3-D printing has become all the rage among investors. Imagine the possibilities, imagine bringing manufacturing home from China, there will soon be a 3-D printer on everyone's desk, or so the story goes. Sometimes the market gets big eyes and draws conclusions before we even decide what technology will win or what is most important in the future of 3-D printing.
3D Systems , ExOne , and Stratasys are fighting for market share but start-ups like MakerBot are close behind, ready to upend the established competitors. The question investors need to be asking is: What will be the one constant in the industry that we can count on in the long term?
A game of chance
Betting on the companies that make 3-D printers is a roll of the dice right now. 3D Systems' earnings today show just what a gamble it can be. Even a 45% increase in quarterly revenue didn't hit expectations, which sent shares tumbling. The reason is simple: Over the past year, the price/earnings multiple of 3-D printer makers has skyrocketed and they're now priced for perfection.
Even a small miss can be terrible for earnings, as we saw today. Both 3D Systems and Stratasys are priced for perfection and small misses like this exacerbate the problem for shareholders. ExOne went public without the benefit of being profitable and isn't growing as quickly as 3D Systems. The company brings even more risk to shareholders.
I think investing in the equipment maker space is risky at best and a bubble waiting to pop at worst. Long-term winners will emerge but the industry is far from mature; these companies don't yet deserve the valuations they've been given.
The key to the future
Where investors should really be watching is software. None of the 3-D technology works without the software to make a 3-D model. The best company to look at in this space is Autodesk , the well-established maker of modeling software for a variety of industries. Autodesk makes a number of different software products for varying levels of skill. From Autodesk Inventor to AutoCAD to the new Autodesk 123D for 3D Systems, there's something for everyone. The company even makes free engineering software for iOS, making quick work of standard force and motion problems.
The big advantage for software over hardware makers is that the software can be used across multiple platforms. 3-D printing may make sense for a prototype for a product, but if you want to make 50 units, then a company like Proto Labs may make more sense; it can use the exact same model used to make a 3-D printed product, making scaling a piece of cake.
CAD software is also very sticky. A designer is more likely to change the tools used to physically create a product than CAD software. Companies often define software with licenses while 3-D printing or molding tools are more open for change.
Foolish bottom line
The 3-D printing or rapid prototyping boom is certainly happening and investors should take notice. But I think 3D Systems, Stratasys, and ExOne are too expensive to jump into right now. They're all priced for perfection.
Autodesk is my top pick, simply because it has more staying power than others in the industry. If you're looking for a more manufacturing based play, then Proto Labs has the ability to rapidly prototype and has a software competitive advantage as well. But in both cases, it's all about the back end. A product can go from a designer's computer to a mold without a person touching it, creating its efficiencies and allowing for lower costs.
A deeper dive into 3D Systems
3D Systems is at the leading edge of a disruptive technological revolution, with the broadest portfolio of 3-D printers in the industry. However, despite years of earnings growth, 3D Systems' share price has risen even faster, and today the company sports a dizzying valuation. To help investors decide whether the future of additive manufacturing is bright enough to justify the lofty price tag on the company's shares, The Motley Fool has compiled a premium research report on whether 3D Systems is a buy right now. In our report, we take a close look at 3D Systems' opportunities, risks, and critical factors for growth. You'll also find reasons to buy or sell, and receive a full year of analyst updates with the report. To start reading, simply click here now for instant access.
The article The Best Investment in 3-D Printing originally appeared on Fool.com.
Fool contributor Travis Hoium has no position in any stocks mentioned. You can follow Travis on Twitter at @FlushDrawFool, check out his personal stock holdings or follow his CAPS picks at TMFFlushDraw. The Motley Fool recommends 3D Systems, Proto Labs, and Stratasys. The Motley Fool owns shares of 3D Systems and Stratasys and has the following options: Short Jan 2014 $55 Calls on 3D Systems and Short Jan 2014 $30 Puts on 3D Systems. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.