How Much Does Netflix Love DVD Rentals?

Stop the presses! Netflix (NAS: NFLX) just introduced a DVD-only plan! Sign up now, get a one-month free trial.

"Starting today, our DVD and Blu-ray loving audience can now easily sign up for a DVD only plan," blares a brand new official Netflix blog post. The key word here is "easy."

So, uh ... what's changed?
OK. This is only news if you had noticed that DVD-only signups haven't been available for a while. The new thing here is that Netflix once again makes it easy to sign up for a DVD-only trial. The fewer-clicks signup process went AWOL somewhere around the unpopular split between DVD and streaming plans, or perhaps the introduction of Qwikster.

This does not in any way diminish Netflix's desire to remove DVD rentals from the business mix. The default page for free trials still offers only a one-month streaming pass. There is no mention of DVD or Blu-ray products on that page. You need to enter a new address to get to the DVD deal.

Some observers are up in arms about this new emphasis on a streaming business that barely breaks even while DVD shipments carry the bulk of Netflix's profits. These are often the same people who complain that Netflix invests in expensive streaming license deals. Both complaints come down to a misunderstanding of fixed versus variable costs.

Running the numbers
The DVD business is simple enough to understand: buy discs, pay for stamps and a mostly automated handling process, reap the difference between these costs and the monthly $8 fees per single-disc customer. Add more customers, you also add more shipping costs and need to buy more DVDs. Margins here are pretty stable.

Not so in the streaming world. There's no shipping and handling. One digital copy from the studio is enough to seed the entire Netflix network. Because Hollywood is so used to negotiating content licenses with predictable cable and satellite broadcasters, nearly every license Netflix signs is a fixed cost. The company doesn't pay a single penny more to Walt Disney (NYS: DIS) or Lions Gate Entertainment (NYS: LGF) if you watch Tangled or The Expendables a million times (though your friends and family may question your sanity). Neither does Netflix get a break on license fees if a title on contract turns out to be a massive flop.

In this environment, the finances work out very differently. To cover the cost of expensive content, Netflix needs a lot of subscribers. Once the costs of content have been covered, every new subscriber is nearly pure profit. In DVD shipments, the costs of doing business will rise and fall with subscriber counts. In streaming, they are set when the company signs content deals. And right now, Netflix has enough domestic subscribers to stay about 11% above the content bets it made a couple of years ago.

Taking the boot off the customer-base accelerator at this point is tantamount to suicide. Firm content commitments of $3.9 billion are waiting to jump onto the balance sheet in the next couple of years. Those costs will be accounted for on coming income statements. Netflix is betting that this massive influx of more expensive -- and presumably more attractive -- content will keep subscribers coming back for more.

This is the same logic that makes Sirius XM (NAS: SIRI) pay Howard Stern $500 million for five years of talk-radio service. With that cost set in stone, Sirius must then leverage that investment to sign up new subscribers -- hopefully enough of them to make Howard worth his while. Stern doesn't get paid a higher fee if Sirius snags another 5 million subscribers.

Or you can kick this model right back to Hollywood: Disney makes a movie to create a solid fixed cost. Then it's up to marketing and product quality to make the darn thing profitable -- actors and special-effects houses won't return their paychecks just because Cars 5 fails at the box office. It doesn't make sense to make expensive movies and then leave them without promotion support.

Makes sense now, boss
So that's why Netflix is so dead-set on becoming a pure streaming company. The DVD business already contributes less revenue to the total business than the domestic streaming operation, and that imbalance will only tip further as the international expansion gains traction.

Every subscriber here puts about $8 toward paying off the license deals while an $8 DVD subscriber puts only $4 in that bucket. I'd ask for more of the $8 payers, too. Expect an increasingly half-hearted effort to keep the DVD business alive. Ideally, the entire DVD catalog would eventually be available for streaming. Realistically, the DVD library will fill a niche role for customers with offbeat or fresh tastes for years to come -- but that's all.

Starting 2012 with a market-beating 75% climb, Netflix is off to a great start in the new year. That's impressive, but Foolish analysts have found an even more promising stock for your portfolio. Learn all about The Motley Fool's Top Stock for 2012 in a special report -- free for a limited time.

At the time thisarticle was published Fool contributorAnders Bylundowns shares of Netflix but holds no other position in any of the companies mentioned.Motley Fool newsletter serviceshave recommended buying shares of Walt Disney and Netflix. Try any of our Foolish newsletter servicesfree for 30 days. We Fools don't all hold the same opinion, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. Check outAnders' holdings and bio, or follow him onTwitterandGoogle+. Ourdisclosure policywonders why people worry so much about delayed rental releases. Movies you want to see quickly surely passed through your local theater at some point.

Copyright © 1995 - 2012 The Motley Fool, LLC. All rights reserved. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.