With the acquisition of Nokia's smartphone division announced last week, Microsoft has made a decisive move targeted at gaining ground in the all-important mobile market. Unfortunately for the company and its shareholders, though, industry dynamics are providing a considerable headwind against Microsoft in mobile.
A complicated relationship
Microsoft and Nokia have already been working together for nearly three years, yet they haven´t been able to achieve much success in smartphones. According to data from IDC, the Windows Phone platform had a market share of 3.7% during the second quarter of 2013, well behind Apple's iOS with 13.2% and Google's Android with 79.3%.
This relationship has been more beneficial to Microsoft than Nokia, Nokia has remained the only manufacturer deeply committed to Windows Phone, and its devices accounted for 81.6% of all Windows Phone smartphone shipments during the second quarter of 2013 according to IDC. Nokia, on the other hand, has seen its share of the smartphone market fall from 9.4% in 2007 to just 4.3% in 2012.
Nokia is selling a decaying business segment for a reasonable price, so the positive reaction in the stock price after the announcement is quite understandable. When it comes to Microsoft, however, things are very different.
To begin with, this acquisition will most likely affect Microsoft's relationship with manufacturers like Samsung and HTC, which have been providing some support for Windows Phone as a second alternative behind Android. Although it may be tempting to compare this deal with the acquisition of Motorola by Google, things are really very different.
Android is the most popular mobile operating system in the world by a wide margin, leaving the platform would be an enormously risky move for companies like Samsung and HTC. Windows Phone, on the other hand, is much less important to them, so they are much more likely to reduce or even eliminate support for Windows Phone after the Microsoft-Nokia deal.
Considering how important Nokia has always been for Windows Phone, the acquisition could be seen as a defensive move in order to protect Microsoft from the possibility of Nokia breaking apart and supporting another operating system in the future.
But the fact remains that Microsoft is going all-in: The company will likely lose support from other partners, so building its own successful smartphones after the acquisition may be Microsoft´s last chance of joining the mobile revolution.
Integrating 32,000 Nokia employees with Microsoft's 100,000 will be no easy task at all, especially considering Microsoft's mediocre track record when it comes to acquisitions and the fact that both companies have been facing serious difficulties on their own.
But the biggest challenge for Microsoft in the smartphone market is coming from its position of competitive weakness. While Apple is the high end leader with its unique brand power and high end hardware, Android smartphones from Samsung and other companies cover a wide variety of options and price points.
The network effect is a key competitive factor in the mobile business. Developers prioritize platforms which provide access to big masses of users, and users choose those platforms which include all the popular apps. Users attract developers and vice versa, that´s why achieving critical mass is of utmost importance when it comes to creating a competitive mobile platform.
Google makes many of the most popular native applications in the world like Gmail, Maps, YouTube and Search among many others, and the company makes them available for both Android and iOS.
But Google doesn't make most of its apps available for Windows Phone, users can find some third party alternatives to native Google applications, but that's still a material disadvantage for Microsoft in mobile. Google can't afford to keep its apps away from Apple users, but things are different when it comes to Windows Phone and its small market share.
In mobile, winners tend to keep on winning due to the network effect. Microsoft will need to build some truly great products if it's going to overcome this disadvantage. Considering the company's experience in mobile over the last years, the odds are not looking very good.
Microsoft has made an aggressive move by acquiring Nokia´s smartphone business, the company will likely lose support from other partners, so succeeding with its own integrated products is now of utmost importance.
The network effect represents a strong disadvantage against Microsoft in mobile though, and the company doesn't have a great track record when it comes to acquisitions or hardware, so things could be getting worse before they get any better for Microsoft investors in the middle term.
The article Heavy Headwinds Against Microsoft in Mobile originally appeared on Fool.com.
Andres Cardenal owns shares of Apple and Google. The Motley Fool recommends Apple and Google. The Motley Fool owns shares of Apple, Google, and Microsoft. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.
Copyright © 1995 - 2013 The Motley Fool, LLC. All rights reserved. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.