Gold vs. Miners: Which Is Better?

In the past year, SPDR Gold Shares (NYS: GLD) has returned 9.2%, while the Market Vectors Gold ETF (NYS: GDX) has dropped 23.4%. The former is the largest physically backed gold ETF in the world, and the latter is the largest gold miners ETF, according to MarketWatch.

The difference in performance has been duly noted by both analysts and investors, and any bullish projection on the miners would be considered intrepid. Street One Financial President Scott Freeze has made that decision though, saying, "If you look at miners on a historical basis, they go through periods of lagging gold futures and then a period of substantial outperformance. We've seen capitulation with the miners, we've already been there. Since the miners have already been lagging, they offer more upside than downside now compared to a fund like GLD."

He also states that inflation could explode sometime over the next 15 months because of the previous rounds of quantitative easing from the Federal Reserve, so gold is positioned to outperform even other precious metals.

Business section: Investing ideas
If the inflationary environment that Freeze believes becomes reality, will gold or miners outperform? Below is a list of gold mining and exploration stocks that have seen institutional purchases over the current quarter. Do you think the metal or the companies are better investments?

List sorted by market cap. (Click here to access free, interactive tools to analyze these ideas.)

1. Yamana Gold (NYS: AUY) : Engages in gold and other precious metals mining, and related activities, including exploration, extraction, processing, and reclamation. It has a market cap of $10.8 billion. Net institutional purchases in the current quarter stand at 23.5 million shares, which represents about 3.16% of the company's float of 742.77 million shares.

2. Allied Nevada Gold (NYS: ANV) : Engages in the evaluation, acquisition, exploration, and advancement of gold exploration and development projects in the state of Nevada. It has a market cap of $2.63 billion. Net institutional purchases in the current quarter stand at 3.2 million shares, which represents about 3.92% of the company's float of 81.58 million shares.

3. NovaGold Resources (NYS: NG) : Engages in the exploration and development of mineral properties primarily in North America. It has a market cap of $1.47 billion. Net institutional purchases in the current quarter stand at 12.2 million shares, which represents about 7.5% of the company's float of 162.64 million shares.

Interactive Chart: Press Play to compare changes in analyst ratings over the last two years for the stocks mentioned above. Analyst ratings sourced from Zacks Investment Research.

At the time thisarticle was published Kapitall's Danny Guttridge does not own any of the shares mentioned above. Institutional data sourced from Fidelity.Motley Fool newsletter serviceshave recommended buying shares of Market Vectors Gold Miners ETF. The Motley Fool has adisclosure policy. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe thatconsidering a diverse range of insightsmakes us better investors. Try any of our Foolish newsletter servicesfree for 30 days.

Copyright © 1995 - 2012 The Motley Fool, LLC. All rights reserved. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.