Did Occupy Wall Street Really Change Anything?

Occupy Wall Street

Since Occupy Wall Street first set up camp in Zuccotti Park one year ago, it has helped to raise class consciousness among "the 99%" and given that silent majority a sense of empowerment.
But a recent report out of SNL Financial (not to be confused with Saturday Night Live) suggests the Occupy movement hasn't changed consumer behavior much at all.

Since OWS got off the ground, the Dow Jones Industrial Average (^DJI) has gained 14%, America's banks are bigger than ever, and just last month the owners of Hawker Beechcraft announced a plan to sell their company to China, dump their pension obligations on the federal government ... and give themselves $5.3 million in bonuses.

But what about average Americans?

A Small Victory

OWS's one real victory to date took place on Nov. 5, 2011 -- "Bank Transfer Day."

Touted as a call for consumers to move their checking and savings accounts to small banks and not-for-profit credit unions, ditching commercial megabanks like Wells Fargo (WFC) and JPMorgan Chase (JPM) en masse, Bank Transfer Day, or BTD, seemed by some measures a resounding success:
  • It was credited with helping to force Bank of America (BAC) to ditch its plan to impose a $5 monthly fee on debit card users.
  • A Facebook page dedicated to the movement generated 58,153 "likes."
  • According to the Credit Union National Association, or CUNA, some 40,000 consumers opened new accounts at credit unions on November 5, 2011 -- a rate at least 18 times above normal.
  • Over the course of five weeks leading up to BTD, CUNA says American depositors moved $4.5 billion from big banks to credit unions.
But did BTD inspire people to shift their money over to credit unions? Or was BTD itself part of a larger shift from big banks to smaller banks? SNL Financial suggests the latter.

The real economy is at homeWhich Came First: The Chicken or the Nest Egg?

According to SNL's report, released last week, credit unions were benefiting from a widespread shift away from big banks "long before populist rhetoric over bank fees crescendoed into BTD." Indeed, as early as 2009, SNL data show deposit growth at credit unions beginning to outpace that at banks.

According to CUNA, the 2008 financial crisis caused many depositors to lose confidence in banks in general. Meanwhile, CUNA notes that after the crisis, many banks began cutting the interest rates they paid depositors -- after all, why pay good rates to depositors when the Fed was practically giving away loans for free.

CUNA says that as big banks' interest rates plummeted, "deposit rates at credit unions remained consumer-friendly."

Sponsored Links
Curiously, even as depositors fled "Big Banking," they still sought safety in numbers. SNL data note that Boeing Employees Credit Union, based in Tukwila, Wash., is the fourth-largest credit union in the U.S., while State Employees' Credit Union is the second-largest. Deposits at BECU in Raleigh, N.C., grew 9.7% between 2007 and 2009 (when the crisis began). Meanwhile, SECU saw deposit growth of 32.8%. No. 1 credit union Navy Federal took in an extra 18.6% between 2007 and 2009. More recently, 2011 numbers show all three of these "mega-credit unions" outpacing the rate of deposit growth of credit unions at large.

CUNA suggests one reason larger credit unions are growing faster than smaller credit unions could be the fact that the bigger institutions offer more physical locations and greater convenience for customers.

But what about Occupy's call to abandon "banks?"

Bigger Is Still Better

To the extent that customers are leaving big banks behind and moving to credit unions, it appears the primary motivator is simple fear over the financial soundness of the banks and a perception that money is safer in a credit union (which, all else being equal, is probably not an unreasonable theory, inasmuch as a credit union is unlikely to have significant exposure to European government debt derivatives or use customer money to do a lot of proprietary trading for its own account).

But no matter how "global" their thinking is, it appears consumers aren't really enthusiastic about "acting locally" and moving their business to smaller institutions. To the contrary, the factors named above -- better rates on deposits, and better convenience through larger size -- appear just as popular as ever, regardless of whether they're found at banks or at credit unions.

Pop Quiz: American Opportunity
See Gallery
Did Occupy Wall Street Really Change Anything?

A. 20%
B. 13%
C. 7%
D. 1%

What percentage of Americans expect to become millionaires within the next 10 years?


According to an AP/CNBC poll conducted in 2011, two in 10 Americans think that they will become millionaires within the next 10 years.

A. 15%
B. 11%
C. 7%
D. 1%

What percentage of Americans are millionaires?


According to the Capgemini/RBC 2012 World Wealth Report, the U.S. currently has 3.07 million people with liquid assets of $1 million or more. That number has dropped by 1.2% since 2010, but America still has more millionaires than any other country in the world.

A. 67%
B. 30%
C. 21%
D. 10%

Adjusting for real value, how much has the minimum wage increased since 1990?



On the surface, it would appear that the minimum wage has almost doubled since 1990, going from $3.80 to $7.25. In terms of real value, however, it has only gone up by 21%. Today, 18 states -- and the District of Columbia -- have minimum wages that exceed the national standard.

A. 67%
B. 30%
C. 21%
D. 10%

How much has the cost of living increased since 1990?


While the real value of the minimum wage has increased by 21% in the last 22 years, the actual cost of living has gone up more than three times as much.

A. United States
B. Germany
C. France
D. Canada

Which country has the least economic mobility?

The United States

According to several recent studies, America lags behind much of the industrialized world when it comes to income mobility across generations. A report from the Brookings Institute stated that Canada's economic mobility is 2.5 times that of the U.S.

A. They rose by 11%
B. They rose by 3%
C. They dropped by 7%
D. They dropped by 12%

Between 1974 and 2004, what happened to the median incomes of 30-year-old men?

They dropped by 12%

Between 1974 and 2004, median personal income for men in their thirties fell from $40,000 to $35,000.

A. It stayed even
B. It increased by 50%
C. It increased by 70%
D. It increased by 150%

What happened to the economy between 1974 and 2004?

It increased by 150%

From 1974 to 2004, while median personal income for men was dropping, the economy was soaring. Gross domestic product during that period increased by 150%.

With more millionaires than any other country in the world, it's hard to deny that America is the land of opportunity. But, while the U.S. economy has vastly expanded in recent decades, the proceeds from that explosive growth have landed in the hands of a comparatively small portion of the populace. At the same time, low wages and a high cost of living are making it much harder for people to move from the bottom of the economic ladder to the top -- or even the middle.


Motley Fool contributor Rich Smith holds no position in any company mentioned. The Motley Fool owns shares of Bank of America and JPMorgan Chase. Motley Fool newsletter services have recommended buying shares of Wells Fargo. Motley Fool newsletter services formerly recommended JPMorgan Chase.

Read Full Story