Plan to Build Home on Top of Historic Heard Cemetery in Sandy Springs, Ga., Enrages Neighbors

Heard family cemetery Sandy Springs Georgia

A real estate attorney's plans to build a home on top of a cemetery in Sandy Springs, Ga., that dates back to the 1800s has neighbors outraged and fearful that the property's historic value is in jeopardy.

"It was meant to be left like this," Gloria Taylor, who lives near the tree-lined 19th century site, told CBS Atlanta News. "When it's gone, you can't get it back. ... It's gone permanently, and that's a shame."

According to a deed dated 1900 (pictured at left), the one-acre cemetery for the Heard family, one of the founding families of Sandy Springs, was created by Judge John Heard. The document reportedly indicates that Heard intended for the property to remain a cemetery for himself and his family. But Fulton County, Ga., officials repossessed the property years ago after filing a lien against it for unpaid taxes. That should have never happened, neighbors insist, because cemeteries are exempt from property taxes. Court documents show that the county sold the property on the courthouse steps to real estate attorney Christopher Mills for $1.

When Mills filed for a building permit to construct his family home on the cemetery, the city of Sandy Springs denied it, recognizing the historic significance of the site. Mills is now suing the city for the right to build there.

Mills has declined to comment to the media about the case.

13 Historic Homes in the 13 Original Colonies
See Gallery
Plan to Build Home on Top of Historic Heard Cemetery in Sandy Springs, Ga., Enrages Neighbors

240 Prince George St., Urbanna, Va.
Built: 1742
For sale: $495,000

Virginia claims the honor as the first colony and the site of the first successful English settlement. This Urbanna home was built as a tavern more than 100 years after the colony was established. Urbanna was once a significant seaport, and this tavern hosted a number of passing dignitaries, including founding father Patrick Henry, who famously declared “Give me liberty or give me death!”

See the listing for more details.

See more homes for sale in Urbanna, Va.

138 Baker Ave., Concord, Mass.
Built: 1707
For sale: $985,000

The home of Plymouth Rock and the Pilgrims’ Plymouth Colony, Massachusetts held some of the earliest European settlements. This home -- the Hosmer Homestead -- is located in Concord, one of the sites of the Revolutionary War’s first battle in 1775. Undoubtedly the residents of the Hosmer Homestead were witnesses to the battle and “the shot heard ’round the world.”

See more homes for sale in Concord, Mass.

130 Old College Road, Andover, N.H.
For sale: $2,850,000
Built: 1781

Although a separate colony, New Hampshire was joined to Massachusetts and ruled by one governor for many years leading up to the Revolutionary War. This small state was significant in moving the U.S. toward constitutional government; as the ninth state to ratify it, its vote put the Constitution into effect. This 18th-century farm is one of many historic properties in the neighborhood of Taunton Hill in Andover and is a restored Federal style building.

See the listing for more details.

See more homes for sale in Andover, N.H.

3251 Gamber Road, Finksburg, Md.
For sale: $2,889,000
Built: 1765

As royal colonies under the British empire, governors of each colony were established by the king. This home in Finksburg was built for one of Maryland’s first royal governors. The stone home sits on 45 untouched acres northeast of Baltimore.

See the listing for more details.

See more homes for sale in Finksburg, Md.

6 Parker Lane, Essex, Conn.
For sale: $5,500,000
Built: 1750

Originally known as River Colony, Connecticut was another colony primarily established by Puritans. This Essex property for sale contains not just one 18th-century home but three separate houses joined together by an expansive lawn.

See the listing for more details.

See more homes for sale in Essex, Conn.

27 Byfield St., Bristol, R.I.
For sale: $545,000
Built: 1790

The smallest of the U.S. states was also one of the first colonies to declare itself independent from British rule. The small but mighty state is home to this Cape Cod-style home with two bedrooms, two bathrooms and attached garage.

See the listing for more details.

See more homes for sale in Bristol, R.I.

502 Pilottown Road, Lewes, Del.
For sale: $995,000
Built: 1786

Delaware was not only one of the 13 colonies but was also the first state to ratify the U.S. Constitution. This clapboard-shingled house for sale in “The First State” sits across the street from the water and has four bedrooms and 2.5 baths in 3,000 square feet of living space.

See the listing for more details.

See more homes for sale in Lewes, Del.

207 E. Water St., Edenton, N.C.
For sale: $929,000
Built: 1775

North Carolina was colonized primarily by Virginians steadily moving southward. This Edenton home for sale is one of the oldest in the area. The updated home has water views from its double porches and bay-facing windows.

See the listing for more details.

See more homes for sale in Edenton, N.C.

32 S. Battery St., Charleston, S.C.
For sale: $8,985,000
Built: 1780

Following North Carolina’s colonization, explorers migrated farther south along the East Coast, colonizing South Carolina in 1663. This four-story home in Charleston sits in a historically significant area with views of Charleston Harbor.

See the listing for more details.

See more homes for sale in Charleston, S.C.

166 Cherry Hill Road, Princeton, N.J.
For sale: $7,975,500
Built: 1773

Fifty-six men signed the Declaration of Independence — some well known, some not quite as recognizable. While you can’t buy Thomas Jefferson’s home, another residence owned by a Declaration signer, the Rev. John Witherspoon, is for sale in New Jersey. The Princeton home was built for him and was completely restored and enlarged by its present owners in 1998.

See the listing for more details.

See more homes for sale in Princeton, N.J.

838 Route 9d, Garrison, N.Y.
For sale: $4,950,000
Built: 1750

New York was the site of nearly a third of the Revolutionary War battles. Situated across the Hudson River from the West Point Military Academy, Garrison is home to this barn-turned-modern estate. The 18th-century barn sits on nearly 8 acres of land surrounded by conservation easements.

See the listing for more details.

See more homes for sale in Garrison, N.Y.

217 Spruce St., Philadelphia
For sale: $1,695,000
Built: 1758

William Penn, Pennsylvania’s namesake, received land from King Charles II to settle a debt in 1681 and immediately sailed to the New World to set up his colony. Continuing along the historic thread, this townhouse in Philadelphia is also historically significant, as it was first owned by Maj. David Lenox, who fought in the Revolutionary War.

See the listing for more details.

See more homes for sale in Philadelphia.

900 N. Cave Spring St., Cedartown, Ga.
For sale: $575,000
Built: 1800

The last colony was founded some 50 years after the other 12 by James Oglethorpe, a prison reformer who wanted to ease crowded British prisons with new ones in the colonies. This home for sale in Cedartown is nothing close to a prison. The elegant plantation-style four-bedroom, three-bath home has formal dining and drawing rooms.

See the listing for more details.

See more homes for sale in Cedartown, Ga.


"You can't build a house on this property -- I don't care how careful you are -- without destroying the ambiance and integrity of the site," Taylor told Atlanta TV station FOX 5.

There's another reason the Heard family cemetery is so important to locals: It played an important role in the Civil War. It's the spot where Union soldiers first crossed the Chattahoochee River.

"There's a historical marker here that shows ... this whole ridge was used as a strategic point in the Civil War," Sandy Springs resident Rachel Rosner told CBS Atlanta. "Not only is it just this beautiful, peaceful, thinking spot. ... I would hate to see this destroyed."

Neighbors want so badly to save the cemetery from Mills' plans that they've even reached out to living descendants of John Heard to bolster their case, according to the Sandy Springs Reporter.

Preston Heard, who says he is a direct descendant of John Heard, told the newspaper that he is considering joining legal action against Mills.

"I do think it's at least curious that this guy would want to build on land against the clear wishes of the neighbors," Preston Heard said. "That means more to me than the family heritage aspect. I don't know if that's how my siblings and family would feel."

For historic preservationist Clark Otten, saving the cemetery is of the utmost importance.

"I think it's an extremely important site that needs preservation," Otten told FOX 5.

The Sandy Springs battle joins a number of disputes over preserving historic sites and landmarks in the news recently. The Institute for Advanced Study in Princeton, N.J., raised the ire of preservationists when it introduced plans to build faculty housing on the site of the Battle of Princeton in 1777. And in Phoenix, conservationists are trying to stop a developer from tearing down an original Frank Lloyd Wright home.

UPDATE, Oct. 8 -- Rosner tells AOL Real Estate that neighbors have set up a group called Friends of the Heard Cemetery with a Facebook page and a PayPal account where people can make donations toward preserving the cemetery. Rosner said it will cost at least $5,000 to pay for the legal fees associated with protecting the cemetery.

CBS Atlanta 46

More on AOL
Real Estate:
Find out how to
calculate mortgage payments.
homes for sale in your area.
foreclosures in your area.
Find homes for rent in your area.

Follow us on Twitter at @AOLRealEstate or connect with AOL Real Estate on Facebook.
Read Full Story

Find a home

Powered by Zillow