The Bullish and Bearish Cases for Stocks

The bull is a symbol of a rising stock market
The bull is a symbol of a rising stock market

The frustrating truth about technical analysis is that it requires interpretation. Ideally, a chart would shout "buy" or "sell" and could only be interpreted one way.

But as the saying goes, "If it were that easy, we'd all be millionaires."

The stock market is at an interesting juncture right now as an epic battle between Bulls and Bears has left the market volatile and range-bound since the "flash crash" in early May.

In essence, the Bearish fundamental-analysis case rests on the plentiful evidence that the U.S. economy is slowing: As the economy grinds down, corporate profits will suffer and thus so will stock valuations. Indeed, a number market observers have been suggesting that the market is setting up for a serious crash.

The Bullish case rests on much less abundant evidence that even as the economy slows, it won't slide into the widely feared "double-dip" recession.

Technical Analysis Looks Only at Charts

Technical analysts avoid debates about GDP, revenues and profit margins by looking only at charts. To technical analysts, all the important information is reflected in price and indicators. From this point of view, all the millions of investor opinions, convictions and data points are compressed into the market action as traders buy and sell stocks and options.

This makes a certain kind of sense, because the inputs of the U.S. economy and market are so numerous and complex that it is difficult to crunch them all into a coherent "story" about what the future holds. Everything from the yen-dollar currency trade to the price of crude oil to the percentage of S&P 500 corporations' profits that come from overseas sales bears on the economy and the market.

Just as the market crunches all this data and human emotion into price action, charts compress the market action into a visual display of price and indicators. Given the great economic uncertainty, it's unsurprising that the charts can be interpreted as Bullish or Bearish.

To show how this works, I've marked up two charts, one displaying the Bearish case and one with the Bullish case.

As many technical analysts have noted in the past few months, the Bearish case rests on a technical formation called "head and shoulders." I've indicated the left and right shoulders and the "head" -- the market top in late April-early May.

Technically, a head and shoulders is a topping pattern, meaning that it typically marks a major market top. In theory, now that price has formed the completing right shoulder, the market should fall significantly from here. This is basic technical evidence to support the Bearish "crash" scenario.

More Bearish Evidence: The Death Cross

But there is other Bearish evidence as well. The blue 50-day moving average line crossed below the red 200-day moving average, a Bearish signal known as "the death cross" because it shows that market momentum is declining.

Even more telling, price has fallen below the critical 200-day moving average level. Repeated attempts to regain that level have failed after a few days, a sign of weakness.

The market has also fallen under the shorter-term trend lines of the 50-day and 20-day moving averages -- more evidence of a market in decline. The range-bound trading since early May is thus seen as a period of what is known as distribution, another word for widespread selling by big players.

Key indicators are also signaling a weakened market. The moving average convergence-divergence (MACD) indicator has slipped below the neutral line, marking a bearish trend, and the stochastic has fallen from overbought to oversold, reflecting weakening demand for stocks.

There's Also a Little-Noticed Bullish Case

The Bullish case rests on a standard technical pattern that few commentators seem have discerned: a "reverse head and shoulders" in which the low point becomes the head and higher levels form the left and right shoulders.

While this reverse head and shoulders isn't very symmetrical, technical analysts refer to this type of action as a "complex" head and shoulders, in which choppy price action is resolved into a general pattern with these key characteristics: The "head" is lower than the left shoulder (previous low), and the right shoulder is higher than both the "head" and the left shoulder.

In other words, the "head" marks a definitive bottom, and the right shoulder is evidence of a new uptrend.

The classic definition of an uptrend is simple: higher highs and higher lows. Both are present in the chart. While Bears see a flat trading range, Bulls see a trading range with an upward bias.

Could Be Setting Up a Bullish Cross

Bulls concede that the moving average convergence-divergence (MACD) line is below the neutral level, but they note that it's flattening, which could be setting up a very bullish cross.

Even more telling for the Bulls is the positive divergence in MACD: even as price has traded up and down in a wide range, MACD is working its way higher. This is strong evidence of a market that is slowly working its way into a Bullish stance. While the stochastic has fallen into oversold levels, the lines have begun to rise, and there is some modest positive divergence.

Another source of technical evidence is the VIX or "fear index," which I have reported on several times this year.

Lastly, many observers use sentiment indicators to help identify trends. Right now, sentiment is generally bearish. Contrarians view that as bullish.

So is the market about to crash or is it setting up a new uptrend? There is evidence for both points of view, and every investor must weigh all the evidence and decide where the preponderance lies.