Renting a Room in Your House: Why It Might Not Be the Best Idea

Renting a room in your house: For rent sign
Renting a room in your house: For rent sign
Houselogic logo
Houselogic logo

By Donna DeZube

Find a great housemate and you can end up with a new best friend. Make a bad choice, and you can end up with a fiend. I had the fiend experience back in the '80s when I agreed to split a two-bedroom house with a college student whom I'd just met. It took me a few months to realize that the textbooks she carried around were a prop that she used to do a naughty schoolgirl routine at the massage parlor where she worked. Her chronic sniffles weren't from allergies; they were from too much cocaine snorting.

That was the end of my willingness to share my space until I met my husband. We have a lot of extra space in our current home, but I'd have to be really hard up for cash to rent out any of it. There are apparently several million people who disagree with me. The Census Bureau says 6.2 million Americans live in shared households (not counting the 15.8 million adults who live with their parents). Among the people who think I'm way wrong about house-sharing: Crystal Stemberger, a blogger who's rented a spare bedroom in her Houston home to five different people over the past six years.

Her first roommate was a friend who simply needed a place to live for a while. "A while" turned out to be four months and when he moved out, Stemberger and her husband decided that having housemates agreed with them. "We were addicted to the pretty easy extra money that was covering two-thirds of our mortgage by itself," she says. They put an ad on Craigslist to find a replacement renter. (Fortunately, the Stembergers didn't live in Boston, where at the time "Craigslist killer" Philip Markoff trolled for victims.)

Their second roommate was a single guy with a busy social life and a heavy workload that kept him out of the house. "When he was around, he was clean, friendly, and was always very helpful," Stemberger says. "He stayed for more than a year and we still miss him." A housemate that doesn't come home sounds good to me. Annamarie Pluhar, who blogs for the website Sharing Housing, says money is the first thing people think about. "You save literally thousands of dollars in a year," she says. But what ends up making a difference in your life is having help with household tasks, such as maintenance and pet sitting.

Pluhar adds to her list of positives: "having someone there to find you when you fall and can't get up"-- after a woman in her hometown of Brattleboro, Vt., slipped on an icy front sidewalk and died of hypothermia when no one noticed her. Great housemates not only find you when you're lying unconscious on your icy sidewalk, they create relationships that are different than the ones you have with friends, Pluhar says. "You pass each other in the kitchen and say, 'Hi,' or you spend 45 minutes talking about the latest things. It's a daily connection with someone who can really lift your life."

I get that if you're single, but if you're married, that's what your spouse allegedly does. Maybe a housemate would work out if he'd do all the things my husband and I don't want to do -- like tackle Laundry Mountain or seal the driveway.

This article was originally published on HouseLogic.

See more on HouseLogic:
Another Happy Family Living in a Tiny House
Why Declutter Your House?
World's Easiest-to-Build House

More on AOL Real Estate:
Find out how to
calculate mortgage payments.
Find foreclosures in your area.
Find homes for rent in your area.

See celebrity real estate.

Airbnb Host Rents Rooms from His Apartment
Airbnb Host Rents Rooms from His Apartment