Proxy Advisory Firm Fined $300K for Alleged Data Breach

Securiities and Exchange Commission seal SEC
Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images
By Sarah N. Lynch

WASHINGTON -- Institutional Shareholder Services settled civil charges by U.S. regulators that an employee of the prominent proxy advisory firm shared nonpublic voting data in exchange for meals and concert tickets.

The Securities and Exchange Commission said Thursday that ISS, a unit of MSCI Inc. (MSCI), will pay a $300,000 penalty and hire an independent compliance consultant.

In settling, ISS neither admitted nor denied the SEC allegations that it violated financial adviser rules designed to prevent misuse of material non-public customer information.

Mutual funds, pension organizations and other institutional investors hire firms like ISS to advise them on how to vote on important corporate issue such as executive compensation and board appointments.

The SEC alleged that from 2007 through 2009, an ISS employee provided a proxy solicitor, a firm that rounds up shareholder votes, with nonpublic information revealing how more than 100 ISS clients were voting their proxy ballots.
Sponsored Links

Cheryl Gustitus, a spokeswoman for ISS, said the firm took "swift action of its own" and also cooperated with the SEC.

"The confidentiality of our clients' information is essential," she said. "We now consider this matter closed."

The case marked the first time the SEC has sued a proxy advisory firm, according to an agency spokesman.

Business groups such as the U.S. Chamber of Commerce have long complained about the influence that proxy advisory firms like ISS can wield in corporate elections.

Most recently, ISS urged JPMorgan Chase (JPM) shareholders to vote against the re-election of three board members, saying they failed to oversee the bank's risk-taking that led to $6.2 billion in losses from bad credit known as the "London Whale" trades.

Those directors won reelection earlier this week, but they received less than 60 percent of the vote.

The SEC alleged that the ISS employee who revealed the voting intentions of clients received $11,500 worth of sporting and concert tickets, as well as $20,000 in meals.

"Based on emails between the ISS employee and the proxy solicitor, the ISS employee provided the information to the proxy solicitor as a quid pro quo for the tickets and meals he received," the SEC said.

The SEC didn't provide the name of the ISS employee or the proxy solicitor employee.

5 Stocks Investors Love to Hate
See Gallery
Proxy Advisory Firm Fined $300K for Alleged Data Breach

Satellite radio has never been more popular. There are now 23.9 million subscribers after the parent company of Sirius and XM closed out 2012 with 2 million more accounts than it had when the year began.

However, Sirius XM lost its longstanding CEO late last year, and a media conglomerate has acquired a controlling stake in the satellite radio provider -- events that have triggered uncertainty. 

Still, Sirius XM is a company that has been consistently profitable and generating growing amounts of revenue and free cash flow on its own. And, auto sales also remain strong: Those represent the largest source of new subscribers for Sirius XM, as most of its users tune in through car factory-installed receivers.

A few years ago, Nokia was the undisputed top dog in mobile phone handsets. The Finnish company was a global juggernaut at a time when consumers were swapping beepers -- remember those? -- for wireless phones.

But the market has evolved repeatedly since then. Cheaper feature phones have been replaced by smartphones that run apps and surf the Web, and Nokia has been slow to embrace the platforms that matter. Obviously it couldn't put out an iPhone, but it also wasn't able to match Samsung's early push into Android devices that are now globally popular.

Nokia is accepting billions to back Microsoft's fledgling Windows Phone mobile operating system, but the stock has been stuck in the single digits for more than two years.

It isn't easy being a regional telco, offering up landlines, Internet, and cable TV to rural markets.

A big draw for investors in Frontier Communications is its meaty dividend payout. Even after slashing its quarterly rate from $0.1875 a share to $0.10 a share last year, the stock's still yielding 10 percent. The large dividend is significant, since shorts actually have to cover that when it gets paid out.

Analysts see revenue and profitability continuing to decline here, and pessimists are holding out for more dividend cuts in the future.

The old "Intel inside" ads came out at a time when PC sales were booming. Manufacturers were hopping on Intel microprocessors to power desktops and laptops, only turning to smaller rival Advanced Micro Devices (AMD) when they wanted to show Intel that they weren't entirely dependent on the chip giant.

But the tech world have taken an "Intel outside" approach in recent years. PC shipments have fallen for two years, and Intel's efforts to get its chips into the smartphones and tablets that people are actually buying haven't been effective enough to offset its declines on the PC side.

The poster child for the "too big to fail" banking giants is starting to bounce back.

Bank of America stock hit a fresh 52-week high this month, and regulators finally eased up on the bank after it cleared its stress test. That freed Bank of America to return more of its money to shareholders beyond its token quarterly dividend of $0.01 a share, and the financial services giant's first move was to declare a huge share repurchase program.

As long as the housing market holds up and the general state of corporate America makes lending money to companies a smart bet, Bank of America will do just fine. Shorts, naturally, don't see it that way at all.

Read Full Story
  • DJI27359.1627.160.10%
  • NIKKEI 22521530.37-155.53-0.72%
    Hang Seng28587.5632.680.11%
  • USD (PER EUR)1.130.00010.01%
    USD (PER CHF)1.02-0.0009-0.09%
    JPY (PER USD)107.990.10400.10%
    GBP (PER USD)1.25-0.0002-0.02%