Aug, 27 may turn out to be a landmark day for Best Buy (NYS: BBY) in general, and more importantly Best Buy shareholders in particular. Despite all that's happened in the recent past -- the claims and counterclaims between Best Buy management and company founder Richard Schulze -- the first steps for a change in management are in the works.
A quick recap
The article we posted on Aug. 22 discussing the four reasons Best Buy share prices would decline even further didn't paint a pretty picture. First, the electronics retailer had just announced an absolutely horrendous quarter. Adding to the problems facing Best Buy was the timing of new CEO Hubert Joly's appointment; it was a disaster.
Then there was the ending to the much-ballyhooed butting of heads between Best Buy Schulze and current management. Shareholders were left without a much-needed white knight, or so we thought.
Best Buy's press release announcing full access for Schulze to conduct due diligence, with the intention of securing adequate financing for a takeover, includes a few provisions worth noting. Effective immediately, Schulze and his advisors have 60 days to review non-public information. At the end of that time frame, a fully financed buyout proposal must be provided to existing Best Buy management. If that doesn't happen, Schulze will need to wait until January to give it another go.
The agreement also stipulates a waiver of Minnesota law allowing the due-diligence review before securing adequate financing. You'll recall this was a sticking point the last go-around between the two parties. For Schulze, this is a no-lose proposition. Assuming he follows the agreed-upon procedures, he'll receive two voting seats on the existing eight-person Board of Directors, regardless of how the takeover bid ends up.
Desperate times call for desperate measures
After all that's happened, inviting Schulze back into the picture amounts to having the board say "what else can we do?" And if the trading activity on Aug. 27 is any indication, shareholders agree. But the 3.24% jump in Best Buy's share price on Monday, not to mention the likelihood of another buying spree or two before it's all said and done, is a short-term situation.
The fundamental problems haven't changed, nor will they with Schulze at the helm. Online electronic retailers such as Amazon.com (NAS: AMZN) will continue to eat away at market share. Even as Best Buy's same-store-sales results dropped 3.7% across all markets, and "only" 1.6% domestically, Amazon continues to grow. Amazon's 29% growth in global sales in Q2 was bolstered by a 36% jump in sales across North America.
And even traditional retailers -- including Wal-Mart (NYS: WMT) and Target (NYS: TGT) -- offer more diversified product lines and stronger financials than Best Buy. Wal-Mart's most recent earnings was punctuated by an 8.3% jump in earnings versus Q2 of 2011, and same-store sales increased more than 2%. The Q2 story over at Target is similar to Wal-Mart's -- an earnings improvement versus last year and raised guidance for the balance of 2012.
Whether you compare it with online or traditional big-box stores, it seems everyone is outperforming Best Buy. And that's why the Board of Directors is swallowing its pride -- bitter as it may be -- and inviting the family black sheep back to the party.
Though an act of desperation, Best Buy's reversal allowing Schulze a peek under the financial covers is the right one. But for long-term investors, the fundamental problems at Best Buy haven't changed. It remains a troubled electronics retailer with short-term upside, and that's based solely on takeover talk -- a scary proposition at best.
Amazon poses a significant threat to Best Buy and other traditional retailers. For investors, the online leader offers some unique opportunities. For a new perspective, take a look at this premium report for a comprehensive analysis of Amazon's investment potential. The report not only offers analysis from one of The Motley Fool's top analysts, but it also comes with a year of free updates. So get started today!
The article Best Buy's Act of Desperation originally appeared on Fool.com.
Fool contributor Tim Brugger currently holds no securities positions, including any mentioned in this article. The Motley Fool owns shares of Amazon.com. Motley Fool newsletter services have recommended buying shares of Amazon.com. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.
Copyright © 1995 - 2012 The Motley Fool, LLC. All rights reserved. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.