort of like, "oh, people don't want PCs in their living room".... We need to build something that showed that you could take everything you like about your PC and bring it to your living room... The next step is to release some work we've done on the hardware side.

A Steam Box -- a PC-based, video game console that embraced an open model and user-generated content -- could wreak havoc on the traditional video game consoles long-term. And based on Newell's comments, gamers might not have to wait much longer to get their hands on one.

The Battle for Your Screen Time

Video game makers aren't the only ones making a play for your living room hours. With Americans reportedly spending nearly 34 hours a week watching television, the potential for profits in the space is enormous. The Motley Fool's top experts have created a new free report titled "Will Netflix Own the Future of Television?" The report not only outlines where the future of your screen time is heading, but offers top ideas for how to profit. To get your free report, just click here!

The article Valve: Console Gaming Will Die, Player-Created Content Is the Future originally appeared on

Sam Mattera has no position in any stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool recommends Activision Blizzard. The Motley Fool owns shares of Activision Blizzard and Microsoft. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

Copyright © 1995 - 2013 The Motley Fool, LLC. All rights reserved. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.