The Market Has Reservations About OpenTable
The restaurant-booking-website sector is beginning to flesh out a bit, and it looks as if it might be having an impact on OpenTable's (NAS: OPEN) business.
It's been three years since the company went public, and only a little over a year ago since the stock enjoyed a nearly $115 high a few months after spending a cool $55 million on European rival Toptable. Since then, it's been a slow and steady decline to the current $37 value as investors lose faith in the company. It's looking like OpenTable is suffering from stymied growth, while the specter of new competition curbs investor enthusiasm.
After its IPO, OpenTable quickly became the leader in the online restaurant-booking space. This led to some discontent among restaurateurs, who found the service useful but pricey. Soon, competitor Urbanspoon, owned by IAC/InterActiveCorp. (NYS: IACI) offered an iPad app named RezBook, a very similar table management system that cost clients only $99 per month, compared with the $199 charged by OpenTable , who also charges eateries for their software.
Now, Scripps Networks Interactive (NYS: SNI) is launching its own offering, called CityEats. The parent company of the Food Network is undercutting OpenTable as well, charging $175 to $200 per month but collecting only $0.75 per registered diner, versus the $1 that Urbanspoon and OpenTable charge. The new service isn't signing up anywhere near the estimated 17,000 North American eateries that OpenTable has on its roster, but the company claims that it's not concerned, and plans to expand to markets in San Francisco and New York soon. Currently, the service is available only in Washington, D.C., and Philadelphia.
Google and Yelp are also seen as threats
As if that's not enough, investors are worried about competition that hasn't even occurred yet. The two entities seen as the biggest threats, due to their familiarity with consumers and market compatibility, are Yelp (NAS: YELP) and Zagat, recently purchased by Google (NAS: GOOG) .
Zagat, famous for its restaurant reviews and recommendations, could easily segue into the reservations market if Google decides it would be in its interest to do so. The same goes for Yelp, which currently partners with OpenTable to facilitate customer reservations from Yelp's website. It certainly wouldn't be a stretch for Yelp to add a reservation component to its offerings, cutting out OpenTable completely and trimming its customer base.
It's never a good idea to borrow trouble, but concerns about Google and Yelp are certainly well-placed. There is no doubt that OpenTable is still the dominant player here, but the business has been slow to grow, which always worries investors. Toptable has been a bit of a disappointment as well, and it appears to be dragging the company down rather than boosting it, even after 18 months. While it's true that the company's recent first-quarter report contained some good news along with the bad, there is definitely a disquieting tendency toward stagnation, or even backpedaling on gains. When the company released its much-rosier fourth-quarter report earlier in the year, it also took the opportunity to cut its EPS estimates for the next two years. What are investors to think?
Currently, only about 12% of diners use the Internet to book reservations, indicating a virtually untapped market. If OpenTable can't grow itself with that potential and minimal competition, what will happen if more, well-established entities enter the fray? If the company maintains this course, it is only a matter of time before its table becomes empty.
There are some real growth-oriented companies out there disrupting traditional industries, and they're being rewarded with big profits. The Fool recently issued a research report detailing two specific companies that are changing the face of retail, which we've made free to our readers. Click here to access our free report today.
At the time this article was published Fool contributor Amanda Alix owns no shares in the companies mentioned above.The Motley Fool owns shares of Google and OpenTable. Motley Fool newsletter services have recommended buying shares of Google, Scripps Networks Interactive, and OpenTable. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days.
Copyright © 1995 - 2012 The Motley Fool, LLC. All rights reserved. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.