Investors Need to Run From this Value Trap
There are value stocks, and then there are stocks that simply act like value stocks. Take RadioShack (NYS: RSH) , for instance. The company is down 78% from its 52-week high, it's a household brand that everyone knows, and it has all sorts of assets that could be liquidated in a fire sale. That's the start of a great value play. But, as yesterday's earnings release highlighted, RadioShack isn't a value stock; it's a death trap.
Bad news stacked on bad news
The beginning of the fall is always in same-store sales. RadioShack had a 1.6% drop in comparable sales last quarter. Management said that one of the biggest problems for the stores was the delayed purchasing of the new iPhone. Last year, the iPhone came in at Q4, which meant that people who needed to upgrade in the middle of the year probably went ahead and did it. This year, the iPhone 5 came out in September, so mid-year upgraders may have held off. Either way, sales were disappointing.
The company is also losing money on its Target (NYS: TGT) arrangement. Under that plan, RadioShack manages the postpaid mobile sales in 1,500 Target locations. That means that RadioShack is selling low margin phones and missing out on accessory sales, one of its best categories. On its conference call, RadioShack said that it was trying to work out a new deal with Target, but that right now, it was planning on breaking off the deal in April of next year.
Finally, the combination of lower sales, shrinking margins, and poor relationships with Target resulted in a $0.47 loss per share. That's a huge decline from last year's break-even result, and EPS fell well short of the $0.16 that analysts had been expecting.
The market reaction was odd, to say the least. With an earnings miss, a failed plan in place, and no CEO at the helm, early trading slapped RadioShack on the hand, and shares fell 14% in early trading. Then -- and this is conjecture -- word got out that now RadioShack was an even better value play, and the shares rebounded by midday. I can think of no other explanation for the company surviving a horrible earnings report on a bad day for the market.
The rumor of value
Looking back, over the past week, RadioShack has outperformed the S&P 500 by almost 7%. A lot of that stability came from one line in the conference call. Interim CEO Dorvin Lively said, "We have total liquidity of $938 million, including the $546 million of unrestricted cash." That's a strong position, and the company looks like a great value play on paper.
Current assets are sitting at $1.9 billion, while total liabilities are only at $1.6 billion. Just using that rough math, the company is worth about $345 million, but its only valued at $250 million on the stock market. It's easy to see why investors could be excited about RadioShack, just looking at the headliner numbers. But as Fitch Ratings has alluded to, the company is still in cash burning mode. The turnaround may be just ahead but, if it's not, then the company is just going to hemorrhage cash.
RadioShack is also facing the growing specter of irrelevancy. As companies like Amazon (NAS: AMZN) and Best Buy (NYS: BBY) diversify offerings, RadioShack's niche is disappearing. I can't remember the last time I talked to a person who raved about the selection and prices at RadioShack. Until the company gets some traction with customers, there's no reason to expect a turnaround.
The bottom line
There is one option that I haven't discussed yet, and it's more likely than some grand RadioShack renaissance - it's a buyout. RadioShack has a good(ish) brand, good locations, and a lot of potential. All of those combine to make for a nice private equity buyout target. I wouldn't be surprised if RadioShack went on the auction block and promptly sold out over the next year. That could be a great return for investors, if it happens soon enough. If, however, the company languishes over a few quarters, and spends the cash they have on hand, I can't imagine the buyout price would be at all rewarding.
To get your hands on some real value, check out the Motely Fool's report on The Stocks Only the Smartest Investors Are Buying. These aren't the stocks you find dumpster diving, these are pedigree stocks that Wall Street has overlooked due to their smaller size. You can get all the details for free in this report just for Fool readers. Click here to get your copy today.
The article Investors Need to Run From this Value Trap originally appeared on Fool.com.Fool contributor Andrew Marder has no positions in the stocks mentioned above. The Motley Fool owns shares of Amazon.com, Best Buy, and RadioShack and is short RadioShack. Motley Fool newsletter services recommend Amazon.com and Best Buy. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.