U.S. Natural Gas Kills Coal

Aimee Duffy, The Motley Fool
Updated

The booming production of U.S. natural gas has depressed prices, making the commodity more appealing for consumers looking to heat their homes. But it has also begun to significantly impact other industries, and combined with federal regulations, it may sound the death knell for the future of coal in this country.

Power generation
Coal simply doesn't burn as cleanly, producing twice as much carbon dioxide, four times as many nitrogen oxides, and nearly 13 times the sulfur dioxide per megawatt hour than natural gas.

The federal government's effort to reduce emissions through air pollution regulations means power generators are starting to open up to alternative fuels. Indeed, coal's share of the electricity-generating pie has already begun to decline, from 51% net electricity generation in 2003 to 43% through the first three quarters of this year. Natural gas's share is up to 25% from 17% over the same time period.

By 2016, there is potential that 10% to 20% of coal-fired generating capacity will be shut down. Changes have already begun to litter headlines across the U.S.:

  • Oct. 17 -- Ohio: Proposed refinery changes original plan to fuel operations with natural gas instead of coal.

  • Nov. 10 -- Texas: Lower Colorado River Authority receives EPA permit to modernize a power plant to run on natural gas.

  • Dec. 2 -- Michigan: Consumers Energy plans to shut down some units and cancels plan for new low-emission coal plant.

American Electric Power (NYSE: AEP) , the nation's biggest coal user, expects consumption to drop by 17 million tons over the next three years. Other major utilities like Southern (NYSE: SO) , Progress Energy (NYSE: PGN) , Ameren (NYSE: AEE) , and Xcel Energy (NYSE: XEL) also plan to retire coal-fired operations.

As coal plants shut down, companies are thinking differently about what type of plants they bring online. Duke Energy (NYSE: DUK) is building four new power plants: Two will burn natural gas, one will first convert coal to a cleaner gas, and one will burn traditional coal.

It is no wonder, then, that coal stocks got crushed this year. Peabody Energy (NYSE: BTU) , Consol Energy (NYSE: CNX) , and Arch Coal (NYSE: ACI) all suffered terrible losses:


anImage
anImage

Peabody Energy Corporation Stock Chart by YCharts

Domestically, the days of coal-generated power are slowly coming to an end.

The world outside of coal
The coal industry is not the only one that natural gas production has begun to affect. The chemical industry is a big winner here, as many components of natural gas can be processed to make chemicals, plastics, and fertilizer.

Royal Dutch Shell (NYSE: RDS-A) is planning to build an ethylene plant near the Marcellus Shale to take advantage of natural gas supplies there. Dow Chemical (NYSE: DOW) plans to invest $4 billion over the next six years building two new plants on the Gulf Coast and upgrading other facilities.

Natural gas is also creating new opportunities for steel manufacturers. Nucor (NYSE: NUE) is building a $750 million plant in Louisiana that makes iron out of natural gas and iron-ore pellets. The low cost of natural gas makes the whole project possible.

Foolish bottom line
Natural gas has the ability to disrupt many sectors of the American economy, from manufacturing to power generation. As regulations continue to roll out of Washington, it will be important for investors to think about how they affect companies beyond oil and gas exploration and production outfits.

If you're looking for a stock to tap into the growing natural gas boom, click here for our free report, "The Only Energy Stock You'll Ever Need."

Advertisement