The New Retail Reality: More Shoppers but Spending More Cautiously
The Commerce Department's retail and food services sales tally for October rose to $373.1 billion, up 7.3% from October 2009 and up 1.2% from September 2010. Excluding auto sales, totals were up 6% from the year-ago month, and retail-sales-only were up 7.7%. Both categories showed momentum going into the holiday season, with sales excluding autos up 0.4% from September 2010 totals and retailers up 1.3%.
The numbers bolster the optimism shown by retailers during the first week of third-quarter earnings reports, when department stores noted that increased traffic is making up for shoppers' tight budgets. The Commerce Department's tally is the most complete picture of retailing because it includes gasoline, food and auto sales, as well as the results of Walmart Stores (WMT), the world's largest retailer, which doesn't publicly report monthly sales.
Spending Is Picking Up Momemtum
"With four consecutive months of sales gains, retailers are happy to turn the page on the last three years and embrace a more optimistic future," said a statement by Sandy Kennedy, president of the Retail Industry Leaders Association, a trade group.
The numbers show the consumer is coming back, however cautiously. Experts have noted that starting in September, year-over-year comparisons are closer to apples and apples than they were in 2009, and that continued month-over-month growth shows spending is picking up strength heading into the all-important holiday shopping season.
"This continued momentum is good news for the industry, especially with Black Friday and Cyber Monday quickly approaching," Matthew Shay, president of the National Retail Federation, said in a statement. But like many industry observers, he sounded a note of caution: "While there is no question that consumer demand has improved, there are still questions about consumer confidence tied to high unemployment. We need to see improvement in key economic indicators to sustain any long-term growth."
Indeed, Lowe's (LOW), which reported net earnings increased 17.4% in the third quarter, also warned that consumer spending remains "sluggish," in the words of CEO Robert Niblock.
Discretionary Projects Are Still Small
The hardware chain reported comparable sales rose 1.9% in the quarter, thanks to increased traffic and higher average spending per transaction. But Niblock noted Lowe's customer surveys found that, while shoppers say about half their home-improvement projects go beyond just essential repairs, those discretionary projects are still small -- with most worth under $500. "The economic recovery continues to bounce along the bottom," said Niblock.
But many observers point out that some discretionary categories such as clothing stores (up 3.5% year-over-year) and food and drink establishments (up 4.3%) showed robust gains, which says shoppers are shaking off some of their fears of spending.
Many observers have previously highlighted the "new frugality" among consumers that has led many households to continue saving and paying down debt, rather than using credit to spend on big-ticket items. As long as unemployment remains high, that could turn into a longer-term condition.
"That lack of re-leverage underscores the lingering uncertainty on the part of the consumer," Sozzi says. "Until that tide turns, retail sales will be stuck in a 'new normal' rate of growth."