Why Gas Prices Rise Quickly but Fall Slowly
This phenomenon has held true for decades, and recent price trends have been no exception. On Thursday, the retail price for regular unleaded averaged $3.52 per gallon in the U.S., up a massive 37 cents in just one month -- and a whopping 60 cents, or 20%, since December. Several different factors have contributed to this trend.
Here's an example: If the price of oil increases $5 a barrel, it will typically cost an additional 10 to 12 cents per gallon -- in wholesale prices -- for the retailer's next delivery. Gas station operators know this, and often will immediately increase the pump price of gasoline 10 to 12 cents in response. When they do this, retailers are essentially basing their prices on the cost of replacing the gasoline that's being used, rather than on the price they originally paid for that gas, to help even out their cash flow.
Smoothing the Cash Flow
The opposite happens when gas prices are dropping, leading to slower decreases as gas station operators hold off on lowering their prices in order to cover the earlier costs of buying more expensive gas. Here's a simplified version of what happens (excluding taxes and the cost of environmental regulations that also affect gas prices): Say you're a gas station owner who buys 10,000 gallons of regular unleaded gasoline -- a month's worth -- at Wednesday's wholesale price of $2.85 per gallon. Your bill comes to $28,500.
Imagine that you sell 9,000 gallons over the next three weeks, but then the price of oil drops, bringing the wholesale price for gas down 10 cents to $2.75 per gallon. You'll be able to buy your next 10,000 gallons at the lower price and cut your pump price by 10 cents per gallon as a result, but if you reduce your prices right away, you wouldn't cover the cost of the remaining 1,000 gallons of gasoline that you already bought at the higher price. Most likely, you'd wait until you'd sold those 1,000 gallons before cutting your price.
In this way, as retailers wait to cover the costs of the higher-priced gas still in their tanks, gas prices decline more slowly than they rise.
Other factors also play a role in this phenomenon, however. One of these can be considered either "profit maximization" or greed on the part of station operators, depending on your perspective.
Sometimes, even after a station has sold all of its expensive gas at that higher price ($2.85 per gallon in our scenario), it will keep pump prices high and pocket an extra 10-cent-per-gallon profit on the cheaper $2.75 per gallon gas. As station operators squeeze an extra dime, nickel or even pennies out of each gallon of cheaper gas, for as long as possible, that lengthens the amount of time it takes for pump prices to fall.
If stations are all inclined to keep prices high, what persuades them to cut them? Competition, of course. If an area contains multiple gas stations, all of which want to boost their market share, one or two will inevitably lower their prices by a penny or two (or more) in the hope of increasing sales. Others will respond by cutting their prices too, until the pump prices finally reflect the reductions in the wholesale price.
Gas stations equipped with convenience stores, which generally earn more money from store sales than gas sales, typically can afford to lower their prices first. Meanwhile, some stations keep their prices high for other reasons -- they might not have much competition, for instance, and might not be concerned about losing a few customers -- but in general, the rule of competition applies.
The Power of Customers
And that means that customers do, in fact, have an impact on prices. To start prices on their slow journey downward, you need to shop around.
That said, customers' control over prices is limited. The largest factor in gasoline's price is still the price of oil, which has remained above $60 per barrel for the last 20 months. Oil prices have been rising -- albeit with volatility -- since December 2008, when they hit a low of about $35 per barrel during the financial crisis.
Given the current global trends in oil supplies and demand, it appears that the best way to cut your gasoline bill for the foreseeable future is to drive less, such as by carpooling more, using mass transit or buying a more fuel-efficient vehicle.